George Spellwin / Brr Re: Satch Vs.carth

[satchboogie]

SATCH VS. CARTH IS JULY 17TH...

we decided to have the members decide whose got the edge via a poll.
ulter mentioned that mods can edit polls and it was later suggested that we have you monitor the poll so that nobody fucks with it to favor a contestant.

are you in brotha or what?

we wanna make this as fair as can be!

thanks.

 

[slat1]

Maybe it can be posted in a few forums so nobody misses it too!

 

[TheAssholeFomerlyKnownAsDBBT]

Word life George

 

[Smokescreen]

Maybe it can be posted in a few forums so nobody misses it too!

Nice! Slat bro! Poll??? WTF??? I thought.........

 

[satchboogie]

you cant escape a poll CARTH.
what else did you expect?

maybe have your wife be the only judge??

 

[Smokescreen]

you cant escape a poll CARTH.
what else did you expect?

maybe have your wife be the only judge??

Nooooo!! CourtneyBCCA!!!! For sure!!!

 

[Mr.X]

mods don't edit polls, only ELITE mods w/ certain access can

and, either way, none of us have ANY reason to do that

 

[needsize]

you cant escape a poll CARTH.
what else did you expect?

maybe have your wife be the only judge??

that only works as long as people vote based only on physiques, not for other reasons. For those same reasons, you might actually beat me, but on any bodybuilding stage in the world, I would hand you your ass.....so the voting idea doesnt always work right

 

[satchboogie]

that only works as long as people vote based only on physiques, not for other reasons. For those same reasons, you might actually beat me, but on any bodybuilding stage in the world, I would hand you your ass.....so the voting idea doesnt always work right

like i said many times and ill make it very clear on contest day..
i DONT want people to vote for me cause we're buds.

i want the better man to win!!

and if CARTH looks better than me (which he wont i guarantee you that) ill be the first to admit it.

relax bro its fun and games..
i think y'all are takin this WAY WAY too heavily!

keep chillin brotha..

 

[needsize]

like i said many times and ill make it very clear on contest day..
i DONT want people to vote for me cause we're buds.

i want the better man to win!!

and if CARTH looks better than me (which he wont i guarantee you that) ill be the first to admit it.

relax bro its fun and games..
i think y'all are takin this WAY WAY too heavily!

keep chillin brotha..

I'm just trying to keep this fair, I had a similar experience back in the day with fonz, and it ended up anything but fair, till his mod powers were taken out of the equation, all of a sudden it was no contest

How about if everyone who votes, also posts who they voted for, and possibly why

 

[satchboogie]

How about if everyone who votes, also posts who they voted for, and possibly why

i think thats a brilliant idea!

they will vote based on the following criteria:

PROPORTION

SYMMETRY

MASS

BODYFAT

 

[satchboogie]

furthermore...

each member will vote like this example:

PROPORTION - satch

SYMMETERY - satch

MASS - carth

BODYFAT - satch

TOTAL:

SATCHBOOGIE: 3 POINTS
CARTH: 1 POINT

each member will post their points based on the above outline and we'll add the points up after 1 week or so.

 

[Smokescreen]

like i said many times and ill make it very clear on contest day..
i DONT want people to vote for me cause we're buds.

i want the better man to win!!

and if CARTH looks better than me (which he wont i guarantee you that) ill be the first to admit it.

relax bro its fun and games..
i think y'all are takin this WAY WAY too heavily!

keep chillin brotha..

I think I will look better than you. Problem is that I or should I say " all of us " know that you WILL WIN!!! THAT I GUARANTEE YOU!!!

 

[needsize]

i think thats a brilliant idea!

they will vote based on the following criteria:

PROPORTION

SYMMETRY

MASS

BODYFAT

now that sounds fair

 

[satchboogie]

I think I will look better than you. Problem is that I or should I say " all of us " know that you WILL WIN!!! THAT I GUARANTEE YOU!!!

let the shit talkin begin (with good taste and fun bro)

you WONT win!
you MAY have more mass than me but thats about it... and even thats questionable right now as i put on some mass lately.

im more lean, more defined, and much much more proportional bro it aint even funny....

ill let you enjoy your long goin thread with your woman, ice cream and nice house.. but as far as the contest go, you will enjoy a defeat by the hard work of the boogiemachine.

 

[TRAINHD]

furthermore...

each member will vote like this example:

PROPORTION - satch

SYMMETERY - satch

MASS - carth

BODYFAT - satch

TOTAL:

SATCHBOOGIE: 3 POINTS
CARTH: 1 POINT

each member will post their points based on the above outline and we'll add the points up after 1 week or so.

