Please Scroll Down to See Forums Below
napsgear
genezapharmateuticals
domestic-supply
puritysourcelabs
UGL OZ
UGFREAK
napsgeargenezapharmateuticals domestic-supplypuritysourcelabsUGL OZUGFREAK

Spanking Children

  • Thread starter Thread starter madbomber31
  • Start date Start date
BLITZ99 said:
i'd skip this and laugh at a psycho chick who spanks her teens, but i think i'd rather reply... think of me any way you want and think of how i do my job any way you want, that does not matter to me as you mean nothing to me. but you do realize what you do, right? you realize you deflect everything aimed at you and you attack...

BM, you did nothing a 12 year old inner city daughter of a crackwhore couldnt do.. you had kids... thats nothing special, sorry. now i see why you spanked your daughter, she made you mad and your anger came out... you rationalize what you do, good for you...

i answer back something you state and it becomes "the best i can do"... you are the one who claimed by spanking your teenager she wont be on a milk crate... i simply replied and said that by spanking her and treating her like that it could actually lead to her leaving...

you then go on to say how i know nothing and you feel bad for the state of our country because kids are in my hands??? you go on doing what it is you do and blaming your ex for your situation... go on and blame the counselor for your situation... go on and blame your daughters friends for your situation... go on and blame the parents of these friends for your situation... but please, whatever you do... DO NOT BLAME YOURSELF... you are above that.

You REALLY have a college degree? I call bullshit.

Darlin'... I could give TWO SHITS about who is to blame for "my situation". That is what you and any other weak minded fool who keeps parroting such mindless drivel clearly does not get. "Whomever is to blame for my situation" is 100% irrelevant. I am not blaming anyone. When I reveal certain facts that are germaine to OUR situation it is only to give a bit of background, etc. to those that *think* they know what is going on and not to seek approval/sympathy or whatever useless emotion YOU THINK I care about.

I have and do continue to accept that I am the solution for my situation.

You have all but called me a stupid crack whore for that. However, I am STILL WAITING for a singular word of constructive advice.

You can name-call and degrade till you are blue in the face. This fact will not change and having said that clearly negates any shred of credibility you or any other weak-minded fool (including a piss poor excuse for a school counselor) may have had at the beginning of any debate in regards to this topic or any topic like it.






(Not bad for a dumb crack whore who "knew enough to spread her legs", eh?) :)
 
BLITZ99 said:
not sexually....

when does spanking cross the line? when should you stop spanking your child?

after reading a thread the other day i began wondering this....

a lot of us were hit with belts or paddles when we were young, but just because that shit happened back then doesnt make it right, ya know? so when does it cross the line???

in my opinion, if you have to take your kid to a doctor for the lashings you gave them, you are a fucked up individual with anger issues and need to get that shit resolved before you can become a respectable (not good) parent.
I try not to leave marks.
 
Lestat said:
No I don' yet, and I realize it is very easy to say when you don't, but I've studied spanking and the effects of spanking quite a bit and I can say for certain that barring a complete breakdown of self control on my part, my kids will not be spanked. I don't see much difference between spanking a kid with a hand, or god forbit a board or stick, or just punching them in the face. The goal is to inflict plain. Crazy fucking parents make their kids pull their pants down and shit too.. how degrading. All humans deserve more respect then that.
No no no no no no no no no no no. You, as a non parent, are looking at spanking as an abuse/violence issue. Spanking is a loving discipline. If you are over-the-top angry, you wait to discipline the kid. You don't give them a spanking under 4ish, & over 10ish. Outside of those time frames a swat on the ass, or fingers usually suffices.
Remember, these are little sentient beings who do not yet have the communication skills to admonish them. They understand the punishment principal & they don't respond consistently to praise, 'cause they don't understand it.
For the older ones, you can communicate, but they don't care what you want, they think you're full of shit, & will do what they want when your back is turned. An occasional, judiciously applied non-marking slap on the face can get their attention & lets them know you're serious.
All of this will be useless if you don't show them your love consistently at other non-dramatic times, & explain yourself when you do discipline. Even though they won't understand as toddlers, tyou will set the precedent.
Spanking between 5& 10 is usually necessary, at least occasionally. Kids that age are trying to find their limits & establish an heirarchy in the relationship. They will do totally inappropriate, sometimes intentionally malicious things to force their agenda.
 
