Canadian Soldier Vs American Soldier - who would win?

[SSAlexSS]

Just out of curiosity
what if you take 1 infantry guy from Canadian military and 1 from American military and put them agains each other. Who would win and why? Lets assume both of them trained for same amount of time in the military and lets assume that genetically they arent better than each other.


Lets hear all the replies!

 

[BigRedCat]

Well that is a stupid question because it would depend entirely on the particular soldiers but since the US has the best trained Army in the history of warfare I will go with the Yankee.

 

[SSAlexSS]

Well that is a stupid question because it would depend entirely on the particular soldiers but since the US has the best trained Army in the history of warfare I will go with the Yankee.

Is american army better trained then say, romans or greeks?

What about Mongols? If a squad leader misperforms he and his guys get executed....... I dont think the US uses such cruel and effective measures.

 

[WarriorPL]

American, no questions asked. We have the BEST trained army in the world. The Greeks and Romans are a different story though... those people were animals.

 

[guards]

I am gonna say the Canadian...not just because i am canadian but because american doctrine is pretty basic. Not to mention they are trained much much differently.

It is my experience that american NCO's have their balls tied to their shorts when it comes to being able to make a decision. Without an officer around they seem to act like a bunch of chickens who have just had their heads cut off.


they are BOTH well trained troops...my money would just be on the Canadian....CAUSE CANADA ROCKS! I forgot my point.


That is all. Carry on.

 

[DcupSheepNipples]

Well that is a stupid question because it would depend entirely on the particular soldiers

Agreed!

Universal Soldier Will Kill All!

 

[theoak01]

A canadian soldier,simply because we dont have the money like the americans and learn to deal with out all the high tech shit that does it all for you.

Ask any CF member and you dont have the best of anything

 

[armyhead27]

wow really ,you people really think American soldiers are better trained?, they may have more money,more equipment,more war machines,more weapons in general, but one thing Americans don't have is good soldiers, Canadian soldiers actually have to fight their way out of situations as Americans just call in air support when ever they get in A little trouble. come on people your talking about a country that was born to retreat since the birth of their nation compared to Canadians who since birth had to fight for their victories up close and personnel. to conclude get real Americans your bomb droppers and that's it. PS..you don't even do that right and that's your trade mark.

 

[Razorguns]

Bad question.

A trained Canadian ops vs a fat 17 y/o immature American grunt who joined for bonus money? A SAS soldier vs a Coast Guard? A US Marine vs a Canadian reservist army cook?

Either way, it's moot cuz whoever has the biggest GPS controlled satellite bomb system wins or can pay the enemy to plan IED's well, wins.

IED's and Suicide Bombers > Military strength. I think Iraq and Afghanistan proved that.

r

 

[Cardinal Slin]

An American Man and a Canadian man jump off a cliff to see who hits the ground first!

Who wins?





Society




Thanks for that one Razor!

 

[AAP]

Kind of lopsided.

Maybe Canadian SAS vs American Girl Scout would be a more even match.

 

[SpyWizard]

?? The girl scouts have brownies ya know??

 

[goin on 4T]

I am thinking of the best trained American soldier vs. the best trained Canadian soldier. To me, someone who has been in the military as well as my brothers and my father, grandfather etc... I would say the American!!!

 

[iggy]

quit bumping old threads army. this is the second time ive warned you.

 

[the_alcatraz]

now why the hell would someone go and bump a 2003 thread?

 

[iggy]

second time hes done it today.

http://www.elitefitness.com/forum/chat-conversation/canadian-soldier-dies-296756-2.html

 

[brew]

Both call in air support. I wonder who shows up first...

 

[walliwalibus]

LMAO... hey lets live in the past.

