http://mywebpages.comcast.net/wjambruzs/HIT.htm
in support of the thread starter. don't read the above if you don't have an open mind.
Two important things said by SSAlexSS
"Why high volume is logical? Muscle growth because of work it does, not how much it lifts in 1 set. More work in unit time means bigger muscles, since you need stronger and more energetical muscle to tolerate more tension. "
= work capacity...a bigger muscle will have larger work capacity measured by load lifted across units ot time. be it a workout, a microcycle or a meso cycle. track it and as long as it progressively increase over time..you will be bigger. load is important as represented by respectable poundages in the 50-80% 1RM .i am not saying you will get larger doing reps in the 30% 1RM range!!
"Also some people say that "training 6 days per week is not very intensive or else you would overtraing." You need intensityu they say. YES but, you need to progressively increase it. If you train super intense 2 days per week and start training 6 days per week with the same intensity and puking every minute - Yes you will overtraiin. But if you start slowly and work your way up,
eventully you could train as intensily on a 6 days per week program"
this is the key to why people diss high volume...they are HIT in the heart make the switch..and proceeded to do 20 sets a day for 6days/week and complain when they overtrain/get small/get sick...need to make the switch progressively. 5% more sets a week, something moderate!
additional, my personal opinion is that whilst training to failure is a great asset..its overuse is a big problem. training to failure on a set in HIT individuals in my case led to a large drop in weight lifted on subsequent sets=reduced load=reduced tension.
similar related to this i don't do high reps due to lactic acid build up..fatigue..and knock on load/tension on subsequent sets...so its 5-7reps sets..1-2 reps short of failure.
just my view after training for many years and utilising HIT for many of them and now a higher volume convert that monitors performance from a load perspective (weight *reps) relative to a unit of time..which means a workout(in minutes) or micro cycle (15 days) or longer.
blitz periods of higher load occassioanlly and back off periods of lower loads for restoration and recuperation.
i expect flames!! never mind that i don't think i have ever posted on here before!
In Iron
Charlie