I think thats the only way to keep it fair IMO.

 

[Smokescreen]

let the shit talkin begin (with good taste and fun bro)

you WONT win!
you have mass over me. thats about it brotha!!

im more lean, more defined, and much much more proportional bro it aint even funny....

ill let you enjoy your long goin thread with your woman, ice cream and nice house.. but as far as the contest go, you will enjoy a defeat by the hard work of the boogiemachine.

You did work hard. That I admit. I halfassed this whole thing the whole time. Sorry! I got work to do. And my tendonitis is FUCKED UP!!!!! Never again Dbol for me!

 

[satchboogie]

so CARTH good bro and muscular freak..

do you agree on the above idea or what?

 

[Smokescreen]

so CARTH good bro and muscular freak..

do you agree on the above idea or what?

Like you said bro. We are all taking this way too seriously. If I really was taking this seriously. Don't you think I would've stuck to the horrible hell I was going through with the cutting drugs? Or trained for more days per week and for more hours? And work out with the intense pain I have in my elbow and shoulder.

I admit...I'm NOT taking it too seriously. Why? Because there is NOTHING to win here. And there ain't shit to lose. So yeah! Whatever! Sounds fine to me.

That's how you want to do it. So be it.

 

[criffer]

Satch's scoring idea sounds real good, who will be the one counting all the votes and rendering the final verdict????

 

[Apexx]

i think thats a brilliant idea!

they will vote based on the following criteria:

PROPORTION

SYMMETRY

MASS

BODYFAT

what would be the difference between PROPORTION & SYMMETRY?

 

[Stainless_Steel]

Are you guys going to be able to post the pics of same poses side by side as metioned in another thread. Also please post the pics for non-plats.

 

[Smokescreen]

I am unsubscribing to these threads. So if there is anything I must really know. Please...someone PM me. Thank you!

 

[littleb]

I think it can be a pretty fair contest, due to the fact a lot of people who vote are like me, i dont know either of you besides reading your posts, so for those of us in that boat we have no reason to be biased. just my .02

 

[satchboogie]

I am unsubscribing to these threads. So if there is anything I must really know. Please...someone PM me. Thank you!

WEAK!

 

[swordfish151]

I need to post my opinion on this one..its really not fun when one guy is hardcore ready and excited about it and the other is just "whatever" i understand there are different circumstances and i understand that no one wins anything or looses anything...but its just no fun to see Tyson step into the ring with joe shmoe...no offense to anyone...both you guys are outstanding bro's but a competition is just that...to compete...not for one person to just give up or not care before the actuall event....

 

[satchboogie]

I need to post my opinion on this one..its really not fun when one guy is hardcore ready and excited about it and the other is just "whatever" i understand there are different circumstances and i understand that no one wins anything or looses anything...but its just no fun to see Tyson step into the ring with joe shmoe...no offense to anyone...both you guys are outstanding bro's but a competition is just that...to compete...not for one person to just give up or not care before the actuall event....

especially after CARTH started that ever goin thread about his car/house/training/pics..

and even titled the thread "satch vs carth precontest pics".

shit..i had no idea that was coming.
at least he could have told me ahead of time to prepare pics.

anyhow, he's so toast it aint even funny.
im pretty much resting comfy now knowing that i won this thing..
and he feels me.. thats why he bailed out of the threads.

 

[courtneybcca]

wow can anyone say spoiled sport... carth if this isn't a big deal why are you acting like a child?

anyone that knows me knows that I will be harder on satch because I know what to expect of him..

I will vote and I like the idea to explain why you voted the way you did... Carth if the pics come in and you look better I will be the first to say it. And if satch comes in half ass I will also be the first to say it....

 

[brooklynheight]

what he said ^^^

 

[Fukkenshredded]

Carth --

You need to adjust your mindset. PM me and lets get you in the game.

 

[Little Boy]

There shouldn't even be a poll option.

Just post up in WORDS who you think wins and why, that way there's no cheating.

And I can't believe there's mods that would actually cheat....WTF?

 

[alltraps]

no poll, just post your opinons on each contestants strenghts and weaknesses.

 

[will b huge]

I need to post my opinion on this one..its really not fun when one guy is hardcore ready and excited about it and the other is just "whatever" i understand there are different circumstances and i understand that no one wins anything or looses anything...but its just no fun to see Tyson step into the ring with joe shmoe...no offense to anyone...both you guys are outstanding bro's but a competition is just that...to compete...not for one person to just give up or not care before the actuall event....

