Comhrac Bas???

[illusionofsize]

BIg Rick's probably gonna kick my ass for this but you Comrac Bas Guys are Fcuked!!
Who the Fcuk talks like that Poison Orange boy.??????
Thinking your educating people on what a non-sequitor is will not grant you or your art much credibility. I was interested until I started laughing.

Styles like JKD, Muay thai and Boxing are tried and proven via combat training and"Drills" as you call them.But you come on here and insult every single artist on here with your patronizing, condescending , holier than thou attitude.
Unless you train with live blades, guns with live ammo, Vehicle evasion and attack techniques, grenades,rocket launchers and nuclear missles.....WHAT MAKES YOU SO SPECIAL??!
Oh, I know- That one move where you can kill me with your pinky finger while drinking a glass of water standing on your head.


Now I'm only 2 hours away from Moncton so I'm gonna look up your buddy Claude there and check it out. I don't suppose you're anywhere in MAritime Canada??
I think i'll also maybe ask a couple of my Kinda-ha JJ budies in Moncton about him as well as my Kick-boxing buddies.

As for KOS. I know a couple of good schools in Moncton and there is a REALLY good school in Rothsay(JKD).

E-mail if you wish- [email protected] for details.


Ill

 

[teep]

Well I guess you showed your hatred of intellectual enquiry. Wow you don't like the way someone talks so that, of course, means you now get to invalidate everything that is said because naturally you are more of an authority-- (are you a professional? do you make your living training others and teaching others? do you even have training tapes available?) then why are you capable of an informed opinion on the subject?

Two hours away from Moncton--in which direction? Nova Scotia?

Just because your experience is limited does not mean that others have the same problem.

"Don't judge the world by your own shitty standards"--James Keating

 

[illusionofsize]

Well I guess you showed your hatred of intellectual enquiry. Wow you don't like the way someone talks so that, of course, means you now get to invalidate everything that is said because naturally you are more of an authority-- (are you a professional? do you make your living training others and teaching others? do you even have training tapes available?) then why are you capable of an informed opinion on the subject?

Two hours away from Moncton--in which direction? Nova Scotia?

Just because your experience is limited does not mean that others have the same problem.

"Don't judge the world by your own shitty standards"--James Keating

I don't hate intellectual inquiry. I hate individuals who will try to discredit all other arts in light of their own "superior" techniques. You and Poison have done that quite well with-out actually trying to engage in sensical or rational debate as to what makes an art an art, or what makes an art effective.
YOu just tell everyone that all other arts are out-dated and of no use so Comrac Bas is the be-all, end-all and everyone else on here knows nothing.
Then you to try to justify by stating that you are "professionals". All professional means is that you take people's money from them. IT DOES NIOT SPEAK TO YOUR ABILITIES AS A MARTIAL ARTIST!

I am an authority because I hold rank in several of the styles mentioned and am certified under Dan Inosanto, Remy Presas and Louie Lindo.I am an authority because I hold 4 provincial kick-boxing titles and numerous competiton wins.I have trained CF's troops and Several local Police forces in Hand to Hand, kubotan and Baton work. I am not a professional. I have no need to convert my MA hobby into a money making scheme whereby I can rip off thousands of un-informed MArtial artists with video tapes and one hour lessons in " modern technology" of fighting.

I notice POB has been training in Comrac Bas for all of ONE WHOLE YEAR!!

That certainly makes him an expert on all martial arts and gives him the right to discredit the rest of us who have been training for 20 odd years and have been all over the world to train with the top individuals in martial arts.

My experience is far from limited. In fact, I would try Comrac Bas to determine if it was indeed an art I would be interested in. Can you say the same of JKD or any other art??

Ill

 

[teep]

I don't hate intellectual inquiry. I hate individuals who will try to discredit all other arts in light of their own "superior" techniques. You and Poison have done that quite well with-out actually trying to engage in sensical or rational debate as to what makes an art an art, or what makes an art effective."

JKD was advacement of Wing Chun--obviously you not where Comhrac Bas comes from or what it is built from--you are blinded by your own limitations yet again.




"YOu just tell everyone that all other arts are out-dated and of no use so Comrac Bas is the be-all, end-all and everyone else on here knows nothing.""


Gee sounds a lot like Bruce Lee doesn't it?

Then you to try to justify by stating that you are "professionals". All professional means is that you take people's money from them. IT DOES NIOT SPEAK TO YOUR ABILITIES AS A MARTIAL ARTIST!"


Really", so a docotor that gets paid for operating is no better than some one who sits around and hobby operates? That is your argument.

"I am an authority because I hold rank in several of the styles mentioned and am certified under Dan Inosanto, Remy Presas and Louie Lindo.I am an authority because I hold 4 provincial kick-boxing titles and numerous competiton wins.I have trained CF's troops and Several local Police forces in Hand to Hand, kubotan and Baton work."


