Profile Idea

[MaGilicuti]

How about show how many threads this person has started and/or show their highest and lowest responses are for their threads. Or an average number for responses on their threads. This would show how much quality goes on to the thread this person makes I think. Just a thought. Kinda gives the people that come up with good threads a pat on the back.

 

[MaGilicuti]

no one likes my idea? okay fuck you guys then

 

[HappyScrappy]

I like it. I'm a big stats fan.

 

[gymtime]

It would make RyanH a candidate for EF member of the year.

 

[Raina]

I think that would work well. Some people have lots of posts and little to say.

 

[MaGilicuti]

It would make RyanH a candidate for EF member of the year.

if his threads make for good conversation then he is a good chat member, he is doing his job

 

[The Shadow]

It would make RyanH a candidate for EF member of the year.

Hehehehe...you said member...

 

[MommaKin]

it's all relative though........what qualifies as a good thread?
some ppl bitch cuase ppl start stupid threads....well, this is a chat board...who is someone to say such and such a thread is poor quality

 

[gymtime]

if his threads make for good conversation then he is a good chat member, he is doing his job

Very true. Don't think I've ever seen a RyanH thread with less than 30 responses.

 

[MaGilicuti]

we'd figure it out the more we used it. but a thread with more posts is usually a good thread. we'd factor how many times ppl post on the thread as well so we just don't have two ppl posting back and forth getting a high thread count. i think that what was wrong with the karma system

 

[MommaKin]

I agree there, Mag
Not only would RyanH win, strongchick would too....
That's a scary thought...

 

[MaGilicuti]

i think we need karma mods, like to receive karma you post postive karma as usual but you write the real reason you are giving good karma. its reviewed the the karma mods to see if its approved or not

 

[MommaKin]

that I don't agree with.....I think if someone wants to give good karma to someone, for whatever reason, it should be there choice...it should not be left up to someone else to decide...

i think we need karma mods, like to receive karma you post postive karma as usual but you write the real reason you are giving good karma. its reviewed the the karma mods to see if its approved or not

 

[Puc]

It would go something like this

1. Smallmovesal
2. Mommakin
3. ...
4. ...
5. ...
6. every other female in this shithole
7. bigots and anarchists
8. eliteists
9. ...
10. ...
11. ...
12. Puc
    [/list=1]

 

[MaGilicuti]

that I don't agree with.....I think if someone wants to give good karma to someone, for whatever reason, it should be there choice...it should not be left up to someone else to decide...

i dont think the anabolic mods appreciate chat mods having more "karma" then them. they are the real reason this board is here

 

[MommaKin]

Puc, I like you and I'll be ehre if you ever need to talk to someone, but, are you ever positive at all?
Try and smile once in a while.....life is what you make it

 

[Citruscide]

i dont think the anabolic mods appreciate chat mods having more "karma" then them. they are the real reason this board is here

Sir, I applaude you...

That's why I try to take time out of my day when I'm at the anabolic discussion part and give them their due... they are the reason I came to this board... hell, I had around 500 posts before I even checked out the chat board...

C

 

[MommaKin]

So?
That doesn't mean they deserve more karma then anyone else on ef. There are plenty of good ppl on chat, as well as the AS forum.
I'm not going to get in an argument, yet again, about what forum is better on ef. They are all good in their own way, just as every person on here is. I also won't argue about ppl that come to ef chat and don't work out...so what if they don't...it's chat board....it's free for all to come and chat.,,,,,fat or skinny, lazy or not...

i dont think the anabolic mods appreciate chat mods having more "karma" then them. they are the real reason this board is here

 

[MaGilicuti]

well the truth is a lot of ppl get karma for just posting in those "KARMA THREADS." Hey i'm guilty of it too but that is NOT how the karma system is suppose to work. That is not why it was made. The top 10 karma holders were posted recently. Those people probably don't have many quality posts or threads as their karma says they have.

 

[MaGilicuti]

just because u don't share the same view as me doesn't mean its an arguement, its a debate. please share your opinion, its fine. that is what chat is about

 

[MommaKin]

I am guilty of that too, obviously. I also am aware why the karma system was brought about. But, it hasn't turned out the way it was intended too. But, we'll have to live with that. Maybe in the end, the karma system will work itself out.
Also, I was one of those top ten ppl......of course most, if not all, ppl think I don't deserve that spot.....o well.....what shall I do? Shoot myself over it? I think not noly does the karma system have to do with quality posting, but, it also has to do with the personality of the person.......

well the truth is a lot of ppl get karma for just posting in those "KARMA THREADS." Hey i'm guilty of it too but that is NOT how the karma system is suppose to work. That is not why it was made. The top 10 karma holders were posted recently. Those people probably don't have many quality posts or threads as their karma says they have.

 

[MommaKin]

Anyhow, my original point was I don't think it should be up to a "karma mod" to decide if someone else is worthy of good karma.....it should remian up to the discretion of the person giving it.....

 

[MaGilicuti]

Anyhow, my original point was I don't think it should be up to a "karma mod" to decide if someone else is worthy of good karma.....it should remian up to the discretion of the person giving it.....

that is a good point.

i think your posts should show how many posts u have per forum. maybe that would help

 

[MommaKin]

or maybe even a karma system for each forum....
I dunno...
or maybe in each post, on say the AS forum, have a voting thing...so when you post, you have to vote....
now there;'s a good idea...

that is a good point.

i think your posts should show how many posts u have per forum. maybe that would help