 

[buzzsaw696969]

Canadian of course

 

[miplank]

lol@ 2 votes for canada

 

[UncleBee]

Seeing as how I was a forward observer 13Fa, (mainly CAS by way of worthogs and 155mm artillery) I would have to say that when it comes to just dropping gps or radio controlled bombs it still doesn't matter who does it, it is not as easy as it sounds. And between the two I would have to say the Americans, not because I was one, but because we have the best training programs and the most first hand experience in real combat. Other than that fact it really depends on the individual. If they were both trained the same with the same equipment and so on, it would be a toss up. by the way, WHO CARES!! It's not who is better anyway. Why should we care who is the best. The best is the country who can make a situation peacefully resolved through diplomacy rather than through violence. That's what the REAL question should be. What country is the best at resolving conflict without any bloodshed. I ask everyone to answer THAT question.

 

[samoth]

LOL @ mounties.

 

[heavy_duty]

Retarded question to ask on a yankee web site!
come to a CFB and find out for yourself.

These are some examples of the fight in Afghanistan.. These video shots are not made through the shooter's telescopic sight... they are made looking through the spotter's scope. The spotter lies right next to the sniper and helps the sniper to find and home in on the target.

The sniper is using a 50 caliber rifle. A 50 cal. round is about 7-8 inches long and the casing is about an inch in diameter. The bullet itself is one-half inch in diameter and roughly one and one-half inches long.

Pay close attention to the beginning of the video. A Taliban is lying on top of the peak in front of you... when you hear the shot fired.... watch what happens. The sniper is also about a half mile away... or more.

A Canadian sniper in Afghanistan has been confirmed as hitting an enemy soldier at a range of 2,310 meters, the longest recorded and confirmed sniper shot in history. The previous record of 2,250 meters was set by US Marine sniper Carlos Hathcock in Vietnam in 1967. The Canadian sniper was at an altitude of 8,500 feet and the target, across a valley, was at 9,000 feet. Canadian sniper units often operated in support of US infantry units, which were grateful for their help. The record lasted only one day, until a second Canadian sniper hit an enemy soldier at 2,400 meters (8000 feet).

The Canadian snipers fire special .50-calibre McMillan tactical rifles, which are bolt-action weapons with five-round magazines. The Canadian snipers were the only Canadian troops operating without hel mets or flak jackets as they had too much other equipment to carry. Each three-man team has one sniper rifle, three standard rifles (Canadian C7s), one of them with a 203mm grenade launcher.

WARNING!! Flying Body Parts!!! Sniper Video

http://www.testdepthmedia.com/Sniper.wmv

 

[heavy_duty]

YouTube - Sniper

 

[buzzsaw696969]

awesome vid,
thanks

 

[canadianhitman]

The average Canadian grunt is superior to the average American grunt...believe it or not, our basic infantrymen are better trained.

 

[ricco561]

The average Canadian grunt is superior to the average American grunt...believe it or not, our basic infantrymen are better trained.

Having spent 22 years in the Army and working with the Americans many times, I would have to agree.
Vietnam ruined the American military, but they have gotten better and continue to improve.
The Canadians make superior peacekeepers, which is known worldwide and now Afghanistan is showing that we’re not just good at that.
Like anything else, I’ve worked with good Americans and poor Americans (and Canadians, for that matter).

 

[stosstruppe]

Star Wars Stormtrooper Vs Aliens Space Marine, who would win????!!!!!!!11111111one

 

[Chaser678]

wow really ,you people really think American soldiers are better trained?, they may have more money,more equipment,more war machines,more weapons in general, but one thing Americans don't have is good soldiers, Canadian soldiers actually have to fight their way out of situations as Americans just call in air support when ever they get in A little trouble. come on people your talking about a country that was born to retreat since the birth of their nation compared to Canadians who since birth had to fight for their victories up close and personnel. to conclude get real Americans your bomb droppers and that's it. PS..you don't even do that right and that's your trade mark.

No, your just stupid. We don't call in Air support because it's "Oh so cool and pretty lights"

We call in air support to avoid our own casualties. That's like saying you expect a squad of 20 men to take out 3 buildings that are 15 stories high that have 40 men in each of them. Air support isn't a puss move idiot. If you knew anything about war you would find that the Air support is the deadliest most expensive force in the world. Espescially when it comes to the U.S

Also, Did we retreat when we went off to fight WWI? No. WWII? Did we retreat? No. The korean war? That wasn't even our war and we fought it. Same with Vietnam. Oh p.s to your border customs officers; Don't just ask me if I have a gun/beer/smokes and take my word for it. At least ask me for my passport.

