Please Scroll Down to See Forums Below
napsgear
genezapharmateuticals
domestic-supply
puritysourcelabs
UGL OZ
UGFREAK
napsgeargenezapharmateuticals domestic-supplypuritysourcelabsUGL OZUGFREAK

what is your opinion of the fence/wall/barrier that Isreal is building around itself?

Allon since you live in Israel, what do you think of the chance of Israel acting unilaterally attacking Iran b/c of its nuclear ambitions? Whats the sense of what the Sharon govt. might do from the inside, any chance. Weve been sorta talking about it on the board latelyu on who might, if anyone do, something like that, course were half a world away and on the outside looking in.
 
I am no expert on that but as I said before, I am pretty sure that is something Israel will not let happen.
I think right now we are counting on the US and whoever to do something about it, if it fails, Israel will probably just find a way to make the reactor dissapear (airstrike or missilestrike) I do not think a war will start, it will be an attack and Iran will not be able to do anything about it if we succeede. They may try send missiles or something but we can beat them at that. They would not send airforce coz they would stand no chance.

I really think that the US will probably sort this out instead though, they seem to be pretty firm about not wanting Iran to have nukes.

Then again who knows, maybe they will build them and thats it...

On the other hand, I do know that Iran is very near a big change, I have heard many people (from Iran) say that it is a matter of 10-30 years until it becomes a modern democracy.

BTW, if I sound arrogant about Israels military abilities on this then sorry, but this is what Israel is built on: The military superiority over our neighbours, anything less and we are good as dead.
 
Allon said:
I am no expert on that but as I said before, I am pretty sure that is something Israel will not let happen.
I think right now we are counting on the US and whoever to do something about it, if it fails, Israel will probably just find a way to make the reactor dissapear (airstrike or missilestrike) I do not think a war will start, it will be an attack and Iran will not be able to do anything about it if we succeede. They may try send missiles or something but we can beat them at that. They would not send airforce coz they would stand no chance.

I really think that the US will probably sort this out instead though, they seem to be pretty firm about not wanting Iran to have nukes.

Then again who knows, maybe they will build them and thats it...

On the other hand, I do know that Iran is very near a big change, I have heard many people (from Iran) say that it is a matter of 10-30 years until it becomes a modern democracy.

BTW, if I sound arrogant about Israels military abilities on this then sorry, but this is what Israel is built on: The military superiority over our neighbours, anything less and we are good as dead.


No if anyone thinks youre arrogant when talking plainly about Israels strength in comparison to others in the region, they be just plain idiots, nuff said.

Interesting, seems a bit up in the air as to what will happen. Europeans are trying to deal with em right now, but they seem to always negotiate from a position of weakness. hmmm we shall just have to wait and see.

I sure hope it doesnt take that long for democracy in Iran.
 
Yeh Europeans do seem to do that. However on the other hand the US always come over as too aggressive, there must be a middle ground somewhere... I liked Clinton's way to do things usually, personally.

I read an article last week that Iran have upped their airforce surveilance and they are on the lookout for an attack by Israel more than ever.

If it comes it will probably be swift and without warning. I don't think our government have any illusions that threatening Iran to not build nukes will help. If they decide the time has come they will strike without any warning whatsoever.
 
Allon said:
Yeh Europeans do seem to do that. However on the other hand the US always come over as too aggressive, there must be a middle ground somewhere... I liked Clinton's way to do things usually, personally.

I read an article last week that Iran have upped their airforce surveilance and they are on the lookout for an attack by Israel more than ever.

If it comes it will probably be swift and without warning. I don't think our government have any illusions that threatening Iran to not build nukes will help. If they decide the time has come they will strike without any warning whatsoever.

Wasnt always a big Clinton fan, but I respected his abilities, some things he was masterful at and I dont think there's politician that can do what he did coming anytime soon.
Yeah, I believe w/o a doubt that Iran has upped their defensive alert status. And goes without saying that will it be swift and no warning. Yeah and they arent going to respond to threats I believe as well.
Middle ground, sorta the "walk softly and carry a big stick." approach. Hopefully the europeans can fill the void with the US and Israel playing the hammer role. Hope it doesnt come to that though, I think that would be a bad thing.
 
I doubt Iran will stop building the nukes, I may be wrong obviously but I just doubt it.

I think it will come to either military action or the world will just not do anything and Iran will become a nuclear power.

I think I only really started seeing the beauty of clinton once he was gone LOL. I always thought it was amazing that until the last day he had in office he continued to try and make peace between Israel and the palestinians. It was like a major goal of his and he seemed to be doing it out of strong beleif and goodwill. (apart from wanting to be remembered for it)
 
Allon said:
I doubt Iran will stop building the nukes, I may be wrong obviously but I just doubt it.

I think it will come to either military action or the world will just not do anything and Iran will become a nuclear power.

I think I only really started seeing the beauty of clinton once he was gone LOL. I always thought it was amazing that until the last day he had in office he continued to try and make peace between Israel and the palestinians. It was like a major goal of his and he seemed to be doing it out of strong beleif and goodwill. (apart from wanting to be remembered for it)

Yeah, I agree I respect Clinton more now that he's gone, Bush just doesnt seem articulate enough to lead our nation at times at times and Im not bushbasher either, alot of things I agree with.
Im an independant,but I like the hardline of the foreign policy at times. In retrospect, if we knew what we know now about Iraq, the war Id have to admit was a mistake. At the time prior, I thought it was the right decision at the time and now I can admit that given the info we now know, that I was wrong. It may still be the right course, the media reports make it seem like the sky is falling over there, but I dont think its that bad and it may improve rapidly and a few years we'll look and think Bush was a genius for the war who knows, youd have to have a crystal ball. Afterall, any war you can find horrible things happening, thats just part of war. But in comparison with others wars of the century, it could hardly be classified as EVEN a major battle in terms of casualties. As I stated before to someone that had no ability to put things into perspective. In WW1, The battle of Verdunne, one battle, 700,000 soldiers were killed. IN WW2, the estimated amount of soldiers and civilians killed as a result, was about 50 million. So in terms of scale, this is not very big. Just gonna have some tough times and transition periods, we arent losing the war by any means.

