I use butterface as "pudgy", you can be pretty and still have a butter face imo. I think she's pretty too, wonder what her personality is like, her eyes say she's nice.... and tig ol bitties, at least what you can see....
We need a second pic like you said, have them stand up....
The other blond is definately the prettiest, but she just has a look that, idk, looks like she could say "I'm not feeling good, I have a upset stomach/headache, I think I'll go on to bed" yada yada. The other one looks like she'd be saying, ' Where the HELL is that damn waitress with the drinks?"
I pick that one....