smokinghawk
New member
Why do non-Indian people "Wanna be" Indian? It's strikingly bizarre: people who dabble and hobby-play with Indian religious beliefs and ceremonies (without any authentic training, and even by paying huge amounts to attend new-age weekend retreats and buy new-age "Indian spirituality" workbooks). And if I meet one more person who swears,
"My great-grandmother was full-blooded Cherokee"
...usually followed with a version of:
"...But she never reported it so she's not on the rolls and we can't prove it/but the courthouse with her records in it burned down so we can't prove it/but our family never talked about it and I'm trying to research it back, but we can't prove it/you can *really* tell in the old pictures of her but we can't prove it..."
...I'm gonna scream. I'm beginning to suspect there was never an actual Cherokee nation, only a bunch of great-grandmothers (most of them "Princesses," at that!).
I seldom hear people invent a contrived "my great-grandmother was full-blooded Black" heritage; just Indian. It is somehow "cool?" Does it make people feel "exotic" or less ordinary? Less guilty? Entitled to something? Somehow more profoundly spiritual? Culturally "dangerous" in an exciting way? Is it a backlash reaction against being just another middle-class suburban white guy (or gal) who mows the grass and eats at Burger King?
Seriously, what's going on?
"My great-grandmother was full-blooded Cherokee"
...usually followed with a version of:
"...But she never reported it so she's not on the rolls and we can't prove it/but the courthouse with her records in it burned down so we can't prove it/but our family never talked about it and I'm trying to research it back, but we can't prove it/you can *really* tell in the old pictures of her but we can't prove it..."
...I'm gonna scream. I'm beginning to suspect there was never an actual Cherokee nation, only a bunch of great-grandmothers (most of them "Princesses," at that!).
I seldom hear people invent a contrived "my great-grandmother was full-blooded Black" heritage; just Indian. It is somehow "cool?" Does it make people feel "exotic" or less ordinary? Less guilty? Entitled to something? Somehow more profoundly spiritual? Culturally "dangerous" in an exciting way? Is it a backlash reaction against being just another middle-class suburban white guy (or gal) who mows the grass and eats at Burger King?
Seriously, what's going on?

Please Scroll Down to See Forums Below 










