I know I'm gonna get railed on by a few fellas here for this, but once the door is open again I highly recommend dating someone with similar faith background to you. My longest relationships were with two guys who were athiests and it never bothered me at the time (well, it didn't bother me MUCH), but it also made it a lot easier for me to not live a godly life. Dating someone who grew up in a VERY faith centered home, being with someone who encouraged me to rely on God first, him second, showed me exactly how much I need that in a partner.