Hey SWORDFISH,

From what I have seen, CARTH/SATCH started this big thing between them about the competition and CARTH put in his signature of every post he made SATCH BOOGIEMAN vs. CARTH Pay Per VIEW JULY 17th......And everyone was pretty pumped about it and it was cool.......(Personally, I was watching and waiting with a little build up for the damn thing.....AND THEN, LATE LAST WEEK, CARTH POSTED A THREAD SAYING PRETTY MUCH HE QUITS---IT ISN'T WORTH IT TO HIM ANYMORE----HE HAS PROBLEMS WITH ONE HOUSE AND HAD TO GET ANOTHER-----AND THE CUTTING DRUGS ARE PISSING HIM OFF------Don't get me wrong, I give CARTH credit for being honest, but 2.5 weeks before the deadline, he posted the damn thread was 100 sentences long!!!!!! It disappointed me to say the least......


Anyways, a POLL sounds fair, I will compare each pic and point out reasons on exactly who and why I voted for what.........based on not just "Whos BIGGER", but for anyone that hasn't done a show or been to an IFBB Show---Judges score like the following:

Round 1--Symmetry round, Overall shape (symmetry and proportion)
THERE IS NO FLEXING/POSING IN THIS ROUND---simply view from the front and back with no ability to cover up flaws from flexing.....

Round 2--Muscularity round
MANDATORY POSES---front double bi, side chest, etc....----judges score based on overall physique, leanness compared to mass, Flat (sloppy) vs. striations through the body (RIPPED), vascularity, etc. etc......

Round 3--Posing round
This is when competitors don't have to do mandatory poses, but can pose in anyway they choose for the judges---(usually to MAXIMIZE their STRENGTHS and MINIMIZE any and all WEAKNESSES)


ALRIGHT, Anyways......We can make it as serious as you fellas would like....(Am I saying to make sure your spread your JAN/DREAM TAN all over and get your POSING Suits ON--no--FLMAO)....(although if this competition if really for something that we don't know about (like a night with the other's wife/girl or whatever)...then it may not hurt to get that tan kicking, take your diuretics, get that enima, and the last few days to completely carb deplete and right before show time eat a big FAT ASS BROWNIE----it will shock your system and make all your veins pop out everywhere---real ripped/vascular look.........

Another great tip----The night before the contest, mix up 1 cup of red wine and 50 ml of glycerine and sip this before going to bed. This helps to fill out the muscles. Glycerine temporarily draws water inside the muscle cells making them fuller. I will have the wine and glycerine again early Saturday morning. Glycerine is also a mild laxative, so it will help eliminate any bloating!!!!



OK...I'm done with my bull shit---Too much time on my hands tonight.....sorry fellas....LOL


Good Luck

 

[gtrcivic]

just don't forget to have a piece of paper with the date 7/17/05 in each pose as well to let the peanut gallery know they are from 7/17/05 and not from previous years ....

 

[swordfish151]

just don't forget to have a piece of paper with the date 7/17/05 in each pose as well to let the peanut gallery know they are from 7/17/05 and not from previous years ....

yeah thats a good idea...

 

[George Spellwin]

SATCH VS. CARTH IS JULY 17TH...

we decided to have the members decide whose got the edge via a poll.
ulter mentioned that mods can edit polls and it was later suggested that we have you monitor the poll so that nobody fucks with it to favor a contestant.

are you in brotha or what?

we wanna make this as fair as can be!

thanks.

You should post the poll on the Platinum Hardcore board to restrict voting to Plats only. Post links to the thread here. People creating lots of alters is too easy if anyone can vote.

 

[Apexx]

You should post the poll on the Platinum Hardcore board to restrict voting to Plats only. Post links to the thread here. People creating lots of alters is too easy if anyone can vote.

not a good idea. People have been reading and gearing up for this for a while now. They have been seeing the back and forth posts and checking out the update pictures every day. If u then deny them the opportunity to vote for something they have been following since it started, I think ur gonna piss a lot of people off.
Besides, I really don't think there will be enough alters to sway the contest.

 

[George Spellwin]

not a good idea. People have been reading and gearing up for this for a while now. They have been seeing the back and forth posts and checking out the update pictures every day. If u then deny them the opportunity to vote for something they have been following since it started, I think ur gonna piss a lot of people off.
Besides, I really don't think there will be enough alters to sway the contest.

There is a big Alter problem here and really no way to control it. How do you propose to keep voting fair?

 

[Apexx]

There is a big Alter problem here and really no way to control it. How do you propose to keep voting fair?

I didn't realize that the alter problem was such a big deal. Guess some people have way too much time on their hands.

As for the voting, someone mentioned this earlier, Everyone post who they voted for. That way we could weed out the alters.

 

[will b huge]

You should post the poll on the Platinum Hardcore board to restrict voting to Plats only. Post links to the thread here. People creating lots of alters is too easy if anyone can vote.

