Please Scroll Down to See Forums Below
napsgear
genezapharmateuticals
domestic-supply
puritysourcelabs
Research Chemical SciencesUGFREAKeudomestic
napsgeargenezapharmateuticals domestic-supplypuritysourcelabsResearch Chemical SciencesUGFREAKeudomestic

Muscle gain , does amount of bodyfat % matter?

blood_drinker

New member
I once read that the lower bf you got, the higher your muscle gain will be considering you do diet and training right.

Now, in everyones experience, does this hold true?
 
There was a post that touched on this on the women's board once, and yes, it does matter. The ratio of muscle to fat gain during a gaining period/cycle is greater the leaner you are. Another reason not to "bulk" Lee Priest style.
 
I don't know anyone who got huge by being ripped.

There are big guys on this board...and we did not get this way by being cut.

If you want to be small for the rest of your life...spend all of your time worrying about fat grams, carb depletion, and prot powders.

Remember what you long term goal is...and seek it intelligently.

B True
 
b fold the truth said:
I don't know anyone who got huge by being ripped.

B True

OK, OK, I went and found it, I didn't mean be ripped or stay ripped, just that BF % DOES make a difference, but DOESN'T mean you won't GAIN fat in the process of adding LBM. I was assuming blood_drinker was referring to starting body fat percentage:

A cut and paste from Dave Greenwalt (the Powerstore) regarding gaining LBM.

"Weight gain experiments

In subjects overfed, initial body fat level is
important. In fact, in a few studies, subjects with low
initial levels of body fat (10kg) gained about 70% of their
weight gain as lean body mass (and only 30% was fat mass).
These data also show that in subjects starting with 20kg and
40kg of body fat, only 30% and 20% of the weight gained was
lean body mass (while 70% and 80% of the weight gained comes
from increased fat mass).

From overfeeding studies, it is clear that lean
individuals gain less fat and more lbm when overfeeding when
compared to their fatter counterparts. In fact, this study
generated a predictive equation indicating that the ratio of
lean mass gained to total weight gained is related to
initial fat mass by the following equation:

Lean Mass Gain / Weight Gain = 10.4 / {10.4 + initial fat
weight (kg)}

Therefore for someone who is 92kg (200lbs) and 5% body
(4.6kg fat), about 70% of the weight gained during an
overfeeding phase can be expected to be lean body mass. In
someone who is 92kg and 10% body fat (9.2kg of fat), 53% of
weight gained will be lean body mass. So perhaps a good
idea is to only overfeed when relatively lean. If you are
200lbs and around 10-15% body fat (14-18% for females), about half the weight you
gain will be fat and half will be muscle. If you try to
gain when fatter than 15% (18% for females), much of the weight you gain will
be fat mass.

Since the equation seems to work for dieting also, just
switch it around as follows:

Lean Mass Loss / Weight Loss = 10.4 / {10.4 + initial fat
weight (kg)}

While not flawless, these equations are handy tools for
estimating how much lbm and fat you may gain or lose when
underfeeding or overfeeding. Remember though if supplements
that preserve lean body mass (like the ECA stack) are used
during dieting or if supplements like creatine or drugs like
androgens are used during overfeeding, these ratios may
change."

(Body fat content influences the body composition response
to nutrition and exercise. Forbes GB. Ann N Y Acad Sci 2000
May;904:359-65)


-----------------------------------------------------------
To sign up for Dave's Power Store News just visit
http://www.thepowerstore.com and enter your e-mail address


The subjects were not BBs, and were not following a clean "bulking" diet.
However the general principal is sound. By decreasing you carbs and increasing your protein compared to those test subjects you can minimise fat gain but you're still gonna add a some more fat before you reach your goal.
 
I would like to see exact numbers on this study.

Example: Guy A(lean guy) is 170lbs, and puts on 5lbs.
3.5lbs muscle, 1.5lbs fat. (70%lean, 30%fat)


Guy B (Fat dude) is 200lbs and puts on 30lbs.
that would be 9lbs muscle, 21lbs b/f. (30%lean, 70%fat)

Just because the percentage is lower doesn't mean the fatties aren't gaining more muscle.

What are the time periods for this study also? Guys who compete are looking for some quicker ways to build lbm. The amount of fat gain sometimes doesn't really matter to them because they will bust their ass on cardio and diet to get rid of it.
 
studcj said:

Example: Guy A(lean guy) is 170lbs, and puts on 5lbs.
3.5lbs muscle, 1.5lbs fat. (70%lean, 30%fat)


Guy B (Fat dude) is 200lbs and puts on 30lbs.
that would be 9lbs muscle, 21lbs b/f. (30%lean, 70%fat)


Guy B? Fat dude? Man...people callin me names left and right...lol...hahaha..lol

Interesting guys..

B True
 
studcj said:
I would like to see exact numbers on this study.

Example: Guy A(lean guy) is 170lbs, and puts on 5lbs.
3.5lbs muscle, 1.5lbs fat. (70%lean, 30%fat)


Guy B (Fat dude) is 200lbs and puts on 30lbs.
that would be 9lbs muscle, 21lbs b/f. (30%lean, 70%fat)

Just because the percentage is lower doesn't mean the fatties aren't gaining more muscle.

What are the time periods for this study also? Guys who compete are looking for some quicker ways to build lbm. The amount of fat gain sometimes doesn't really matter to them because they will bust their ass on cardio and diet to get rid of it.

OK, but if Guy A put on 30 lbs, about 20lbs of that would be muscle, so actually, the fatties aren't gaining more muscle.

Fo numbers, sorry - all I have is what I found, as above. Maybe try the link to the powerstore ...

The thing with busting ass on diet and cardio to lose the fat is that most times, if you're not taking any juice, you'll lose a bunch of muscle too.

I'm useless at maths. Maybe you can figure out the lean mass loss equation the article gives, using your example guys.
 
1. The only way to grow muscle is to overfeed.
2. When you overfeed, you not only grow muscle, you store fat as well
3. Simple truth, live with it.

Kingsquat
 
Top Bottom