WQhat everyone has to remember is that PERSONALITY is more important than BIG MUSCLES in wrestling. Even Al Snow told jake that. Fact of the matter is that Jake is boring, dull and lame. The black dude could wrestle better than Jake, but he too was pretty lame and boring. I mean lets look at Brock, totally huge and scary looking, but not that exciting, he would never get over. Goldberg? again, big, but no personality. Lex Luger, Hercules, Dino Bravo, Brakkus all guys who were fucking huge, but none really had all that much charisma.
The black chick, well personally I dunno what the deal was with her. She is a pretty decent wrestler, but again not too charismatic.
Now Jackie, well Im just in love with her. But she clearly has the will to do what it takes to be a superstar. Choosing her was a no brainer. She has decent wrestling skills, sexy look, drive, and is not boring or dull like the other 3.
Look at Maven, nothing special in the way of muscle, but clearly the guy can entertain, he sells great, and acts great, where as Chris was adecent wrestler, big, but looked totally boring and lame.
I dont have a problem with Tough Enough picking the two yaks to win it. The guys were just dull.