SofaGeorge said:
1. Holyfield - Why? Because his fights were among the most exciting fights in boxing history. Damn near every one of them was a classic. Secondly, he was never a true heavyweight. He was a cruiser who buffed up to fight with the big boys. That is an incredible accomplishment. Holyfield heart and soul is what great boxing is about.
Zerxes said:I'm no Boxing expert or anything, but I do know a little bit, and I don't put Tyson up there with the best quite frankly. He was a bully in the ring, up until the point when good Boxers started to figure out his style. Then he was nothing. Any good boxer, who wasn't totally intimidated by the guy, could, would, and did, beat his ass.
Maybe up until 1989 he was on his way, but he chose another route.
MattTheSkywalker said:
Hence the qualifier 'pre-Robin Givens' when decribing Mike's greatness.
Tyson lacked the competition of the Ali-Foreman-Frazier-Norton era, so it is hard to gauge him against that type of fighter. He had to make due with Carl Williams and Michael Spinks.
Tyson was also a rproudct of the $20M fight era, so there were no shortage of people around wuith their hands out. It;s too bad, in a way, because he could have settled this best ever dispute if he had maintained any focus.
I;d have to say Ali was the best ever, Unmatched combo of speed and strength.
Zerxes said:I'm no Boxing expert or anything, but I do know a little bit, and I don't put Tyson up there with the best quite frankly. He was a bully in the ring, up until the point when good Boxers started to figure out his style. Then he was nothing. Any good boxer, who wasn't totally intimidated by the guy, could, would, and did, beat his ass.
Maybe up until 1989 he was on his way, but he chose another route.
HUCKLEBERRY FINNaplex said:Marciano for his size was probably the toughest/hardest puncher.
BeefyBull said:
Muhammad Ali vs. Mike Tyson, both at their very prime = Ali getting decimated by Tyson, probably within 6 rounds
bullett said:And Ali could take a punch, remember fighting Joe Frazier with a broken jaw for 10 rounds?
I would say Ali. If you watch some of those fights, he was so accurate with his punches...he hit Frazier on the button every time he threw. I also believe without a doubt that he was the SMARTEST of all the heavyweight champs. He knew how to get in their head (made Sonny Liston quit), knew how to manupulate them in the ring, knew how to craft a strategy (rope a dope), etc....the guy was smart. He also knew how to play the media.
I remember seeing George Foreman fight Joe Frazier and almost knock his head off...I think he knocked him down six times in two rounds....now rememeber Ali never knocked him out...and I thought NO ONE could beat him. like 6'4", pure muscle, hit like a freight train...then I saw Ali make him look like a fool...UNBELIEVEABLE, easily done. How much moxy does it take to plan to allow him to beat on you for 10 rounds until he tires himself out? Angelo Dundee was not even privy to that strategy, and was screaming at ALi to fight....
Anyway, for all the reasons above, I think Ali was the best, plus he lost 3 years in his ABSOLUTE prime due to the draft thing.
I think in his prime, he could have beaten anyone else in their prime. The guy was an artist..
And for you guys who will say Tyson, Tyson, Tyson, remember fuckin Buster Douglas knocking him out...he couldn't take a punch. He beat most people by pounding them into submission, and he didn't get hit. Now, that is something, he was quick, and awesome, fast, powerful, etc...but I believe Ali would have beaten him, cause he was so smart...
NOW give me some karma......
The Unjust said:
I must retort. It was Norton who broke Ali's jaw.
Personally, I believe the Ali/Foreman fight was fixed. Foreman threw very few punches to Ali's head in this fight. Most of the punches he threw were to Ali's hips where he wore a protective cover.
Tyson's jaw was better than most in the division. Buster Douglas had a career night, was motivated by the death of his mother, and Tyson took him as lightly as if he were fighting a featherweight.
The best heavyweight of all time is a difficult thing to assess. However, basing it on stats vs era of difficulty, Ali would have to be #1.
powerforward said:Tyson never beat a great fighter, he was humilated twice by holyfield and killed by lewis. Ali beat great fighters (liston,frazier,foreman,quarry). But, given the argument about today's guys being bigger and stronger, I would probably say that Lennox would beat Ali 9 out of 10 times if they fought. One other thing, the most underated champ ever= Larry Holmes.
