The harsh reality is:
1) Evolution is true.
2) Evolution still can't explain how we got here.
I don't believe some gray-bearded deity whisked us into existence. But I also don't believe a couple hundred thousand amino acids lined-up perfectly on the backside of a perfectly imperfect crystal and got stuck by just the right cosmic ray either.
When it comes to the origins of life, I'm perfectly fine accepting the fact that we just don't know right now. Trying to overgeneralize a fundamentally good theory such as evolutionary adaptation to explain the origins of life seems just as silly as the ridiculous religiously-based theories.
Sometimes it's A-OK to not have the answer.