Eviction, the lightning will make all the difference. Your bf is low enough to pull this off because, quite frankly, you got Fonz beat BY A LONG SHOT. You simply are more muscular and have better symmetry and muscle shape than Fonzie. He does (or atleast did) have less bf but who knows what he looks like now.
Notice Fonz has always taken his pics with overhead lightning, the kind that will create deep shadows. Use yellower light. That's the kind of lightning you need to use. Do you have a pump in these pics?