Originally posted by macrophage69alpha His post in red
Also, if some people (ulter comes to mind) are experiencing hypoglycemia from just 300mg of r-ALA, how come I didn't experience it *at all* on 1200mg of r-ALA?
your actual production of insulin may be blunted due to use of the racemic mix.. but it could be for other reasons??
Okay, so then... why do I get lethargic on huge amounts of racemic ALA, if what you say is true? If my production of insulin was 'blunted' by my use of racemic ALA from 3 days ago, then I have two questions:
First how long will my insulin be blunted by my prior use of the racemic?
really no idea... and it may be due to other factors.. this is a theory as to why.. cant really say for sure that is what is going on.. partly because the mechanism and effect of high doses of racemic ( or any ALA) are not all the well studied
Second, a constantly blunted insulin level due to constantly high usage of the racemic mixture should cause me not to feel any lethargy at all as long as I do those huge, insulin blunting amounts of racemic ALA, correct?
not really.. it is not quite clear what causes the "tired" feeling... it could be the ALA ...but whether this is a direct or inderect effect is UNKNOWN... that is really the issue here.. much of this is conjecture.. what is not conjecture are that the effects of r-ala (from health and insulin sensitivity aspect are superior).. it is not clear how r-ala will affect ketosis.. or if ketosis is even necessary with insulin minimization and sensitization through the use of r-ala.. once again.. not clear.. it will take time and comparison on many levels (ie low carb v. moderate carb ketotic) before any real comparison.. (at least with respect to ketosis can be made).. as well as differing effects on fat loss and glycogen storage.. (we are at the beginning...)
Shouldn't r-ALA be a powerful glucose disposal agent that does its job independently of the amount of insulin in one's system?
yes, but if insulin production levels are low.. you wont get the hypoglycemic effect
Here's the part that confuses me. I thought that hypoglycemia was defined as a rapid decline of blood glucose, such that your brain is starved of of sugar, with the liver not being able to adapt quickly enough to produce ketones, which is an alternate energy source for the brain.
The result: Coma and maybe even death. This should be the result of *any* glucose disposal agent that suddenly removes glucose from your blood stream and deposits primarily in your muscle and perhaps fat tissues, while not giving the brain a chance to adapt to the sudden change.
Are you saying that r-ALA is a powerful glucose disposal agent which somehow spares the brain from the sudden decline in blood sugar? And that it's only insulin that starves the brain? What about metformin ? Glucophage?
Perhaps you're suggesting that r-ALA disposes of the glucose gently, such that the brain is not starved at all?
here it is easier.. if you are already somewhat insulin sensitive (ie younger, normal estrogen levels, etc) the hypoglycemic effect MAY not be as great (plus the other factors mentioned.. ie perhaps already low insulin).. in ulters case.. older, taking androgens, taking aromatase inhibitors.. the hypogycemic effects (since his insulin levels will generally be higher for the above reasons) is more prominent .. not suggesting any of the above
And what about the folks who took just 100-200mg or R-ala and experience the lethargy? Is that a placebo effect, because they are expecting it from reading about it here?
?????????
I'm referring to the this thread:
http://boards.elitefitness.com/forum/showthread.php?threadid=153266&highlight=rala
by Diesel3d There he states that he took only one 100mg cap of r-ala and felt tired. I'm wondering if he's misattributing his tiredness to r-ala, just because he's seen so many posts on how ala is like insulin, or whether for some people 100mg of r-ala is sufficient to cause this lethargy. But thiis last point goes against what your saying Macro, which is that the lethargy is primarily induced by the increase in plasma insulin level iwhich in turn is induced by the s-ala. In this poor chap's case, where's the s-ala coming from? I'm confused.
the ???? were to indicate... dont know.. but it could be for a # of reasons both directly and indirectly related to r-ala and insulin (as well as glucagon).. not to mention other hormones.. as well as other supplements that may enhance insulin secretion/sensitivity/ etc.. its a complex system
.