The Nature Boy said:we have to. it's part of the camp david accords. we also give them all kinds of favorable loans with open ended payoff dates. of course they'll never pay off those loans, but we look the other way. i wish I got that deal.
Doktor Bollix said:The Egyptians get an identical amount and I never hear anyone bitching about that.
2Thick said:
No one bitches about the Egyptions because they are about 50 times the size of Isreal and do not stir up resentmenmt against America all over the world.
I love the way everyone brings up Egypt. It has nothing to do with why the US gives money to Israel. It is just distracts the issue.
Doktor Bollix said:
I love that argument that America should timorously avoid the further disapproval of those who hate us already.
When 2 parties get 90% of US direct military aid and both get the same amount and both are neighbours who hate each other and both are key levers of American foreign policy in the area I think it's valid to mention them together when only one of them raises all these objections. Particularly when only one of them (Israel) gets any international critiscism for it's treatment of political dissidents. The Egyptians probably disappear and torture more people in a month than Israel has in it's entire existence.
But I'm just distracting from the issue, which is whatever 2Thick says it is.
2Thick said:
What do Egyptians care anyway? They are NOT Arab and do not directly identify with the Palestinians anyway.
MattTheSkywalker said:
Don't identify LOL!
Doktor Bollix said:2 Thick, yeah that's why they get the aid. So what?
The only objections to Israel are not it's defiance of a few UN resolutions, it's very existence is the issue. The Israelis are smart enough to know that courting approval and being nice won't get you anywhere with people who want to destroy you no matter what and see concessions as a sign of weakness.
MattTheSkywalker said:
The money to Israel (and egypt, to an extent) can be thought of as a defense department subsidy, if that helps you sleep at night.
Keeping things in perspective, it will take 170 years of this aid to equal the cost of one year of Social Security.
Doktor Bollix said:Not seeing how you can equate the right to exist with the right to commit genocide, nuclear blackmail, export Islamic fascism etc.
Plus there's the national self-interest. The US has subverted legitimate governments so American fruit companies wouldn't take a beating on the price of bananas and the Middle-East is on a whole different plane of importance than bananas.
2Thick said:Israel is committing genocide...or at very best trying to ethnically cleanse Israel. That is very ironic to say the least.
2Thick said:
Iran is a sovereign country that is anti-Islamist. The people are against Arabic Islam and have adapted their beliefs into a secular society that makes Turkey look like it is controlled by the Taliban. The only ones that are extreme are the Mollahs who are trying to hold on to their power. There is no proof (beyond speculation) that Iran is invloved in terrorism.
North Korea is not using Nuclear blackmail. They are a sovereign country that is tired of being bullied by other countries with bigger guns. Plus, they know that they would not survive without international aid and are only making sure that they have enough power to thwart the US and their "interests."
Israel is committing genocide...or at very best trying to ethnically cleanse Israel. That is very ironic to say the least.
Doktor Bollix said:
This is a joke right?
Just let know.
ImSoBig said:ISRAEL RECIEVES ABOUT 5.5 BILLION A YEAR!!!!
AND WHAT DOES THE US GET OUT OF IT? NOTHING but HATE from ISLAMIC EXTERMISTS.
PS - EGYPT RECIEVES ABOUT 2.2 BILLION A YEAR, look at the sizes of the countries, If it wasnt for the US israel would have been a goner long ago. Even with all this aid they are suffering economically.
2Thick said:
I am dead serious.
Have you done any research outisde of North America?
It is a given that most info about situations outside of our immideiate orders are biased, but you really do not see the whole situation until you do your homework in all of the areas affacted...in short, get all 3 sides of the story.
GinNJuice said:
I really don't like how people immediatly start going off on tangents when there is a clear question/issue to be discussed.
I KNOW we spend money on Egypt, several other countries, and thousands of programs.
I asked a simple question why do we give billions of dollars to ISREAL!
If you want to talk about other countries, then let's make separate threads for them, I was asking about ISREAL.
Matt,
You seem to simplify this as a defense department subsidy, or more correctly defence contrators.............
........... If that's the only reason we give them money, then I would rather give the defense contractors the money directly for R&D. That way there wouldn't be any losses of Cost Of Sales.
You have to tell me there is some other reason we give them that kind of money. Because I believe their economy could be self-sufficient.
Doktor Bollix said:As for Israel committing genocide and ethnic cleansing, the numbers just don't support this, at that rate the job will never, ever get done. I think they could do better if they were actually trying, right?
MattTheSkywalker said:
Yawn.
Islamic extremists hate their own geovernments as much as they hate us.
Doktor Bollix said:
What about the Islamic Revolution of 1979?
Doktor Bollix said:
What about the tens of thousands of Iranian children who held hands and walked through the mine-fields singing of their joy at entering paradise during the Iran-Iraq war?
Doktor Bollix said:
What about Hizbollah in Lebanon and the 10,000 Katyusha surface to surface missiles Iran has supplied them which could destroy a chunk of northern Israel (according to European Union foreign policy chief Javier Solana?).
Doktor Bollix said:
Iran is no way secular in the same manner as Turkey, that's fantasy and I know you know better.
