IS the ASSAULT on Mrs. YATES over?

[Frackal]

Well as I said in the pm to Ryan, I agree with him that she should not simply be executed and dropped into the back of a dumpster, YET. She does NEED to be studied, poked, pricked, discected, I don't give a fuck, because this is obviously a real issue that can again obviously cause many problems.

However, I hope however this bitch meets her end, she meets it horridly.

This is the simple fact:

IF SHE WAS SO FUCKING DEPRESSED, THEN SHE SHOULD HAVE KILLED HER MOTHAFUCKIN SELF, SINCE SHE CERTAINLY HAD THE MENTAL CAPACITY TO SLOWLY KILL 5 OTHERS INSTEAD. SHE IS A COWARD, AND NOT WORTHY OF ANYTHING OTHER THAN MENTAL DISCECTION AND SOON AFTER, DEATH.

And this is not thinking just with emotion, this is logically fair. She killed 5, she should die.

 

[Citruscide]

It's hard when you think of what would be best for the victims, or when you put yourself in the victim's shoes... it pisses me off too. But, killing off people that have mental (curable) disorders for murder, a crime that has the inherent elements of malice aforethought (planned out) ... doesn't make sense to me? IF... I stress... IF this lady was out of her goard, she shouldn't be put to death... maybe in a mental hospital for the rest of her life (which is worse than death, to me)...

There isn't a justification for crime... in fact the number of sucessful insanity defenses are less than .1 percent. Most people who claim they were insane try to cover it up... an insane person would walk into a bar, with a bloody ax, order a beer and watch a game... when asked why he is covered in blood, he would respond "I just hacked off my wife's head, now please, I'm trying to watch the game" -- they lack the capacity to know what they are doing is wrong...

C

 

[RyanH]

they lack the capacity to know what they are doing is wrong...

C

that' exactly right, and that's why she'll be found to be mentally insane.

 

[RyanH]

Well as I said in the pm to Ryan, I agree with him that she should not simply be executed and dropped into the back of a dumpster, YET. She does NEED to be studied, poked, pricked, discected, I don't give a fuck, because this is obviously a real issue that can again obviously cause many problems.

However, I hope however this bitch meets her end, she meets it horridly.

This is the simple fact:

IF SHE WAS SO FUCKING DEPRESSED, THEN SHE SHOULD HAVE KILLED HER MOTHAFUCKIN SELF, SINCE SHE CERTAINLY HAD THE MENTAL CAPACITY TO SLOWLY KILL 5 OTHERS INSTEAD. SHE IS A COWARD, AND NOT WORTHY OF ANYTHING OTHER THAN MENTAL DISCECTION AND SOON AFTER, DEATH.

And this is not thinking just with emotion, this is logically fair. She killed 5, she should die.

And Frackal, what do we do when this tragic circumstances lurks its ugly head again.....again, and again. Ultimately we're going to have to deal with the problem instead of the effect.....the question is how many mentally troubled women will we slaughter before we finally ask...."why are they doing what they do?'

 

[strongchick]

For all you folks that advocate capital punishment in this case, what would you do to prevent another post partum murder?

If you think the lethal injection is the answer, you are 'dead' wrong.

Knee-jerk capital punishment only serves to allow us to ignore prevention mechanisms.

Those that think a mother suffering from this condition is going to think "no, I won't do it cuz the punishment for getting caught is death", sound naive.

 

[RyanH]

WOW!!!!!



you really are a cookie cutter liberal!!!

do they make you in a factory?

with enlarged rectums, and mouths on the new and improved hollywood model?


seriuosly, I am pretty liberally leaning.......but your just plain wrong on this dude.....

not everything is a case for the establishemnt of some sort of legal precident that will effect all other laws you know.

save the dramatasicm for more "gray" area cases...this ones pretth black and white

O

Who said anything about legal precedent, I certaintly didn't. As I stated earlier, this is about women's mental health.

 

[RyanH]

For all you folks that advocate capital punishment in this case, what would you do to prevent another post partum murder?

If you think the lethal injection is the answer, you are 'dead' wrong.

Knee-jerk capital punishment only serves to allow us to ignore prevention mechanisms.

Those that think a mother suffering from this condition is going to think "no, I won't do it cuz the punishment for getting caught is death", sound naive.

I knew that many more of the ENLIGHTENED would weigh in....As usual, Strongchick has truth on her side, again.

You see, Strongchick, some people are having a troublesome time understanding cause/effect and how they are dependent on one another.

 

[Bodhidogma]

I acchieve a couple of things.

1. One more piece of shit is taken from this earth.

2. She will be dead and the great citizens of Texas will not have to support this scum, nor will they have to provide for government research into depression.

Oh thats right, she is not to blame. Her husband and society in general is to blame. I forgot that liberals have zero concept of self responsibility.

and people will think twice about killing their children and trying to get off by pleading insanity

 

[BO-CEPHUS]

How is keeping this moron alive going to do anything to prevent another case of murder. That is like saying that keeping Tim McVeigh alive would prevent another OKC bombing.

I would execute this women and then allow the private sector to further their research on mental health issues concerning both men and women. I do not want my tax dollars supporting any type of gov.org research into this condition. I also do not want my tax dollars keeping this scum alive.

 

[strongchick]

I do not want my tax dollars supporting any type of gov.org research into this condition. I also do not want my tax dollars keeping this scum alive.

Unless of course, you _personally_ have some rare weed smoking disease....