Ali was highly skilled, and one of the best in his prime. However, aside from the fact that he was an absolute jerk, I still rate Frazier as a better fighter. While Ali turned into a lazy show-dancer, Frazier remains one of the hardest working men ever to set foot in the ring. It's interesting to note that after their fight when Ali won by knock out, Frazier went out for a night on the town to blow off steam while Ali was immediately rushed to the hospital. Now you tell me who really won?HUCKLEBERRY FINNaplex said:Ali was the highest overall skilled and fastest.Marciano for his size was probably the toughest/hardest puncher.
raider2124 said:You all have to remember that as time goes by the athletes of almost every sport get bigger,stronger,faster. No disrespect to Ali but there are a number of boxers today that would destroy him in a fight. Speaking as all these boxers were in there prime Tyson,Lewis,Holyfield,Vlad. Klitchscho, David Tua could win just because of his incredible punching power. As far as alot of you saying Marciano is the best, he was the best for his time and one of the greatest ever but no match for the fighters of today. He would be in Roy Jones Jr's weight class and that would spell the end to his undefeated record.
BeefyBull said:
What are you talking about. He's 49-4 with 2 no contests. Look at the 4 losses: 2 fights he wasnt prepared for (B. Douglas, Lewis), a 12-round thriller (Tyson/Holyfield 1), and a DQ (T/H 2). The no contest against Golota should have been a Tyson win. Golota just gave up and left the ring with his trainers chasing him. That would give Tyson 50 wins. 50 wins is more than most of history's heavyweights. Give him back his prison time & the 1 year he was banned after the Holyfield fight and he'd have 65+ wins. Mike is 37-0 in non-title fights.
Muhammad Ali vs. Mike Tyson, both at their very prime = Ali getting decimated by Tyson, probably within 6 rounds
If/When Tyson/Lewis 2 happens, if Tyson is in proper shape, focused, and not heavily drugged again, he will win.
powerforward said:Tyson never beat a great fighter, he was humilated twice by holyfield and killed by lewis. Ali beat great fighters (liston,frazier,foreman,quarry). But, given the argument about today's guys being bigger and stronger, I would probably say that Lennox would beat Ali 9 out of 10 times if they fought. One other thing, the most underated champ ever= Larry Holmes.
SofaGeorge said:
This is the gospel. It's embarrassing to see people put Mike Tyson in the same category as Ali. Tyson ducked any real competition his whole career. People got a very exagerated view of his power and ability because he got matched against tomato cans. I mean for God's sake the guy won his title beating Trevor Berbick. Who the hell has ever heard of Trevor Berbick? Tyson had the good fortune to be a good fighter during an era when there were no great contenders. He showed his true colors by ducking a fight with Holyfield his entire career. It used to be a joke in boxing that the only way Tyson was ever going to beat Holyfield was by refusing him a fight till Holyfield was too old to compete. That is literally what Tyson's camp tried to do. It was an actual legal battle that finally forced Tyson to fight Holyfield. The game wasw up. Tyson had to fight him. He couldn't hide anymore.
Silent Method said:
Ali was highly skilled, and one of the best in his prime. However, aside from the fact that he was an absolute jerk, I still rate Frazier as a better fighter. While Ali turned into a lazy show-dancer, Frazier remains one of the hardest working men ever to set foot in the ring. It's interesting to note that after their fight when Ali won by knock out, Frazier went out for a night on the town to blow off steam while Ali was immediately rushed to the hospital. Now you tell me who really won?.
TC2 said:rocky marciano with out a dought, anybody that disagrees doesn't know shit about boxing.
Mike tyson was great in his prime, I used to live to watch him fight.
But if you go back and look at rocky marciano's fights you'll see what a truley great fighter he was, and by far the hardest puncher.
HUCKLEBERRY FINNaplex said:Polish-Sugar Ray Robinson was welter/middleweight...Just thought I'd point that out.But lb for lb he may be the greatest fighter to ever step in the ring.His ability/toughness/speed/power was mind-boggling.A truly complete fighter.
MattTheSkywalker said:Mike Tyson pre Robin Givens.
bullett, read my post again, and this time put some thought into it. Yeah, Ali scored a knock out acording to officail boxing regulation. But while Frazier went out to party, Ali was rushed to the hospital. Who kicked who's ass?bullett said:Silent...read you own post...
