Who is the victor? Satch or Carth?

[Mikus]

i think carth has a slight edge..but damn satch, very impressive! both of you guys, well done!

 

[Beachboy6294]

Well, Satch is my bro, I will say that first. But I am also an NPC judge that has to judge friends all the time and I am a no bullshit judge. I placed my sister out of the trophies so I am honest always.

I would have to put Carth over Satch do to his more mature muscle mass. He has a harder physique that is more balanced. Satch is stronger in the chest but Carth is strong from the back and legs...bet he deads and rows heavy and squats deep. Really nice calves. Needs upper pec development and traps and arms a bit bigger.

Satch needs to bring his legs up...common for people training a short time. Satch has a very nice waist and ab structure. Needs to bring up middle back thickness. Squeeeeze and feel it and row, row, row. Biceps are a little ahead of tris. Legs need to come up but that is with time. This is the best I have seen you. You will continue to get leaner each diet too.

This is a sport of paying your dues...a marathon not a sprint. Carth looks to me to have more time in the trenches but both have done a great job. Kudos to both of you.

Quadsweep

Damn I guess that is why your a Judge and Mod on here because you said everything I could have ever thought of or didn't even realize until looking at the pics after reading your comments! I had said that Carth looked better in the legs and back but you explained to a T!!! Great job to both Bro's!!

 

[bigmann245]

of course there can only be one. they both did an outstanding job. they are an inspiration to us all. i for one am more motivated to hit the gym and hit it hard. great job guys.

 

[thelion2005]

Pics are in bros. Time for your opinions.

Carth wins, but do not count Satch down.

He'll grow and hit the legs hard. I see him at a lean and cut 235 next year with a more "matured" look as he trains more.

 

[danaf1]

I'm with quadkilla on this one, so what if they werent up right at 2pm, its not like he was pulling some last minute trick out of his ass, he got them up an hour late, and now everyone eho kept calling him names(but dont have the balls to post any of their own pics), get to eat some humble pie as he clearly beat satch.
Props to both on this for having the balls to post the pics, unlike 95% of the shit talkers on here who dont post pics for a very good reason

Agreed. It's not like he dropped his bodyfat down or added and 1" to any measurements in an hour or two. It was a competition but it was for fun, not like an IFBB comp or something. Everyone should forget about it being a little late and just judge the pics.

 

[musclemuscle]

why is this a sticky...my thread has side by side pics and more votes and was made way before this one...wtf

just wonderin?

 

[will b huge]

Will b Huge?? When??? LOL Talk shit! K to Need!

Hey Carth,

Didn't mean to be so negative bro....and to rant on and on.....

Satch and you both came in very impressive--you shocked me with your size and I couldn't believe how far Satch has came either....

I deleted my rants in here and spread positive karma around to everyone.....

Sorry about the rants, it was a bad day--(I've seen that you know where I'm coming from)......(didn't mean to piss off the world; especially all the CARTHINITES!!!!!)

Take it Easy and Congratulations...

Hope the nice house,inground pool, lion fountain, naked wife are all doing GREAT!!!!



(Quadkilla, ZZZ, please forget about it too)

--

 

[Smokescreen]

Hey Carth,

Didn't mean to be so negative bro....and to rant on and on.....

Satch and you both came in very impressive--you shocked me with your size and I couldn't believe how far Satch has came either....

I deleted my rants in here and spread positive karma around to everyone.....

Sorry about the rants, it was a bad day--(I've seen that you know where I'm coming from)......(didn't mean to piss off the world; especially all the CARTHINITES!!!!!)

Take it Easy and Congratulations...

Hope the nice house,inground pool, lion fountain, naked wife are all doing GREAT!!!!



(Quadkilla, ZZZ, please forget about it too)

--

And that is why LOVE conquers all!!! K to you for coming back to the Light.

 

[zZzStarGazer]

Wow, I got a lot of respect for you now. That took a lot to do. I think you're the first to really be a man about it. Thank you. I mean it, thank you.

Hey Carth,

Didn't mean to be so negative bro....and to rant on and on.....

Satch and you both came in very impressive--you shocked me with your size and I couldn't believe how far Satch has came either....

I deleted my rants in here and spread positive karma around to everyone.....

Sorry about the rants, it was a bad day--(I've seen that you know where I'm coming from)......(didn't mean to piss off the world; especially all the CARTHINITES!!!!!)

Take it Easy and Congratulations...

Hope the nice house,inground pool, lion fountain, naked wife are all doing GREAT!!!!



(Quadkilla, ZZZ, please forget about it too)

--

 

[Smokescreen]

Wow, I got a lot of respect for you now. That took a lot to do. I think you're the first to really be a man about it. Thank you. I mean it, thank you.

Yeah no shit! I too I'm a little shocked about all of this! Takes a real man to do shit like that. Much props!