vick for MVP

[madbomber31]

i think aikman's head is finally unrattled... he said something that made sense today... "the only people crowing vick the mvp are the ones that have only seen the highlight reels"...

good point troy, about time...


look at the defenses he exploded against and look no further.

 

[The Shadow]

Remember though - TB matches up better than anyone will against Atlanta's offensive scheme - especially with their starting tailback being out.....

...does this mean that TB is THAT much better than Atlanta - NO...just as New Orleans is NOT that much better than TB - its about match-ups....

 

[The_Mexican]

It's either going to be vick or holmes... after this week Id say holmes is more deserving.

 

[mylife]

who do yo uthink is more deserving than him?

 

[The Shadow]

If you judge by what player is most valuble to his team - Vick wins going away

 

[MP5]

Holmes is on a whole other level than any other tailback in the league right now. Vick ought to be a running back, not a QB. Give him 3 years of running out of the pocket instead of throwing the ball, then he will slow down and just be another average quarterback.

 

[The Shadow]

Vick has an the strongest arm in the league as well as the sharpest learning curve

 

[mylife]

Holmes is on a whole other level than any other tailback in the league right now. Vick ought to be a running back, not a QB. Give him 3 years of running out of the pocket instead of throwing the ball, then he will slow down and just be another average quarterback.

he only averages 7 rushes a game. the top 5 qb's in the nfc all average at least 5 rushes.

 

[The Shadow]

yep......but he averages about 20 per run - lol

 

[MP5]

When was the last time a black QB won a superbowl?

 

[the nature boy]

Doug Williams in 1987.

 

[madbomber31]

nah, tony banks was on the ravens...

and mcnabb is winning it this year.

holmes is the mvp, he's about to break the all time single season td record... hmmm, emmitt had it and was mvp that season... then faulk broke it and was mvp... so........ vick isnt a qb yet, sorry.. he's a runner.

 

[HighIntensity]

GANNON

 

[WODIN]

Holmes or Gannon are top dogs this season. Vick is a phenomenal player and will get his due in time.

 

[The Whole F/N Show]

What about Priest Holms? He deserves a nod. But if Falcons make a run in the playoffs Vick would be very deserving MVP. Without him the Falcons are 6 and 10. Gannon may break Marino's single season passing record but Vick may rush for 1,000 yards. That something no QB has ever done and if all the more impressive if it get's his team to the playoffs.

 

[HulkRow]

GANNON

 

[runner]

it's gotta' be priest or gannon.

i knew priest a bit when he was a longhorn. really nice guy. my roommate when i first got to UT was a transfer from delaware, where he backed up gannon at QB....

 

[madbomber31]

since mcnabb didnt win it last year or the previous year... no way should vick win it this year.. mcnabb did just as much for his team but was beat out by warner (which is bullshit) and faulk (i can live with that one)... last years eagles were weaker than this years falcons offense but mcnabb still had over 3k passing...

if vick explodes the last 3 weeks in the PASSING GAME then ya, i'll say give it to him, but thats not gonna happen... holmes is the mvp.... gannon has too many weapons around him (then again, so did warner).

 

[TheProject]

Holmes, no doubt.

1454 yards rushing, average 4.9 yards/carry, 21 rushing TD's, add to that 650 yards receiving, with 3 TD's.