Suddenly I can't log into my original account, change or receive my password. Pretty shady response to an otherwise worthy debate.
Let's continue,
Clomid is NOT an estrogen. It is structurally SIMILAR to estrogen and can ACT like an estrogen by modulating the estrogen receptor, but it is NOT an estrogen. It's like comparing a quarter to a slug. They are similar and will fit in the same slots, but will not always elicit the same response. The fact that you can't seem to comprehend all of this as more than just black and white makes you look pretty ignorant.
....................................................
WELL, YOU START CALLING PEOPLE IGNORANT AND THERE GOES THE WHOLE "WORTHY DEBATE." CLOMID WILL PRODUCE ESTROGEN-LIKE SYMPTOMS. SURELY YOU KNOW THIS.
.....................................................................
I'm not disagreeing that clomid can have nasty sides and ACT like an estrogen when you're taking it. This is totally true. But real estrogen, the stuff that your hypothalamus can recognize and respond to by lowering GnRH, is blocked due to the over-saturation of clomid in the blood. Even if / when clomid is acting like estrogen, your brain cannot recognize it as estrogen.
.................................................................................
BUT IT DOES. ASK ANYONE WHO GOT MOODY, DEPRESSED, HAD HEADACHES OR LOSS OF LIBIDO.
............................................
Once you back off of clomid, the real estrogen in your body can begin binding to receptors instead and all of the sides from the clomid will subside.
......................................
AND TESTOSTERONE DROPS BACK DOWN. THAT'S THE CATCH 22.
...................................................
As for the medical studies you commented on. The length of one study was 4 months (2 months on placebo and 2 months on clomid). No where does it say that it took 4 months for clomid to increase LH/T. Also, the first study was to see if clomid could be used to raise T in order to improve sexual function. The only significant portions (as they relate to this debate) of both of these studies are the facts that clomid did indeed raise LH and T.
........................................
AND IT RAISES ESTROGEN. AND SOMETIMES A RISE IN ESTROGEN IMPROVES LIBIDO. THAT'S WHAT MAKES IT SO DICY.
...................................................
Yes, sexual function is always desired but that isn't necessarily the purpose of PCT. This might not sound appealing, but the reality is that you can enjoy sexual function when you're done - who knows, maybe even some of those products you guys push can assist in this respect through some other mechanisms.
.................................
THEY DO. AND SEXUAL FUNCTION IS RELATED TO TESTOSTERONE PRODUCTION.
.............................................................................
Sucks that my account got "disabled." I've shared a lot with the EF community with only the best intentions. Even very personal things about safety and legal issues (my federal bust for example). Very unfortunate.
.........................................
I DON'T KNOW ABOUT THAT. I'M ALL FOR DEBATE. BUT WHEN YOU STRAT TELLING SENIOR MEMBERS THEY'RE WRONG AND THAT THEY'RE TRYING TO COMPROMISE MEMBERS HEALTH WITH INFERIOR PRODUCTS IN ORDER TO MAKE A BUCK AND INSISTING YOU'RE CORRECT AND ANYONE WHO DISAGREES IS IGNORANT, YOU MAY HAVE BROKEN A FORUM RULE OR TWO.
....