Please Scroll Down to See Forums Below
napsgear
genezapharmateuticals
domestic-supply US-PHARMACIES UGL OZ
Raptor Labs UGFREAK OxygenPharm
napsgeargenezapharmateuticals domestic-supplyUS-PHARMACIES UGL OZUGFREAKRaptor LabsOxygenPharm

The problem with the death penalty

MAX 300

New member
Here's an example where the death penalty ought to apply:

http://www.news.com.au/common/story_page/0,4057,10684059%5E26462,00.html

Armed break in and robbery into a family's house should deserve long sentences of hard prison time. 20 years at least.

But these guys went further, time's up for them

Those three men who did this to that girl deserve to hang.

There were previous articles on this case -

Here's the problem though, what if it wasn't them?

The police, the prosecutors, the judges are too eager to get convictions. In a crime like this they have to find who's guilty or they're in the shitter.
 
MAX 300 said:
Here's an example where the death penalty ought to apply:

http://www.news.com.au/common/story_page/0,4057,10684059%5E26462,00.html

Armed break in and robbery into a family's house should deserve long sentences of hard prison time. 20 years at least.

But these guys went further, time's up for them

Those three men who did this to that girl deserve to hang.

There were previous articles on this case -

Here's the problem though, what if it wasn't them?

The police, the prosecutors, the judges are too eager to get convictions. In a crime like this they have to find who's guilty or they're in the shitter.

Exactly. I understand the death penalty on a philosophical level, but on a practical level it is indefensible.

Punishments must be reversible because absolute guilt can not be determined.

It is even a bad idea to execute people like Saddam, because we will make a martyr out of him.
 
the problem with the death penalty is that it takes so long befor we enforce it. waste so many tax dollars housing/feeding/entertaining/and finally lethally injecting these fuckers. if someone gets convicted, take 'em out back and put a bullet in their head. instead of spending $1000s upon $1000s a $.15 bullet does the trick.
 
There was this girl that worked in a convenient store when i was 24 in college i had a crush on, man ! She was a living doll ,great personality ( Sandra Allen) 3 black men abducted her from work took her to the woods raped her made her preform oral before they killed her & buried her in a shallow grave--it took 25 years before everyone finally got the chair!
I still get choked up thinking about it!

I still cannot get over how her parents let her work in a seedy part of town like that, the blacks hung around the store all day looked like they never bathed and drank.

They should have just turned them over to me and been done with it!
RADAR
 
Last edited:
The main problem with the death penalty is it doesn't work.

Deterrance is the point, but across the US when states would introduce the death penalty there was no change in rates of violent crime. If it doesn't actually prevent crime that basically just makes it for the sake of revenge.
 
casualbb said:
The main problem with the death penalty is it doesn't work.

Deterrance is the point, but across the US when states would introduce the death penalty there was no change in rates of violent crime. If it doesn't actually prevent crime that basically just makes it for the sake of revenge.
'


I think it would prevent crime IF it was enforced. Like ripper2 said it takes too damn long to enforce. If you get the death penalty there is a automatic appeal. Most other crimes you have to go before a judge to get a appeal and still can be denied. But not in death penalty cases. So if people knew they would be dead within 24 hours of convicts no questions ask. I think it would work as a crime preventive. Just like here in a town right next door. It is the law you own a handgun. You know what they have virtaully no crime to speak of. WHY ?? Because criminals know their victim just might be holdin cold steel. So deterrance does work.

Maxpain
 
it prevents tax payers from having to support killers for the rest of their lives- paying for their food, dentists, doctors, entertainment, etc.
It prevents some sicko from wanting to commit a 'simple robbery' and finishing with a murder and then living out the rest of his life with the right to sue the state, with the right to torment the victims family, and with the right to actually be free again.
 
I can't support the death penalty, but I acknowledge it is mostly on religious grounds. Such extreme forms of vengeance have no place in a civil society (imo).

