Are you sure that you are NOT a girl? GEEZE! We overanalyze too much?!
LOL Listen dear. There is NOTHING WRONG with you not having gotten a kiss on the first date.
I am 35, soon2bdivorced mother of four children (so I know exactly how to fuck too), and a dancer.
I NEVER EVER KISS ON THE FIRST DATE - EVER!
Why? Is it because I am a prude? No. It is because of the simple fact that I do NOT like sexually aggressive men. I want to sit there the whole time and think to myself, "When is he going to kiss me? Why isn't he kissing me? Is he going to kiss me now?!" If a man makes the first move REGARDLESS of how much I like him, WE ARE DONE - PERIOD.
The last two men that I had relationships with I knew FOR MONTHS before we ever even had physical contact. Then when we did finally get together I WAS THE ONE WHO ENDED UP PRACTICALLY RAPING THEM!!!
I have been in situations where I have even slept over the guy's apartment (I slept on their couch of course) and we are talking HUG at the end of the date. And I am not talking a hug where I hug with my whole body (that is below the hips).
Just relax.
True, the girl may have been turned off a bit by your sexual past but that doesn't necessarily indicate that she isn't willing to forego that by getting to know you better.
Take a deep breath and stop psychologizing so much. If she digs you then you will get together again, if not, oh well. She is not the first girl that you really liked and she will not be the last.
I think that it is always better for a guy to be TOTALLY cool with making physical moves on a girl than for her to like him but to be turned off because she felt a bit forced to have contact.
Just my .02