That is good now we know that you are good follower--but not an innovator. That is normal, don't feel bad--there are lots of good classical musicians, but only one Mozart. Good work on the provincial titles--I assume this is the old above the waist fighting? Canada only has a population of 27 million--and the best are around Montreal and Vancouver. It is a different animal that comes to the forefrount out of 300 million people. You know what I mean?

""I am not a professional. I have no need to convert my MA hobby into a money making scheme whereby I can rip off thousands of un-informed MArtial artists with video tapes and one hour lessons in " modern technology" of fighting.

Nice justification after the fact--and again you talk about something you know nothing about. (Like someon poor who claims that being rich doesn't make you happy--as if poverty makes anyone happy?) You have at the best a specious grasp of what it is that you are writing.

"I notice POB has been training in Comrac Bas for all of ONE WHOLE YEAR!!"

So your standards again are what sets the standards for all. Gee let me tel l you--a Dutch kickboxer in a year can beat the hell out anyone else training (Dekkers and Kaman changed Muay Thai forever). But since you didn't learn anything in a year that must mean that everyone else is incapable.

"That certainly makes him an expert on all martial arts and gives him the right to discredit the rest of us who have been training for 20 odd years and have been all over the world to train with the top individuals in martial arts."


Well the Zulus were better warrior spirited men than the British troops that they fought--but guess what (and pay close attention) the TECHNOLOGY of the British beat the Zulus.

"My experience is far from limited. In fact, I would try Comrac Bas to determine if it was indeed an art I would be interested in. Can you say the same of JKD or any other art??"


You clearly think you understand the background of those that you talk to. This is your biggest error. Maybe all of those things that you are clinging to with your ego are things that I and other progressive thinking people let go of. Or did that even come to your mind? So what keeps you from trying CB in fact there is a seminar in Ohio 6 and 7 November (CALL 419-938-6089)hosted by the former USA Oloympic Judo Coach (gee someone that has seen the best in the world sees the reality of CB and has embraced it--is that a big enough of a traditional authority to impress you?)

 

[illusionofsize]

JKD is far from an advancement of wing chun. You speak of my limitations but you also know nothing of it's evolution.

Give up the doctor analogy. It won't fly with any of the martial artists on here.You have to go to med school and achieve a modicumof success before professionally treating patients. ANYONE can open a martial arts school and claim to be professional.

Now you compare your art and it's "innovations" to mozart??
The best are from the USA is what you're trying to say...lol
Jean Yves Theriault!

I don't understand your background. In that you are correct. I can only speculate that you have no formal or competent training in any other arts except this Comrac BAs of which you speak that has such fantastic moves as a "Tossed Salad."

I don't thimk I'll be going to Ohio .I will however, travel to Moncton to visit so if you
are present I would certainly welcome your asistance in teaching me this amazing art form of yours and opening my eyes to prove how I've wasted 20 years of my life as a "follower" of some of the best Martial arts and instructors in the world.

I would also encourage all the other artists on this forum to investigate the infomercial that is theburst showcasing Comrac Bas.

Video tapes...lol1

I'm done.

 

[XBiker]

Cat Fight!!!

 

[teep]

Well, it is clear that you don't want to take the advantage of learnig from the sources. You can check out more at: http://www.johnsaylor-sja.com/index.html


You never did answer if you are in Nova Scotia. I am in Europe to answer your thought.

Jean Yves was okay as above the waist--but could never hang even with modified Muay Thai fights (Kaman stopped him in an above the waist kicking fight--and would have killed him in a leg kick, kne fight).

YOu talk about Muay Thai but clearly have no idea aobut fighting in the ring with it.

I think you are done (or was that to say dumb in the true sense of the word?) because there is nothing that you can say.

Also your non sequiturs are really painful--doctor analogy works with professionals who have done things (that is the point--we are not talking about a franchised Tae Kwon Do school here).

Anyway, if you really can do more than talk and can open your mind (which has been closed since you first typed on this thread) then you would get yourself to Ohio. But you are the type that has too much of their ego invested in what they already do--you cannot let go of the rung to climb higher on the ladder.

And that said it all.

 

[karde]

This thread should be closed, it has degenerated from a legitimate question into the common disagreement martial artists tend to get into, the kind that can never be settled.

 

[teep]

A truth about all things

This thread should be closed, it has degenerated from a legitimate question into the common disagreement martial artists tend to get into, the kind that can never be settled.

Actually this is not a disagreement. This is an error in reading what has been said. This is about experential truth--I have been speaking of experential truth and the other has been speculation (not founded in any sort of experential data). One talks about what he thinks in his imagination (without any sort of experential truth)--I have only talked about those things that I have actually done. There is no theory in what I have stated.

So to sum it up: this has been one person talking about his limitations and unwillingness to do what is needed to gain experential truth (only ad hominene attacks, red herrings, non sequtiurs, etc) and I have only talked about what is real in my experience.

Big difference from disagreement of what color the room should be painted.

 

[booby]

i have seen chris clugston fight in tulsa oklahoma...with all his training and cohmrac bas claims he lost a kick boxing match to a kid who had never kicked boxed before! chris clugston is a fraud! and a joke in the fight world!