ALI KNOCKED HIS PHILLY CHEESE_STEAK LOVIN ASS OUT
lol
Silent Method said:
bullett, read my post again, and this time put some thought into it. Yeah, Ali scored a knock out acording to officail boxing regulation. But while Frazier went out to party, Ali was rushed to the hospital. Who kicked who's ass?
BTW, record books may show different, but Frazier beat Ali TWO times before that last bout.
joack said:
I agree. The "old" Mike Tyson would knock out any heavyweight boxer who ever stepped foot in the ring, including my sentimental favorite Ali.
Yes, Tyson would beat the hell out of Rock M., Joe Luis & Ali!
Zerxes said:
EHHHHH WRONG!!! Dude, why post if you really have no idea what you are saying??? Get your history straight brother. The first fight: Frasier BEAT Ali in a DECISION!! Second fight: Frasier couldn't make it out of the corner for the 15th and final round. In other words, he quit! Third fight: another Ali victory. Do a Yahoo search or something.
Bro, come over to my house and watch the damn tapes with me.Zerxes said:EHHHHH WRONG!!! Dude, why post if you really have no idea what you are saying??? Get your history straight brother. The first fight: Frasier BEAT Ali in a DECISION!! Second fight: Frasier couldn't make it out of the corner for the 15th and final round. In other words, he quit! Third fight: another Ali victory. Do a Yahoo search or something.
Silent Method said:Bro, come over to my house and watch the damn tapes with me.
I said "BTW, record books may show different, but Frazier beat Ali TWO times before that last bout."
Look past your ass for a second. Go rent that second fight. Frazier WON, no contest.. The judges GAVE the recorded win to Ali.
In other words, he (Frazier) quit? Dude, you would't know Frazier if the knocked your ass out.
No big deal. I have an advantage as I really do have the tapes of the fights. Frazier clearly won the first two. He was robbed of the win for the second. I like to think he could have (and was) winning the third, but it was a legit loss as far as the boxing record is concerned. (Of course given the choice of being Ali in the hospital or Frazier out on the town, I know who's ass got kicked.)Zerxes said:I actually meant to delete that post brother. My apologies, because after I checked I found I was in error. The fight where Joe didn't(or couldn't) come out for the 15th round was the 3rd fight. The "Thrilla in Manilla" as it were. I've never seen the second fight, but know that Ali won so you could very well be right on that one. Don't get me wrong though, Joe was a gutsy mother fucker without doubt, and had a KILLER left hook, as Ali found out in the first fight.
joack said:
I agree. The "old" Mike Tyson would knock out any heavyweight boxer who ever stepped foot in the ring, including my sentimental favorite Ali.
Yes, Tyson would beat the hell out of Rock M., Joe Luis & Ali!
biteme said:It depends on your definition of "greatest fighter". Does that imply which boxer accomplished the most? Or who would win a fight against any other fighter when both are in their prime? Noone can ever say with certaintly who the greatest was. Styles make fights. Ali had trouble with Frazier and Norton, yet Foreman disposed of both of them easily. And yet Foreman lost to Ali. Just an example of how styles makes fights. I like Evander Holyfield, the warrior. I can't think of another fighter as tough and who accomplished as much with what he had.
SofaGeorge said:
I agree with this completely. It's why I picked Holyfield as #1. He fought many great fighters... and he fought them individually. He often adjusted his fighting style and training to take on a man... and he didn't rope a dope... He fought them. He faced them with courage like a champion.
It's odd, but with all the people who lionize Mike Tyson... they miss the point that he never won a single fight against a great contender. The few times he fought qualified boxers - he lost. He will be a very forgotten fighter after the memory of this generation fades and the media hype of the Tyson legend is long gone. You can say he could have been a great and would have been a great... but given the fact that he never won a single fight against a great boxer I'm at loss for what the myth is based on?
Would Buster Douglas have been able to last a round against George Forman? Ali? Marciano? I don't think so.
powerforward said:sofageorge is spot on. I'm not sure if i put holyfield at the top, but he's at least top 5, and a lot higher than tyson in my book.
This page contains mature content. By continuing, you confirm you are over 18 and agree to our TOS and User Agreement.
Please Scroll Down to See Forums Below 














