b fold the truth said:
CCJ: I just watched all the OL clips that you put up the other day and I thank you for them A LOT!!! They will go into my mpeg video library.
I noticed a few things.
When they did full high bar squats OR front squats...they are just as deep or maybe about 1" deeper than my box squats are. My box squats are about 1" below parallel and WSB suggests 2" I believe. I don't see where depth is a real issue in comparison between the OL Squat and the wide stanced box squat on depth...
When the lifters catch the clean or snatch at the bottom in the full squat position...they are closer to the stance width of a wide stance box squat than a close stance OL squat. Well, I'd say that it is somewhere in between the two to be honest.
I know very little about OL lifting (as you know for sure...lol) and I hope that you take note of that.
I have worked with quite a few athletes though and a common weakness that I seen in them is hip strength. Another weakness is the strength of every muscle in the back side of the body. The box squat hits ALL of those muscles. I really can't say that about the OL Squat for myself. Once again...it is just my experience.
Also, I hope that you note that I do box squats, high bar OL squats, wide stanced free squats, and front squats. I believe that ALL of them serve a good and big purpose for the athlete and their development.
Please...give me your thoughts...I'm really interested in what you think.
B True
Well when people look at squat depth they forget the most important thing, joint ROM. You butt maybe as low as the olylifters, but your knee angle is not the same. It's not just the hip angle, its the knee angle as well. Typically when most olylifters do fullsquats, the hip crease will not be much lower than parallel, unless they are really skinny, But the knee angle will be really acute. Also with a wide stance, the ROM is also shortened slightly.
With a box squat one must also lean quite a bit forward to sitback, whereas when one rises out of cleans and snatches you have to be upright and the hips will be closer to the ankles.
Plus in boxsquats the centre of gravity is behind the ankles, so the muscles have to flex forward rather than upwards.
Boxsquats can help pulling power, but because of the double knee rebend in the 2nd pull, again the body is position is actually closer to a high bar squat - knees forward, torso quite upright, centre of gravity slightly forward - except in the snatch where you are quiet bent over forward.
I've put boxsquats forward to CT before, and he says if they did help, elite olylifters would be doing them. There is another guy I know on Dr squat, whose coach knows Louie, and he has taught him box squats. He did try them but found they did not help oly recovery strength.
When you rise from a clean/snatch recovery, it's leg strength, rather than hip strength that's the main factor since your can't really lean to far forward. I would say olylifters are not weak in the hips and posterior chain as a rule, because of the amount of heavy pulls they do. They really are pulling machines, and pulls hit the posterior chain hard. You need strong glutes to pull heavy cleans in the correct body position from the floor. Unlike powerlifting deadlifts, your back has to remain at the same angle, and this requires strong glutes, hams and erectors.
Olysquats don't tax the erectors as hard, but do hit the abs harder becuase of the more upright stance. With the amount of pulls olylifters do this is probbaly a good thing

there are good mornings and other things for that.
Don't forget that Olylifts do quite a bit of heavy drop snatches and frontsquats with the same stance they use for recovery strength.
For myself, I have a big butt and hams from olysquats, even the way I do front squats nail my hams and glutes just as hard as my quads

I just find full squats to be more of a general all rounder that hits all the muscles of the lower body evenly. But that just maybe for my body type, and squatting style who knows. That is appealing in itself, you save time by not having to do different squats etc.
I have dabbled a bit in boxsquats as you may recall. I can't tell if they helped or not. I am willing to try everything once or twice, whatever it takes.