Aside from that, what bothers me the most, are the numbers of convictions later turned over due to later evidence (such as dna testing). In some states the rate of innocent people convicted of murder which were later overturned was a s high as 10%. That's fucking outrageous, and not even close to acceptable in terms of where we would need to be to morally operate under strict death penalty laws.

Once they are in custody, they are no longer a threat. I have no desire to play God with lives unnecessarily.
 
if there is a single person living on "death row" then it hasn't been used enough. pull 'em outta those cells and finish 'em off. any animal that cannot live within the socially acceptable norms of our society has no place here.
 
Hmm, there have been a lot of people on death row who have later been exonerated.

Kill everybody on death row right now and you'll kill a lot of innocent people as well.
 
It´s not like it´s cool to give an innocent man life either though I don´t see the big difference

jailtime is NOT reversible you can´t turn back time
 
IwouldSlamU said:
i think it is over used....ie TEXAS.........




For once I strongly believe that the State of Texas should be our role model for dealing with scum like this and execute them.
 
the system is inherently flawed and its as simple as that. Breaking the law is a money making machine in the US and its ridiculous.

I havent decided whether I support the death penalty or not but it is certainly not working as a deterent. More laws does not mean more conscious law abiding citizens, it just creates more law breakers.

I dont like the idea that I support people on death row - support their prison housing etc. But if it were someone who got life it would be even more money to fund their incarceration.

That on the other hand is a horrible story. Maybe a Lex Talionis type deal would be good....bring in the porn industries finest and have them go at his ass till he's wrecked, I dont know.
 
RADAR said:
There was this girl that worked in a convenient store when i was 24 in college i had a crush on, man ! She was a living doll ,great personality ( Sandra Allen) 3 black men abducted her from work took her to the woods raped her made her preform oral before they killed her & buried her in a shallow grave--it took 25 years before everyone finally got the chair!
I still get choked up thinking about it!

I still cannot get over how her parents let her work in a seedy part of town like that, the blacks hung around the store all day looked like they never bathed and drank.

They should have just turned them over to me and been done with it!
RADAR

I literally felt physically sick to my stomach reading this, but how sure are you that the right three guys road the lightning?
 
Robert Jan said:
It´s not like it´s cool to give an innocent man life either though I don´t see the big difference

jailtime is NOT reversible you can´t turn back time

But you can still let them out, even after years of hard time. At least they will still be alive and they will be vindicated.

Dying guilty and being able to die proven innocent in the end is a huge difference.
 
Tiervexx said:
I literally felt physically sick to my stomach reading this, but how sure are you that the right three guys road the lightning?


DNA samples found on the body!
One later confessed which let to the matching of DNA to the others.
RADAR
 
RADAR said:
There was this girl that worked in a convenient store when i was 24 in college i had a crush on, man ! She was a living doll ,great personality ( Sandra Allen) 3 black men abducted her from work took her to the woods raped her made her preform oral before they killed her & buried her in a shallow grave--it took 25 years before everyone finally got the chair!

RADAR said:
DNA samples found on the body!
One later confessed which let to the matching of DNA to the others.
RADAR

RADAR, that does not add up.

This occured at least 25 years ago? No police department in the world preserved DNA samples 25 years ago.
 
MAX 300 said:
RADAR, that does not add up.

This occured at least 25 years ago? No police department in the world preserved DNA samples 25 years ago.

Dude! They only recently did this, as the confessions gave them the death penalty, however lawyers kept battling over & over about how flawed the investigation was, loopholes,etc!
The DNA evidence finally convicted them without a doubt!

RADAR
 
True or not, it sickens me. The thing I'm against most is rape. Some people are so fucking twisted. And my mom always said I had no reason to hate this world when I was younger. -_-

Shouldn't even let people off with the death penalty. Lock them in a fucking "room, maybe 4'x4'. Let them curl up in there, in a strait jacket. Keep them alive. Have the tiny box padded up. Have a speaker just 24/7 torment them with screams of rape victims, and let the guilt rack up in them. Remidn them all the rest of their lives, every second, what they did.