 

[JTF2Member]

No, your just stupid. We don't call in Air support because it's "Oh so cool and pretty lights"

We call in air support to avoid our own casualties. That's like saying you expect a squad of 20 men to take out 3 buildings that are 15 stories high that have 40 men in each of them. Air support isn't a puss move idiot. If you knew anything about war you would find that the Air support is the deadliest most expensive force in the world. Espescially when it comes to the U.S

Also, Did we retreat when we went off to fight WWI? No. WWII? Did we retreat? No. The korean war? That wasn't even our war and we fought it. Same with Vietnam. Oh p.s to your border customs officers; Don't just ask me if I have a gun/beer/smokes and take my word for it. At least ask me for my passport.

Alright so im a JTF2 member of the Canadian Forces for you idiots thats called Joint Task Force (Special Forces Unit) so Chaser678 kid go back to history class and learn that Canada entered WW1 - WW2 and the korean war first you guys only join ww1 because a german u-boat accidentally sunk an american vessel in ww2 the only reason america joined was because of pearl harbor THATS THE ONLY REASON and in korea the only reason you idiots joined was because of the soviet union and communism considering they were allied with the north koreans SECOND OF ALL Canadians are much better trained then american soldiers we have more endurance considering we have -52 degree training operations to deal with our Leopard 2 main battle tank is better then the abrams our C7A1 / C7A2 assault rifles are much more modernized and better equipped then your f***ing M16's from vietnam so how about you idiots get your facts straight before jumping to any conclusions that americans are better the only thumbs up id give to america is good job on taking money from different countries and being in debt for 100's of billions of dollars and spending it on your technology if canada had the technology you have then we'd be the most powerful country on the planet but considering we spend our money on free healthcare instead of five million dollars to make our f***ing military websites look cool you guys look and are complete and utter idiots - Frank
P.S you f***ing idiots invaded vietnam for no reason why do u think the reast of the world didnt give a flying f*** about your 500,000 wounded or dead soldiers THATS BECAUSE THE WORLD WANTED TO TEACH YOU A LESSON on getting into business thats not yours think of hamburger hill or hill 137 you morons took it 8 times and gave it right back to the enemy which gave you another 60,000 in losses goes to show how smart your dumbass tactics are especially your air support 10,000 men died of friendly fire because of your poorly trained radio ops and pilots.

 

[Redrocker13]

^^^Hmmm, anger issues. First of all it's a fairly worthless thread. No real soldier gives 2 spits about the original question. The truth is Canada has some tremendous soldiers and so does the United States. And both have weapons and training programs that are world class. I have met and seen some of the best from all around including a handful of British Royal Marines. Point is there are great troops all around the world. However, and do with this whatever you wish, but as was just proved again, American Special Ops takes a back seat to no-one.

Next, Mr Jtf, thank you for so gloriously re-hashing a few of our mistakes. However, I believe we have a few successes as well to help balance them out.

Lastly, with regard to your assertion that "the world wanted to teach us a lesson," unfortunately the real lesson is lost. And that is this...I am beyond tired of seeing our soldiers die on foriegn battlefields for people who couldn't care less and then mocked or looked down upon by others who brazenly think we do so for some narcissistic show. Who is it that is typically called upon when something nefarious is going on in the world? Who is it that has kept the UN propped up all these years? And for what great benefit to us? We either wind up giving the hapless countries money, supplies and assets to get them going or some military remnant to help protect them. Do we get paid back? Nope! Eventually we get spit on. (France anyone?!?) Or mocked by jerkoffs like you. So hear this sparky...next time you feel the need to make light of American soldiers dying on a foriegn battlefield, try to remember that this world would be in much worse straits were it not for those brave men and women! Or is class and honor not a high priority among the Canadian military? Your response will enlighten us as to the answer.

