Best album ever?

[perkele]

allmusic.com gives 4½ stars to Shania Twain's "UP!" album. OK, the album had total 19 new songs. Has there ever been an album before that has as many songs and got 4½ stars? Seriously, unless it's a greatest hits album it can't have that many good songs, and I think it's a biggest joke ever to give that album such a good rating. If you've heard it, you know what I mean. Pro-tools masterpiece with 2 turds on top of the whole package.

 

[Cutiebaby]

i love country music...shania twain is awesome...she deserves all the great that has come out of her albums

 

[musclemuscle]

hard choice...there are so many good tunes out there

 

[PrisonBitch]

hard choice...there are so many good tunes out there

I'd go with....led zep in thru the out door......Radiohead OK computer.....Janes addiction.....Ritual.......no particular order..but they are my 3 favs

 

[perkele]

i love country music...shania twain is awesome...she deserves all the great that has come out of her albums

"The Woman In Me" was a perfect country/pop album but "UP!" sucked big time. "UP!" was a poor remake of "Come On Over".

 

[Flah]

allmusic.com gives 4½ stars to Shania Twain's "UP!" album. OK, the album had total 19 new songs. Has there ever been an album before that has as many songs and got 4½ stars? Seriously, unless it's a greatest hits album it can't have that many good songs, and I think it's a biggest joke ever to give that album such a good rating. If you've heard it, you know what I mean. Pro-tools masterpiece with 2 turds on top of the whole package.

Yeah, god forbid a reviewer actually has their own opinion about music. That can't be right.

I forgot that we're supposed to poll a million people before we write a review.

 

[anthrax]

Best album ever=

The Beatles, Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band
The Beach Boys, Pet Sounds
Bob Dylan, Highway 61 Revisited
The Rolling Stones, Exile on Main Street

 

[perkele]

Yeah, god forbid a reviewer actually has their own opinion about music. That can't be right.

I forgot that we're supposed to poll a million people before we write a review.

I guess the reviewer didn't listen either UP! or her previous albums when writing a reviews of those albums. If he did then it's another proof that those guys don't know shit about music.

 

[r1pp3d]

metallica's black album
korn's first album

 

[perkele]

Best album ever=

The Beatles, Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band
The Beach Boys, Pet Sounds
Bob Dylan, Highway 61 Revisited
The Rolling Stones, Exile on Main Street

Steely Dan, AJA