I hate people that can bring themselves to do something so sadistic.
 
Tom Treutlein said:
True or not, it sickens me. The thing I'm against most is rape. Some people are so fucking twisted. And my mom always said I had no reason to hate this world when I was younger. -_-

Shouldn't even let people off with the death penalty. Lock them in a fucking "room, maybe 4'x4'. Let them curl up in there, in a strait jacket. Keep them alive. Have the tiny box padded up. Have a speaker just 24/7 torment them with screams of rape victims, and let the guilt rack up in them. Remidn them all the rest of their lives, every second, what they did.

I hate people that can bring themselves to do something so sadistic.

I think that some rapists might even like that.
 
RADAR said:
Dude! They only recently did this, as the confessions gave them the death penalty, however lawyers kept battling over & over about how flawed the investigation was, loopholes,etc!
The DNA evidence finally convicted them without a doubt!

RADAR

ummm, no.

It is VERY easy to get emotional with things like this, but it is NEVER that simple.

There is always more to it than that, and an infinate number of possiblities for evidence tampering. Some gangs understand enough about how the system works to use little things like that to frame people, and it would be extremely easy to frame people if your idea of an investigation is that simple.


And confessions are not exactly reliable anyway. Police are known for coercing them out of people.
 
onebigab said:
For once I strongly believe that the State of Texas should be our role model for dealing with scum like this and execute them.
Guarantee me with 100% certainty that they are all actually guilty of doing the crime and I could agree with you. But, as history shows us, you can't. SO I don't support it.
 
Just one look at all the people who have been on death row and who have later been exonerated should tell anyone that the justice system is extremely flawed.

Especially when it comes to violent crimes, like murder and rape.

The police have to catch somebody in a case like that. The prosecutors must get a conviction and the judges can't afford to be the spoilers and let people off the hook.

Worst of all are probably the juries of your so called peers, it's essentially a popularity contest at that stage.

Should a man hang for raping and/or killing a girl? Absolutely.

Can this justice system safely determine that it was really him? Unlikely.
 
The worst is that even if someone commits the crime, if you have a lawyer who's a smooth talker, you can get out of it.

"It's not what you know. It's what you can prove."
 
Tom Treutlein said:
The worst is that even if someone commits the crime, if you have a lawyer who's a smooth talker, you can get out of it.

"It's not what you know. It's what you can prove."

Sounds like you are more interested in witch hunts than finding the truth.
 
A good portion of the time there is 100% proof, eye witnesses, dna samples nowadays, confessions in detail (leading police to the body in many cases) there are a lot of grey cases out there but for the ones that are BLACK AND FUCKING WHITE don't even begin to defend those animals. Lord I hope you guys would at least put together a certain mass murderers a la John Wayne Gacy to death considering his house and yard had a whole bunch of people buried
 
Austin316 said:
A good portion of the time there is 100% proof, eye witnesses, dna samples nowadays, confessions in detail (leading police to the body in many cases) there are a lot of grey cases out there but for the ones that are BLACK AND FUCKING WHITE don't even begin to defend those animals. Lord I hope you guys would at least put together a certain mass murderers a la John Wayne Gacy to death considering his house and yard had a whole bunch of people buried

In reality cases are almost never black and white.

Many people have been put to death with much less than what you think.

Eye witnesses can always lie and/or be mistaken.

Police who already know where the body is can easily coerce these "detailed" confessions out of people. And police have been found to coerce confessions out of people.

You have to assume that criminals might be intelligent. If you are going to take such a reckless look at evidence than it is not hard at all for a cleaver man who wishes to get away with is crime to plant DNA, hair, and any number of other samples, as well as burry bodies in someone else's flower garden.

Furthermore, it is very naĂŻve to think that governments can be trusted with the power to execute its citizens. Power will always be abused. It is not a question of if it will be abused; it is only a question of how much of it they have to abuse.
 