 

[Strongbow]

LOLZ what a stupid ass question. Canada sux at life and all things not hockey.

 

[ledhead]

I did not know Canada has a military, I'm being serious! Second, I believe you need a history lesson and a economics lesson, and a reality check. You stated "your country spends its money on free health care instead of military armaments." That might be true.... However, you failed tell the whole story, that your UHC is a complete failure! Every person in Canada that has a terminal or debilitating illness comes to America to receive superior medical treatment. For some odd reason, Canada cannot or denies people adequant treatment. With that being said, Canada is probably better off spending its money on military material, then maybe people would know Canada actually has a military.

Your reasons for America's wars are about two thousand miles off the beam. Those were just events, that gave America an excuse to enter those wars. The real reasons was economics. Which of course worked, after WWII, America had 50% of the world's wealth and 6% of its population. The Cold War wars were for economic purposes, ideology was second. The Soviets were basically pawned by the United States, in order to sustain a war economy. The Korean War easily could have been won if Truman would have listened to Macauthur. I do not know were you came up with the number of casualties Americans took in Vietnam, but they're retarded! America took 58,000 opposed to Vietnam's 2 to 3 million. I would say from a soldiers viewpoint, America kicked Vietnam's ass! Politically, America lost.... All the difference in the world! My dad was a VN vet, he told me if the NVA had intelligence the Marines were in the area, they would hump 10-15 miles out of their way to avoid the core.... What does that tell you? That tells me they knew better.... Listen! one battalion of the Marines would totally obliterate Canada's entire armed forces. Next time you decide to give your ignorant opninon, try to use some primary sources. The Marines and some Army units are proven elite fighting squads. History really does not give Canada's military much praise! Fixed....

 

[wootoom]

I did not know Canada has a military, I'm being serious! Second, I believe you need a history lesson and a economics lesson, and a reality check. You stated "your country spends its money on free health care instead of military armaments." That might be true.... However, you failed tell the whole story, that your UHC is a complete failure! Every person in Canada that has a terminal or debilitating illness comes to America to receive superior medical treatment. For some odd reason, Canada cannot or denies people adequant treatment. With that being said, Canada is probably better off spending its money on military material, then maybe people would know Canada actually has a military.

Your reasons for America's wars are about two thousand miles off the beam. Those were just events, that gave America an excuse to enter those wars. The real reasons was economics. Which of course worked, after WWII, America had 50% of the world's wealth and 6% of its population. The Cold War wars were for economic purposes, ideology was second. The Soviets were basically pawned by the United States, in order to sustain a war economy. The Korean War easily could have been won if Truman would have listened to Macauthur. I do not know were you came up with the number of casualties Americans took in Vietnam, but they're retarded! America took 58,000 opposed to Vietnam's 2 to 3 million. I would say from a soldiers viewpoint, America kicked Vietnam's ass! Politically, America lost.... All the difference in the world! My dad was a VN vet, he told me if the NVA had intelligence the Marines were in the area, they would hump 10-15 miles out of their way to avoid the core.... What does that tell you? That tells me they knew better.... Listen! one battalion of the Marines would totally obliterate Canada's entire armed forces. Next time you decide to give your ignorant opninon, try to use some primary sources. The Marines and some Army units are proven elite fighting squads. History really does not give Canada's military much praise! Fixed....

thats pathetic.....its almost not right......our guys and women are fighting the same war losing families...i cant believe the education system in US...

 

[stevesmi]

I did not know Canada has a military, I'm being serious! Second, I believe you need a history lesson and a economics lesson, and a reality check. You stated "your country spends its money on free health care instead of military armaments." That might be true.... However, you failed tell the whole story, that your UHC is a complete failure! Every person in Canada that has a terminal or debilitating illness comes to America to receive superior medical treatment. .
...

weird cause both my grandparents had cancer in Canada and both recieved superior treatments in Canada and were cancer free. me thinks you don't know what you are talking about.

the US healthcare system is ranked #48 in the world. for you to say our system is good is laughable at best. maybe if you are filthy rich and your wife is banging the doctor you will get good healthcare in the US, otherwise its a joke. thats why most on here buy our roids online or go to a HRT clinic. if you go to a doc for anything you will get turned into a guinea pig, docs want to make money.. they don't care about helping you. thats why for profit healthcare is a failure and the Canadian system is much better. go to an ER anywhere in the US and see how long it takes you to be seen.

anyway back on topic this thread is 7 years old first off. second off the special Ops like rocker said above are the best trained in the world. proof was them killing Bin Laden and running a flawless operation. I would say 20 years ago you couldn't say that.. but in 2011 the US special Ops are #1. I know a lot of Navy guys who are the biggest baddasses you will ever meet.. 8 pack abs, etc. who were REJECTED even though they completed full Navy Seal training. that should tell you how good they are if they are rejected these kind of guys

and finally Canada is a country with 10% or whatever of the US population and 90% of the country is covered in ice most of the year. so its kinda hard to be better then the US at anything when you are facing those kinds of odds. so comparing them is silly and divisive

 

[wootoom]

lol that guy represents the idiot wing of the US redneck population. so i apologize for him.

most thinking Americans are above that rubbish he wrote

the dumbest part of his post was that 2M vietnamese died and only 58K americans hence the US kicked vietnams ass. lol. i wonder if he knows the difference between north and south vietnam

I figured, thats just not believable.

 

[wootoom]

I remembered growing up, i loved the US i always had US shirts on in school lol i wanted to be from there so bad.

 

[Redrocker13]

I remembered growing up, i loved the US i always had US shirts on in school lol i wanted to be from there so bad.

And I have always thought us brothers more than neighbors. Canada like the US is a gorgeous country without amazing people! And hell, who could argue Canada's value having given us John Candy, God rest his soul!

 

[EnderJE]

And I have always thought us brothers more than neighbors. Canada like the US is a gorgeous country without amazing people! And hell, who could argue Canada's value having given us John Candy, God rest his soul!

Sorry about Bieber and Celine. In fairness, Britney and BSB were your fault.

 

[Strongbow]

weird cause both my grandparents had cancer in Canada and both recieved superior treatments in Canada and were cancer free. me thinks you don't know what you are talking about.

the US healthcare system is ranked #48 in the world. for you to say our system is good is laughable at best. maybe if you are filthy rich and your wife is banging the doctor you will get good healthcare in the US, otherwise its a joke. thats why most on here buy our roids online or go to a HRT clinic. if you go to a doc for anything you will get turned into a guinea pig, docs want to make money.. they don't care about helping you. thats why for profit healthcare is a failure and the Canadian system is much better. go to an ER anywhere in the US and see how long it takes you to be seen.

anyway back on topic this thread is 7 years old first off. second off the special Ops like rocker said above are the best trained in the world. proof was them killing Bin Laden and running a flawless operation. I would say 20 years ago you couldn't say that.. but in 2011 the US special Ops are #1. I know a lot of Navy guys who are the biggest baddasses you will ever meet.. 8 pack abs, etc. who were REJECTED even though they completed full Navy Seal training. that should tell you how good they are if they are rejected these kind of guys

and finally Canada is a country with 10% or whatever of the US population and 90% of the country is covered in ice most of the year. so its kinda hard to be better then the US at anything when you are facing those kinds of odds. so comparing them is silly and divisive

Shouldn't you be in the steroid forums teaching noobs about the ill effects of gynocamastia, rather than in Chat giving out histroy lessons to nugga's who don't know any better than to be retards. Also can I have 10 million Karmaz? TYIA

 

[Redrocker13]

Sorry about Bieber and Celine. In fairness, Britney and BSB were your fault.

We all have family we'd rather the rest of the world didn't know about.

