You're comparing a 6'1" dude to a 5'7" dude? Both 200lbs and equal body fat? Of course the shorter dude will be bigger, he has more muscle. A taller guy has to be heavier, but that's all. Not more muscle. That's obvious. But all things equal except the actual weight of the individual? Genetic makeup is what seperates those two more.
Sent from my SCH-I545 using EliteFitness