The rate of exoneration is NOT that high at all.



MAX 300 said:
Just one look at all the people who have been on death row and who have later been exonerated should tell anyone that the justice system is extremely flawed.

Especially when it comes to violent crimes, like murder and rape.

The police have to catch somebody in a case like that. The prosecutors must get a conviction and the judges can't afford to be the spoilers and let people off the hook.

Worst of all are probably the juries of your so called peers, it's essentially a popularity contest at that stage.

Should a man hang for raping and/or killing a girl? Absolutely.

Can this justice system safely determine that it was really him? Unlikely.
 
I don't believe in prison. If someone has a conscience at all, he knows within fifteen minutes "Hey, I screwed up." It does not take twenty years to convince anyone of that, if they are capable of understanding it.

My dad once put it this way: "If someone is so dangerous that he has to be locked in a box, he's too dangerous to live. Put him down the same way you'd put down any dangerous animal, and for the same reason. Otherwise give him a shovel and put him to work."
 
I'd much rather have one or two wrongly accused people on death row, than paying millions to keep the *right* people alive and in jail.

strongsmartsexy said:
Well DUH! Because you're not an innocent person convited of a crime you didn't commmit and are about to be executed.
 
Code said:
I'd much rather have one or two wrongly accused people on death row, than paying millions to keep the *right* people alive and in jail.
As long as they never come off of death row to be executed. Killing one or two innocent people to support the death penalty is morally bankrupt.
 
Paying millions each year to keep properly convicted felons alive is financially bankrupt.

strongsmartsexy said:
As long as they never come off of death row to be executed. Killing one or two innocent people to support the death penalty is morally bankrupt.
 
Code said:
Paying millions each year to keep properly convicted felons alive is financially bankrupt.
Do you mean the felons who have been nailed smoking pot? Or the felons caught using AAS, or the felons who robbed a bank, or the felons who killed someone?
 
Death penalty peeps.

And aggravated rape, and molestation felons.




strongsmartsexy said:
Do you mean the felons who have been nailed smoking pot? Or the felons caught using AAS, or the felons who robbed a bank, or the felons who killed someone?
 
Code said:
Death penalty peeps.

And aggravated rape, and molestation felons.
And your belief is the fractional cost of housing those people versus the entire prison population is worth the cost of potentially executing innocent people?
 
Well, here's my take. It's not about preventing crime but raw punishment.

There is no greater right to remove from someone than taking away their right to live. There are (and should be) circumstances that dictate the use of this, murder, aggravated rape and child molestation are (IMO) the right circumstance.


Do I think the laws need to be revised to allow for looser sentencing for some crimes? Yes. But that isn't going to happen. Do I think prison's are being used improperly? Yes. Do I think prison should be about punsihment, not rehabilitation? Yes.

But I don't think we should stop executing criminals because the system is flawed. No formal system is perfect, I can live with the results of an imperfect system.


strongsmartsexy said:
And your belief is the fractional cost of housing those people versus the entire prison population is worth the cost of potentially executing innocent people?
 
strongsmartsexy said:
Do you mean the felons who have been nailed smoking pot? Or the felons caught using AAS, or the felons who robbed a bank, or the felons who killed someone?

No; no; yes, if they keep doing it after they've been properly horsewhipped and/or put to honest work (see my post above); and hell, yes! but see below for how I'd implement it (if you catch them red-handed).

We need a fundamental reform to the entire justice system first. For instance, the question asked elsewhere, "Do you need thirty-round magazines for your gun?" That question is abhorrent to the US Constitution. Just like criminalizing pot, AAS, or whatever, it throws away the presumption of innocence. It is unconstitutional to criminalize the mere possession of anything. Seriously. The only true basis of a crime is criminal behavior. It's not what you have that makes you a felon; it's what you do.

If you can arrest someone because of what they have, then every man should be in jail as a "potential rapist." Possession of ANYTHING should not be prosecutable. Period. It warps and twists the justice system and must be abolished before we can restore it to sanity.