I agree with this 100% and also a newspaper or something may keep it fair too...great ideas.......so, when is the 17th ---damn, SSSTTIILLLLL another 10 days....

 

[satchboogie]

I agree with this 100% and also a newspaper or something may keep it fair too...great ideas.......so, when is the 17th ---damn, SSSTTIILLLLL another 10 days....

the newspaper idea is perfect!!!
make sure carth reads this!!!!!!!

 

[will b huge]

Hey SWORDFISH,

From what I have seen, CARTH/SATCH started this big thing between them about the competition and CARTH put in his signature of every post he made SATCH BOOGIEMAN vs. CARTH Pay Per VIEW JULY 17th......And everyone was pretty pumped about it and it was cool.......(Personally, I was watching and waiting with a little build up for the damn thing.....AND THEN, LATE LAST WEEK, CARTH POSTED A THREAD SAYING PRETTY MUCH HE QUITS---IT ISN'T WORTH IT TO HIM ANYMORE----HE HAS PROBLEMS WITH ONE HOUSE AND HAD TO GET ANOTHER-----AND THE CUTTING DRUGS ARE PISSING HIM OFF------Don't get me wrong, I give CARTH credit for being honest, but 2.5 weeks before the deadline, he posted the damn thread was 100 sentences long!!!!!! It disappointed me to say the least......


Anyways, a POLL sounds fair, I will compare each pic and point out reasons on exactly who and why I voted for what.........based on not just "Whos BIGGER", but for anyone that hasn't done a show or been to an IFBB Show---Judges score like the following:

Round 1--Symmetry round, Overall shape (symmetry and proportion)
THERE IS NO FLEXING/POSING IN THIS ROUND---simply view from the front and back with no ability to cover up flaws from flexing.....

Round 2--Muscularity round
MANDATORY POSES---front double bi, side chest, etc....----judges score based on overall physique, leanness compared to mass, Flat (sloppy) vs. striations through the body (RIPPED), vascularity, etc. etc......

Round 3--Posing round
This is when competitors don't have to do mandatory poses, but can pose in anyway they choose for the judges---(usually to MAXIMIZE their STRENGTHS and MINIMIZE any and all WEAKNESSES)


ALRIGHT, Anyways......We can make it as serious as you fellas would like....(Am I saying to make sure your spread your JAN/DREAM TAN all over and get your POSING Suits ON--no--FLMAO)....(although if this competition if really for something that we don't know about (like a night with the other's wife/girl or whatever)...then it may not hurt to get that tan kicking, take your diuretics, get that enima, and the last few days to completely carb deplete and right before show time eat a big FAT ASS BROWNIE----it will shock your system and make all your veins pop out everywhere---real ripped/vascular look.........

Another great tip----The night before the contest, mix up 1 cup of red wine and 50 ml of glycerine and sip this before going to bed. This helps to fill out the muscles. Glycerine temporarily draws water inside the muscle cells making them fuller. I will have the wine and glycerine again early Saturday morning. Glycerine is also a mild laxative, so it will help eliminate any bloating!!!!



OK...I'm done with my bull shit---Too much time on my hands tonight.....sorry fellas....LOL


Good Luck

Hey FELLA's...Is it true that this is taking place on FRIDAY??????

Sounds good to me....I'll give my honest opinion.......

 

[superqt4u2nv]

furthermore...

each member will vote like this example:

PROPORTION - satch

SYMMETERY - satch

MASS - carth

BODYFAT - satch

TOTAL:

SATCHBOOGIE: 3 POINTS
CARTH: 1 POINT

each member will post their points based on the above outline and we'll add the points up after 1 week or so.

Forget about the body fat % they don't measure that on stage it goes purely on how you look so who cares what either of you are at in terms of bf%. The rest is all a good idea make is a public poll so peeps can see who voted for who.

 

[satchboogie]

Hey FELLA's...Is it true that this is taking place on FRIDAY??????

Sounds good to me....I'll give my honest opinion.......

well..
both carth and i had prior engagements for the weekend which could not be postponed so, mutually, we decided to take pics anytime from 15th-17th.

but they wont be posted til the 17th so hang tight brotha..

ulter will post them for us for non plats too.

 

[thelion2005]

I don't know either man. I've seen pics of Carth, but not Satch.
Is it possible for them to provide a brief bio?
And some stats ... at least height and weight?

 

[satchboogie]

I don't know either man. I've seen pics of Carth, but not Satch.
Is it possible for them to provide a brief bio?
And some stats ... at least height and weight?

ill be providing a detalied bio of my training years.