Assuming this was stated by at least 3 or more women ... your eyes might wander too much (literally). Generally speaking a woman doesn't think you're a player unless you give her a reason to THINK you're a player. You're doing something, body language, verbally, eyes, something is throwing up a very BIG stop sign.
I think this "You're too attractive for me," could possibly be a VERY nice way of saying, "Jesus, you're hot, you're sweet, you're smart and I'm so terrified that I'm going to fall in love with you and you're going to hurt me because I'm sitting here at dinner and you're sitting across from me and you keep glancing over at that hot waitress." And scientists have discovered that some men do look at other women without even being aware of it.
I mean, who the hell thinks a guy is too attractive? C'mon. Let's be practical here.
I had a brief thing with a ummm, gorgeous guy. We had awesome chemistry ... I could have fallen so very hard for him. Right up front he told me he had no interest in monogamy, and yet in the next sentence he told me he hadn't met a woman he felt he could be so honest with ... it was very hard. I was much younger then, more resilient. The idea of having a summer fling-only with a guy I found unbearably attractive was much more appealing when I was 18. 22 years later, I just don't think I could bear crying for 12 hours straight again. The agony and the ecstasy, so to speak.
And the other thing, you could subconsciously be picking the same type of woman over and over again and not even be aware of it. Without knowing you or the ladies, it's a tough call.