Doktor Bollix said:Who is North Korea bullied by again? The 2 million N. Koreans who starved to death recently were victims of their own government, and I know the inhabitants of Seoul don't really feel like bullies when they contemplate the array of N. Korean artillery that could destroy the city in a couple of hours nukes or no nukes.
Doktor Bollix said:
As for Israel committing genocide and ethnic cleansing, the numbers just don't support this, at that rate the job will never, ever get done. I think they could do better if they were actually trying, right?
Prometheus said:the only acceptable statement is that engaging in this discussion proves you are a racist and an anti-semite.
2Thick said:
The US sells weapons to Israel...and Iran sells weapons to Lebanon.
I do not see you calling the US a terrorist state because israel kills civilians with the weapons the US sells to them.
Doktor Bollix said:Iran doesn't sell weapons to Lebanon. It supplies Hizbollah, a radical Islamic fascist organization opposed to the legitimate government of Lebanon, with weapons.
2Thick said:
So since you are engaging, you must be a racist and anti-semite, too.
Doktor Bollix said:
Iran doesn't sell weapons to Lebanon. It supplies Hizbollah, a radical Islamic fascist organization opposed to the legitimate government of Lebanon, with weapons.
Doktor Bollix said:Never been to Iran, never will, until the people toss the Mullahs out it's not an appealing holiday destination, please don't start with the circular logic, it's childish. I'm amazed post 9/11 at the simpleminded faith some people still place in the omnipotence of the CIA.
Doktor Bollix said:
Genocide has one result: lots and lots of dead bodies. So where the fuck are they?
2Thick said:
That is a falsehood. And even if it were true, one man's terrorist is another's freedom fighter.
Plus, since most of the money spent on US arms is bought with money borrowed from US sources, technically, the US is freely supplying Israel with arms.
GinNJuice said:Here we go again with the tangents
Can ANYONE answer the question? Why does the US give Isreal 3.5+ billion a year..... and what is the benefit of that investment???
Doktor Bollix said:One man's terrorist is another man's freedom fighter. They are my terrorists. You have a problem with that?
GinNJuice said:Here we go again with the tangents
Can ANYONE answer the question? Why does the US give Isreal 3.5+ billion a year..... and what is the benefit of that investment???
The only pitiful answer I heard was that it is a subsity to the defence program![]()
Doktor Bollix said:
The Iranians fly 747s full of them into Damascus all the time.
GinNJuice said:
I was asking about ISREAL.
You seem to simplify this as a defense department subsidy, or more correctly defence contrators.............
........... If that's the only reason we give them money, then I would rather give the defense contractors the money directly for R&D. That way there wouldn't be any losses of Cost Of Sales.
You have to tell me there is some other reason we give them that kind of money. Because I believe their economy could be self-sufficient.
ImSoBig said:
Hizbollah holds the majority of the seats in the lebanese parliment, they are the government why would they oppose it?, its not only a military function, it has differnt wings, like military, excetutive, political, judicial.
And Hizbollah has a history of attacking military instillations and not civilians.
2Thick said:
BTW- You do not know at all the level secularism in Iran, so why do you keep thinking that they are in any way religious?
2Thick said:
According to your definition, the USA is a terrorist sponsoring state for backing countless regimes that killed and tortured civilians.
Just take a look at South America during the past 50 years.
GinNJuice said:Here we go again with the tangents
Can ANYONE answer the question? Why does the US give Isreal 3.5+ billion a year..... and what is the benefit of that investment???
The only pitiful answer I heard was that it is a subsity to the defence program![]()
ImSoBig said:According to Israel radio (in Hebrew) Kol Yisrael, [Shimon] Peres warned [Ariel] Sharon Wednesday that refusing to heed incessant American requests for a cease-fire with the Palestinians would endanger Israeli interests and "turn the US against us."
At this point, a furious Sharon reportedly turned toward Peres, saying "every time we do something you tell me Americans will do this and will do that. I want to tell you something very clear, don't worry about American pressure on Israel, we, the Jewish people control America, and the Americans know it."
The radio said Peres and other cabinet ministers warned Sharon against saying what he said in public because "it would cause us a public relations disaster."
"every time we do something you tell me Americans will do this and will do that. I want to tell you something very clear, don't worry about American pressure on Israel, we, the Jewish people control America, and the Americans know it."
And we support this man.......
MattTheSkywalker said:
Their economy is self sufficient.
In a way, it is money for R&D. Israeli scientists are among the best in the world - many of these are former Soviet scientists. (It's a long tradition: Niels Bohr, Einstein, Oppenheimer, all jews)
Israelis do a lot of work for us that way. They are (militarily) in the situation of continual urban combat, whereas it is very tough for us to gather data on the effectiveness of different systems in the urban environment. Israel can do that every day in live fire exercises.
Fonz said:
"Their economy is self-suficient"?????
I can't believe you wrote that.............
They are net importers of literally EVERYTHING.
Israel is frigging BARREN.
Most of their money comes from MILITARY EXPORTS.
Self-sufficient? LMFAO.....