boxerjake said:
Spanking proves you inability to parent ... end of story I've never once hit my kids ( 7 and 9 ) .. I change my tone and they run for fuckin cover ... it's mental torture for them to think i'm disappointed in them .. thats born out of a loving relationship not a master servant relationship where you do as i say or i strike you down like the dog you are
When I was a kid, I was the same way, with my mother. Her disappointment would bring me to tears. But when she wasn't around, I just didn't think of her. I did what I wanted, which usually wasn't good.
Like everything in parenting, you have to do things with love in mind. If it really doesn't hurt you more than it hurts them, then there is a problem.
having said that, I know some people beat their kids, because they have no control.
I know a guy who still slaps his 20 Y.O. daughter & 22 y.o. son for minor transgressions. He threatens to beat them , or kick them out if their infractions are worse. I can see them not looking back when they do leave.
 
mountain muscle said:
Sorry, kids need a good spanking now and then when necessary.

No, no, no - a spanking will cause them to run away sez blitz69 - DONT DO IT! THEY WILL HATE YOUR FOR LIFE AND RUN AWAY!!! Where to? Who knows but wherever it is they had better have enough free eletricity to fuel and ipod, computer, phone and straightening iron (because there is NO WAY my 13 y/o could live without any of this shit) and gobs of poptarts and gummies. Oh yes, someplace that will provide Abercrombie and Fitch, and Holister clothing.... ALL FOR FREE!

LOL

Funny thing about this and every other thread like it?

I will be THE ONLY ONE called a dumbass crack whore. LOL

I will say this one last time and be done with it.

The only person that the morgue will call with my daughter's twenty year old remains - you know, the ones that are in little plastic bags recovered from underneath the driveway of some sick bastard that abducted and violated in ways too numerous to speak my daughter and 30 other unsuspecting teens - so that I my family can finally have some sort of closure and lay her remains to rest is:

ME.





But dont worry. I wont be calling your sorry ass to attend the funeral so that I can tell you how wrong you were.
 
BIKINIMOM said:
No, no, no - a spanking will cause them to run away sez blitz69 - DONT DO IT! THEY WILL HATE YOUR FOR LIFE AND RUN AWAY!!! Where to? Who knows but wherever it is they had better have enough free eletricity to fuel and ipod, computer, phone and straightening iron (because there is NO WAY my 13 y/o could live without any of this shit) and gobs of poptarts and gummies. Oh yes, someplace that will provide Abercrombie and Fitch, and Holister clothing.... ALL FOR FREE!

LOL

Funny thing about this and every other thread like it?

I will be THE ONLY ONE called a dumbass crack whore. LOL

I will say this one last time and be done with it.

The only person that the morgue will call with my daughter's twenty year old remains - you know, the ones that are in little plastic bags recovered from underneath the driveway of some sick bastard that abducted and violated in ways too numerous to speak my daughter and 30 other unsuspecting teens - so that I my family can finally have some sort of closure and lay her remains to rest is

ME.





But dont worry. I wont be calling your sorry ass to attend the funeral so that I can tell you how wrong you were.

Can I smack other poeple's kids too though? What is the age limit on that?

Did you call me a sorry ass?

I still say kids need a good smack down for their spoiled asses now and then.
 
mountain muscle said:
Can I smack other poeple's kids too though? What is the age limit on that?

Did you call me a sorry ass?

I still say kids need a good smack down for their spoiled asses now and then.

I think the two of us are going straight to hell! LOL :verygood:
 
BIKINIMOM said:
You REALLY have a college degree? I call bullshit.

Darlin'... I could give TWO SHITS about who is to blame for "my situation". That is what you and any other weak minded fool who keeps parroting such mindless drivel clearly does not get. "Whomever is to blame for my situation" is 100% irrelevant. I am not blaming anyone. When I reveal certain facts that are germaine to OUR situation it is only to give a bit of background, etc. to those that *think* they know what is going on and not to seek approval/sympathy or whatever useless emotion YOU THINK I care about.

I have and do continue to accept that I am the solution for my situation.

You have all but called me a stupid crack whore for that. However, I am STILL WAITING for a singular word of constructive advice.

You can name-call and degrade till you are blue in the face. This fact will not change and having said that clearly negates any shred of credibility you or any other weak-minded fool (including a piss poor excuse for a school counselor) may have had at the beginning of any debate in regards to this topic or any topic like it.

