BIKINIMOM said:
I agree with what you are saying to a great extent. There are cases of situational depression that have nothing to do with all of that. Then the real question becomes, NOW WHAT?
Either way you have to keep getting back up. Easier said than done - I KNOW better than anyone. But IF I did it, then everyone else can too.
what youd need to do is look at the root cause of the depression
the root cause may be something as nonspecific as a chemical imbalance in the brain caused by cumulative exposure to various chemicals/temperatures/afferent feedbacks in the environment, that are beyond our ability to identify and/or quantify. in that case, a possible solution may be (as much as i dislike them) antidepressant drugs. another solution is to force the individual to undertake a set of behaviours that ultimately manifest in them hitting a critical mass of happiness that then becomes self sustaining, and grows - which is what yorue talking about - sucking it up,g etting up, using your rational brain to make the decision to "keep going" until your neural chemistry returns to a positive state and remains so
other causes of depression may not be tied in to validation or approval seeking. stuff like death/loss, illness, morbidity, lifestyle change, relationship changes, social aspects - whatever. we're humans. we're complicated.
the important idea here, i think, is to identify what the root cause of the problem is, and address it.
imo one of the main causes of depression in modern times is because we are under so much pressure to be a certain way, when in fact, the ideal that we are taught to strive for is actually far removed from what we as human beings actually want.
when i talk to people.students about this stuff, i simplify it by saying that humans, in order to be happy, need:
a little exercise everyday
some social interaction everyday
a little sexy social interaction everyday (depends on age etc)
good food
good sleep
a "Cave"/sanctuary (a spot that they call home that they can run back to and feel secure in)
and to create something (sometimes in a job - building something, accomplishing something. sometimes a hobby.)
thats it.
but instead, society (and the people that run our society) train us to want to work, to be rich, to have material things etc under the premise that if we do lots of work and have lots of money and have lots of material things, then those 6 or so things listed above will come to you - which is total fucking bullshit.
go to greece, and watch how people live. at 11am, everyone goes home and has a snooze for 2 hours. in australia, most of the time, i have a 30 minute lunchbreak.
in greece, peopel treat a house as someplace to put their things, to have a sleep, and have their room as their sanctuary. they leave their house often to go hand with their friends/relatives and have social interaction. in australia, people build giant forts as houses, and live their lives hiding behind those doors - playing playstation, talking through the internet, saving social interaction for either 1) work or 2) weekend booze fuelled binges
in greece (and the whole of europe) the family unit is alive and well, even in that traditional male/female roles are still in effect, which ties into sanctuary and meaningful social interaction. in australia, the family unit is fragmented - both parents work, and the raising of the child is left to some childcare worker, or worse yet, the television - which then indoctrinates your child with the idea that money solves all your problems, and that the key to happiness is consumption
and we wonder why first world nations are experiencing ballooning rates of depressive disorders