Fonz
2Thick said:
one man's terrorist is another's freedom fighter.
MattTheSkywalker said:
By that logic you have just justified everything ever done in human history as "OK".
Since when is "do what thou wilt" yourphilosophy?
Doktor Bollix said:
You really believe that elderly piece of propaganda, that was a hoax like all the jews in NY staying home on 9/11. I guess the truth is more important to some people than others.
MattTheSkywalker said:and Israel does not need handouts.
ImSoBig said:
funny you say that, that is an assumption your making, in fact you yourself really dont know if those words were spoken by his mouth.
dballer said:
Like.. what the Nazis did was bad... but what Israel is doing is not??
MattTheSkywalker said:
I'm done with this. Yawn....
go fix a car or something.
MattTheSkywalker said:
2Thick is saying:
"A bad can be a good for someone else", eliminates any concept of good or bad, and shows 2Thick's amateurism as well as lack of knowledge.
.
2Thick said:
Not quite. You need to think a little harder when I write, otherwise you will make little mistakes like the post above...
When a Palestinian blows himself up in order to further his people's goal of a nation of Palestine, he is a freedom fighter.
When a person hijacks a plane and runs it into a building, then that is a form of terrorism because there is no freedom there to fight for in NYC for those Arabs.
That is merely one example. By today's standards, the American colonists would be terrorists when in fact they were fighting for their freedoms.
The Basque movement is Spain is a freedom fighter's movement.
The IRA is a freedom's fighter's movement.
If you cannot tell the difference between an IRA "event" and a child molester, then you are a few fags short of a pack.
MattTheSkywalker said:
Right, No freedom in NYC. They were fighting for freedom from US occupation in Saudi, according to OBL.
Don't make inane statements and then run backwards to qualify them.![]()
2Thick said:
The Basque movement is Spain is a freedom fighter's movement.
Fonz said:
"The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few"
Fonz
2Thick said:
That is Communist mantra
2Thick said:
Wrong captain. I know you are slow to pick up patterns so i will re-cap. If they were to attack an American base in Saudi (or even the mid-east) then that would be freedom fightinh. The goal of the plane tricks was to scare and that is all.
2Thick said:
The Basque movement is Spain is a freedom fighter's movement.
manny78 said:
ETA/Herri Batasuna isn't even approved by the majority of Basques. That's why they're affraid of a referendum on Independence.
2thick can you think back 20 years ago to THE ISLAMIC REVOLUTION? Iran is a THEOCRATIC REPUBLIC and is more moderate than Turkey?2Thick said:
Have you been to Iran, ever?
if not, then how the Hell would you know that the people are not secular?
SkullFuct said:2thick can you think back 20 years ago to THE ISLAMIC REVOLUTION? Iran is a THEOCRATIC REPUBLIC and is more moderate than Turkey?
-With abiding faith in the vital importance of women in society, Atatürk launched many reforms to give Turkish women equal rights and opportunities. The new Civil Code, adopted in 1926, abolished polygamy and recognized the equal rights of women in divorce, custody, and inheritance. The entire educational system from the grade school to the university became coeducational. Atatürk greatly admired the support that the national liberation struggle received from women and praised their many contributions: " In Turkish society, women have not lagged behind men in science, scholarship, and culture. Perhaps they have even gone further ahead." He gave women the same opportunities as men, including full political rights. In the mid-1930s, 18 women, among them a villager, were elected to the national parliament. Later, Turkey had the world's first women supreme court justice
2Thick said:
The goal of the plane tricks was to scare and that is all.
Wombat said:
if it was just to scare, then their would be no reason for any other terror-attacks......It goes a lot deeper then just scaring us....They wanted to see what would happen to our economy....And future attacks will be based on how we re-acted......Scare is only part of it......if they hit us hard enough all across the country at the same time....Our economy will shut down possibly long enough for us to turn on each other---and that is their main goal......
Fonz said:
Hmmmm......the US has made several blunders, but the worst one of them all is that they never did tend to view a DIRECT ECONMIC ATTACK as a matter of national security.
European nations understand this readily from past history.
The 9/11 was a DIRECT ECONOMIC ATTACK.
Make no mistake about it. Look what happened after 9/11.
The airlines went DOWN THE DRAIN.
Fonz
2Thick said:
Wrong captain. I know you are slow to pick up patterns so i will re-cap. If they were to attack an American base in Saudi (or even the mid-east) then that would be freedom fightinh. The goal of the plane tricks was to scare and that is all.
MattTheSkywalker said:
You made a dumb statement. Now you're backpedaling. On to another thread.![]()
Fonz said:
Hmmmm......the US has made several blunders, but the worst one of them all is that they never did tend to view a DIRECT ECONMIC ATTACK as a matter of national security.
European nations understand this readily from past history.
The 9/11 was a DIRECT ECONOMIC ATTACK.
Make no mistake about it. Look what happened after 9/11.
The airlines went DOWN THE DRAIN.
Fonz
This page contains mature content. By continuing, you confirm you are over 18 and agree to our TOS and User Agreement.
Please Scroll Down to See Forums Below 