Im pretty much neutral on alot of these issues, but I sure wish some of the people who argue with you had the intellect and ability to place themselves into other peoples shoes for a moment and ask themselves what they would do? How they would think? etc... Like what if they were born an raised in Israel. I look at what happens in Israel with the attacks and I cant help but think that I would react even stronger if that happened in my neighborhood. I think alot of Americans lack the ability to see the world except from the safety of a separate, stable continent.
As far as some of the others, its like they never had a class in history, have no knowledge 20th century history and what has occurred up to this point and have only the ability to form their opinion from when they first watched television and thought about the world and now. A very short time in historical terms to guage the situation. I think my generation and younger lack the ability to see long term and to think in large spaces of time.
And even other still, who for some reason, dont accept the right of Israel to exist. I guess thatd be fine if they actually knew why they thought that way. I mean I guess is just lack of thinking through all facets of a situation. THey think if Israel wasnt there, problem would be solved that simple, failing to realize what a complex issue it is. I dont see how you could even stand to argue with someone who cant think in complex abstract terms to deal with world and global issues such as this. I mean I just dont know how you do it. I cant even read this whole thread. I dont know the answer to the israeli palestinian issue. But I sure as hell know that some of the mental midgets on the board who say the stupidest things dont either.
Why do you even bother arguing with him?
Youre not going to be able to change their mind, itd takes years to do that. They seem to lack all sense of perspective.
 
Hey man, thats a great post, you definitely seem to understand that every story has 3 or more sides and are able to look at things both from your point of view while seeing the other sides. Good discussion without arguments is so rare on these boards...

Regarding answering certain people, some I don't answer but when it comes to GD I really think he sounds like a liberal and Idealist and that is something I really respect. I am pretty sure he is highly intelligent (apart from being argumentative) I just think that if anyone was brainwashed it was him or should I say (as he can also see this) You - GD by Australian press. There is a strong anti Israel propaganda all over the world, the US is one of the only countries that is pro Israel.

I felt that maybe at one point we could actually understand each other and communicate normally here. I have benefited for sure from some of your posts GD, and I am always happy to scrutinize my mindset and views, but I also think you could gain by opening your mind to the reality of the situation being discussed instead of trying to find someone to point that finger at.

Anyway, if I see someone is a dumb kid I definitely prefer not to answer them but GD is definitely not that. He tries to rip me apart yes, but so far it has not lost control so I am still (at this point) enjoying the debate.
 
Allon said:
Hey man, thats a great post, you definitely seem to understand that every story has 3 or more sides and are able to look at things both from your point of view while seeing the other sides. Good discussion without arguments is so rare on these boards...

Regarding answering certain people, some I don't answer but when it comes to GD I really think he sounds like a liberal and Idealist and that is something I really respect. I am pretty sure he is highly intelligent (apart from being argumentative) I just think that if anyone was brainwashed it was him or should I say (as he can also see this) You - GD by Australian press. There is a strong anti Israel propaganda all over the world, the US is one of the only countries that is pro Israel.

I felt that maybe at one point we could actually understand each other and communicate normally here. I have benefited for sure from some of your posts GD, and I am always happy to scrutinize my mindset and views, but I also think you could gain by opening your mind to the reality of the situation being discussed instead of trying to find someone to point that finger at.

Anyway, if I see someone is a dumb kid I definitely prefer not to answer them but GD is definitely not that. He tries to rip me apart yes, but so far it has not lost control so I am still (at this point) enjoying the debate.

Thanks, Ive studied the world and its issues for a long time, sorta my hobby if I was to have, sorta a political junkie.Watch all the debates listen to all sides then try and then form an opinion. I admit that I rarely have the intellect even with all that to form a solution, just educated views and I enjoy discussing different points of view and I often change positions if someone can explain how they arrived at their position in articulate logical ways. Its positive thing and I enjoy it.
Ive found alot of people post naive points of view here on this board with the total inability to help me understand how they arrived at their conclusion. I post on these political threads sometimes, but usually throw my hands in there and say why bother. This isnt going to help me understand or learn a thing and they lack the ability to conceive my points of view, they just lack the background of events and how one situation may affect another. Its said that a great chess player can think in terms of twenty moves ahead, same with politics only some can only think in terms of one or two here. Im not here to rip on these guys either, I think some of these guys on here are very smart, just in the beginning phase of learning what is going on in the world. I was there once afterall, and how wrong some my arguments were LOL! Others, it just makes feel sorry for them.
I find more stimulating discussions with others off the board with have had similar interests in world politics and have had viewed these issues for a long time, alot of patients that I see and work with are older, they have a long perspective of the world so maybe Im spoiled.
 
Last edited:
You know what brothabill, I take it back, I just reread one GD's posts and realized I missed it beofre when he said
"my position on the need for the state of israel is clear - theres no real need for it. if the jews are such clever, money making little mofos, let them nicely make money where tehy are and not stir up shit half the world over."

GD, if you were a idealist you would never say something like that. You are obviously racist and more biased than I thought. I wish you had said that to my face. I dare you to walk up to a Jew and say something like that, I would never say something like that to anyone, no matter what race.

You gotta be joking to think you can walk up to an Israeli, even here on a message board and say something like that and expect for him or anyone else to take you seriously.
Take a hike.

If you had said it to my face you would not be walking anywhere. Now fuck off.
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom