Cornholio said:
Number 1 - Any routine will become stale. In this case it happened to be a strength phase. As you up the intensity, signs of overtraining creep in - such as sore joints. That is just a fact of life.
You state that "you should never have a problem recovering if the program is effecient"......well....if you are upping the intensity at each workout as you should(that is called progressive resistance...either bump the reps or the weight)....recoverability will suffer. Surely you agree with that??!?!
So you think that high-volume and non-traumatic don't belong in the same sentence? Why?? If I increase the volume from 5x5 to 3 sets of 10...is that not consided less traumatic(joint-wise especially) with respect to the 5x5??
Fold - you stated somewhere that you got smaller from strongman training and that you are generally among the smaller guys at the elite level at which you compete.....maybe you are as big and strong as you are in spite of your training methods...not because of them...
Any routine will stay stale if you never modify it. A solid routine needs very little modification. There also is a difference between muscle overtraining and joint overtraining. He was suffering from joint overtraining (from what I have read).
Why should you have to up the intensity every single workout? In my bodybuilding program...you have the choice of weights and reps...and to a degree...exercises. It is not just cycling weights or reps...but one of the keys is to cycle intensity. I can not train like a mad mad 100% of the time. I can train like a mad man 75% of the time though...and grow.
For me, and I guess that may be the key here, doing a 5x5 routine and a 3x10 routine is not much different. If you are still training super intensely...it is still taxing to the joints.
"Fold - you stated somewhere that you got smaller from strongman training and that you are generally among the smaller guys at the elite level at which you compete.....maybe you are as big and strong as you are in spite of your training methods...not because of them... "
.....For starters...that was very low. You are suggesting that I am big and strong by luck? That is funny...have you not seen my transformation pics?
http://boards.elitefitness.com/forum/showthread.php?threadid=51836
Is what you are saying something similar to what your wife spoke of? That you had big legs yet you rarely ever trained them? So...you have nicely shaped quads in spite of your training methods...right?
I took great offense to that last paragraph...great offense. Maybe there is a reason why I am 285 at the moment and you are in the 220's..yet we are the same height. It might be that I am fat...but I am not that fat. It might have something to do with me not doing the Old School 3 day a week program...might. It also might have something to do with me NOT using the smith machine. It might have something to do with me doing heavy deadlifts, squats, barbell bench press...etc...
How was it you phrased it when you were talking to me...something about me eclipsing the sun?
Sorry...just VERY offended.
B True