Now that you've emptied the prisons, suddenly the problem becomes a bit more manageable. Certainty of punishment is the key to getting the attention of would-be criminals. If the police are focussing on real (for lack of a better word) crimes, the certainty of punishment goes way up, and the crime rate goes way down.

But I would not stop there. No, the cops don't get to throw the guy up against a wall because his pocket has a gun-shaped bulge -- that's mere possession. If he pulls it out without good reason, I would let society as a whole teach him that he doesn't get to take more than one or two people with him. No hiding places, no "gun-free zones" (by definition, places full of defenseless targets). Let's see what happens with lots and lots of parents and fit young men recently out of the military, all with unlimited concealed carry permits.

No sig because I'm not posting this as an admin, just another EF Plat.
 
Code said:
Well, here's my take. It's not about preventing crime but raw punishment.

There is no greater right to remove from someone than taking away their right to live. There are (and should be) circumstances that dictate the use of this, murder, aggravated rape and child molestation are (IMO) the right circumstance.


Do I think the laws need to be revised to allow for looser sentencing for some crimes? Yes. But that isn't going to happen. Do I think prison's are being used improperly? Yes. Do I think prison should be about punsihment, not rehabilitation? Yes.

But I don't think we should stop executing criminals because the system is flawed. No formal system is perfect, I can live with the results of an imperfect system.

The issue with you LIVING with the results of an imperfect system is that you can do so because it doesn't directly effect you. Very noble huh? Now if on the other hand you were willing to give up your life to support this imperfect system then there is something noble about that. Misguided, but noble none the less.

In issues of prosectution, they attempt to obtain the highest level of conviction they can possibly get whether it's warranted or not. Their pay and reputation are based on this. Right and wrong be dammed. And the hand picking of juries of least common denominator intelligence works to the significant detriment of this system and the people being pushed through the system.

I watched a jury deliberation on TV where they were trying to figure out if it was "self-defense" or not for this man who killed another man in a shootout. One of the legal triggers for deciding self-defense was (paraphrased) whether the defendant provoked the other person to use deadly force. Interestingly enough, they stopped at "the defendant provoked", and completely ignored the "to use deadly force" part of the condition. They kept hammering that it couldn't be self-defense because they felt the defendant "provoked" the confrontation. Which he clearly did. They issue they overlooked was that they (prosecution) couldn't prove that he provoked the other man to use deadly force. They then ruled out self-defense. Tsk tsk tsk.

The legal system railroads people through. The notion of "justice" is an afterthought in the pursuit of the system of legality we have. What is "just" about putting someone in jail for using marijuana? What is just about puttig someone in jail for AAS use?

I will agree that there are crimes which should warrant the death penalty. I'm not trying to convince you otherwise. However I also believe that no one innocent should be put to death. And that to sacrifice someone elses innocent life to support a known flawed system is not something I can morally stomach.
 
Code said:
Well, here's my take. It's not about preventing crime but raw punishment.

There is no greater right to remove from someone than taking away their right to live. There are (and should be) circumstances that dictate the use of this, murder, aggravated rape and child molestation are (IMO) the right circumstance.


Do I think the laws need to be revised to allow for looser sentencing for some crimes? Yes. But that isn't going to happen. Do I think prison's are being used improperly? Yes. Do I think prison should be about punsihment, not rehabilitation? Yes.

But I don't think we should stop executing criminals because the system is flawed. No formal system is perfect, I can live with the results of an imperfect system.

This is extremely irrational.

You acknowledge the fact that there is a very real risk to killing innocent people, but you think that is justified for the emotional gratification of vengeance?

If such punishments really did deter crime than it would make some sense, and might be worth the risk as less innocent people might die that way, but it is not the case.
 
What I mean to say is that the goal of a justice system should be to protect innocents, not to satisfy animalistic rage.
 
Top Bottom