 

[wootoom]

Bieber and Celine dion are fuckin idiots ughhh

 

[CoBra666]

canada has some of the best trained fighter jet pilots in the world, and is always training fellow air forces from all over the world. i spent several years working on the cold lake air weapons range. the only problem is canda dont spend any money on their troops.... but if there is weed then they will defend it!! wish i had tiny pic, i have a great pic of a a little red wagon with a turret gun on it and a lil kid. it says canadian army on it lol

 

[PICK3]

GSP is dreamy

 

[ledhead]

weird cause both my grandparents had cancer in Canada and both recieved superior treatments in Canada and were cancer free. me thinks you don't know what you are talking about.

the US healthcare system is ranked #48 in the world. for you to say our system is good is laughable at best. maybe if you are filthy rich and your wife is banging the doctor you will get good healthcare in the US, otherwise its a joke. thats why most on here buy our roids online or go to a HRT clinic. if you go to a doc for anything you will get turned into a guinea pig, docs want to make money.. they don't care about helping you. thats why for profit healthcare is a failure and the Canadian system is much better. go to an ER anywhere in the US and see how long it takes you to be seen.

anyway back on topic this thread is 7 years old first off. second off the special Ops like rocker said above are the best trained in the world. proof was them killing Bin Laden and running a flawless operation. I would say 20 years ago you couldn't say that.. but in 2011 the US special Ops are #1. I know a lot of Navy guys who are the biggest baddasses you will ever meet.. 8 pack abs, etc. who were REJECTED even though they completed full Navy Seal training. that should tell you how good they are if they are rejected these kind of guys

and finally Canada is a country with 10% or whatever of the US population and 90% of the country is covered in ice most of the year. so its kinda hard to be better then the US at anything when you are facing those kinds of odds. so comparing them is silly and divisive

LOL... at you, you're supposed to be an American and do not even know the stats of the Vietnam War. Try reading a history book or Historical Statistics of the World, maybe, that will convince you, but I doubt it. It appears, you're a bleeding heart liberal sissy, that never served in the infrantry. Nice patriot you are! Why in the world would you side-up with Canada? Anyway, nobody was talking to you in the first place, so mind your own business. I never chime in your ridiculous advice you give people on the roid site. Which you seem confused, you want a lesson on that subject too?

Yeah, I'm sure you know all the badasses in the world, you're a special guy.... Internet tough-guys, that never experienced things for themselves, feeding-off of everyone elses experiences. If anyone is a moron it is you believing that propaganda, that Seal Team 6 waxed Bin Laden. Everyone, that has every had any combat experience or can identify with goverment policies knows this is bogus as it gets. Bin Laden has been dead for years, the goverment needs to whip-up public support to continue its war games.
Having eight pack abs really means something. People, that weigh 120 lbs have eight pack abs, AND your point is erroneous to say the least. Redneck--NO! However, I wish, I was for a second, so I could call on the Invisible Empire and lynch your Marxist ass.... As for apoligizing for me, don't bother, I make more in a quarter than you do in a year. Canada is 90% covered in ice....thanks for the geography lesson, which is totally inaccurate, but that is expected from you, like I said, I read your advice on the roid site, you don't know shit....

Bombing me is a leading indicator, that I pushed the right buttons, the truth hurts.... That means none of you have the guts to debate me on a open forum, so you have to play your passive-aggressive games and build alliances because none of you can face me one on one. Soooooooo bomb me because I dont give a fuckkkkk, Im never on this site anymore..... CHECKMATE

 

[wootoom]

canada has some of the best trained fighter jet pilots in the world, and is always training fellow air forces from all over the world. I spent several years working on the cold lake air weapons range. The only problem is canda dont spend any money on their troops.... But if there is weed then they will defend it!! Wish i had tiny pic, i have a great pic of a a little red wagon with a turret gun on it and a lil kid. It says canadian army on it lol

lol!

 

[Strongbow]

Did GSP look ghostly white and extremely small to you guys in his latest boring ass fight? If that nugga don't learn to finish his fights Ima call Matt Serra and tell him to whoop his ass. Even worse if he continues to piss me off I may beat his lil ass myself.

 

[CoBra666]

idk, he looked pretty damn big compared to the other dude. wayyy better condition. but yeah thats like 3/4 fights in a row now he said he is disapointed he didnt finish the guy. he better get back to kyokushin and learn how to strike again