(Not bad for a dumb crack whore who "knew enough to spread her legs", eh?) :)
you seriously think you made a point? you call bullshit on my degree??? wow, i have been called out and absolutely owned on this one... the "name calling" was a direct attack at you, yes... sort of a push me and i will resist type thing... look back and see what i was replying to, an attack on my character.. you've made no point and this is going nowhere... however, i must reply because thats how i am...
 
BIKINIMOM said:
No, no, no - a spanking will cause them to run away sez blitz69 - DONT DO IT! THEY WILL HATE YOUR FOR LIFE AND RUN AWAY!!! Where to? Who knows but wherever it is they had better have enough free eletricity to fuel and ipod, computer, phone and straightening iron (because there is NO WAY my 13 y/o could live without any of this shit) and gobs of poptarts and gummies. Oh yes, someplace that will provide Abercrombie and Fitch, and Holister clothing.... ALL FOR FREE!

LOL

Funny thing about this and every other thread like it?

I will be THE ONLY ONE called a dumbass crack whore. LOL

I will say this one last time and be done with it.

The only person that the morgue will call with my daughter's twenty year old remains - you know, the ones that are in little plastic bags recovered from underneath the driveway of some sick bastard that abducted and violated in ways too numerous to speak my daughter and 30 other unsuspecting teens - so that I my family can finally have some sort of closure and lay her remains to rest is:
But dont worry. I wont be calling your sorry ass to attend the funeral so that I can tell you how wrong you were.[/SIZE]


ok, and to reply to this... i believe spanking is fine and needed, you obviously have not read posts of mine in the past about this... my point was that when you used a belt on a 13 year old girl you crossed the line of WHAT I THOUGHT WAS OK... period... and yes, i thought you had to take her to the doctors because of the lashing, my mistake...

how your daughter feels about you now or ever likely has nothing to do with her getting spanked... maybe her being embarassed due to being spanked as a teenager will play into it... or her thinking her mom is a fucking nutjob will play into it.... but not getting spanked... then again, maybe she understands why you did it... i dunno...

you need to take a look back at my comments and realize that they are all in reply to your attacks on me and my career choice and intelligence... THEN you can take the coat hanger and whip your daughter for staying out too late or something like that... teach her a lesson, ya know?

as for the constructive criticism that you say you've not heard yet... how bout taking away things she likes... like said ipod, tv, etc... or how about rewarding her for doing things you consider "good"... you know, positive reinforcement... seeing how that is widely considered the best way to correct a behavior in a child... maybe get wild and combine the two....

i've replied to the last callout of my degree, or career choice....
 
BLITZ99 said:
in my opinion, if you have to take your kid to a doctor for the lashings you gave them, you are a fucked up individual with anger issues and need to get that shit resolved before you can become a respectable (not good) parent.


You assissinated my character with your very first post.

Then when I pointed out to you your HYUGE faux pas (I am still waiting for the retraction and the apology).

In order to "save face" instead of apologizing for YOUR ERROR and continuing and intelligent debate, you changed your arguement to one of "defending the counselor" for doing her job.

Then I pointed out to you that she most certainly did NOT.

So then you began to call me a crack whore that only knew how to spread her legs to receive cum and who "blamed everyone else for her problems."

I intelligently responded to that ridiculous statement and what do you do?

You go on spew more bullshit in a feeble attempt to defend your education. Too bad you cant apply anything they taught you in school.... Or maybe they didnt teach you much. Or it isnt all that hard to attain a degree in the US - or all of the above. Whatever...

The fact remains -

You are a fool, pure and simple. End of story. :)
 
BLITZ99 said:
ok, and to reply to this... i believe spanking is fine and needed, you obviously have not read posts of mine in the past about this... my point was that when you used a belt on a 13 year old girl you crossed the line of WHAT I THOUGHT WAS OK... period... and yes, i thought you had to take her to the doctors because of the lashing, my mistake...

how your daughter feels about you now or ever likely has nothing to do with her getting spanked... maybe her being embarassed due to being spanked as a teenager will play into it... or her thinking her mom is a fucking nutjob will play into it.... but not getting spanked... then again, maybe she understands why you did it... i dunno...

you need to take a look back at my comments and realize that they are all in reply to your attacks on me and my career choice and intelligence... THEN you can take the coat hanger and whip your daughter for staying out too late or something like that... teach her a lesson, ya know?

as for the constructive criticism that you say you've not heard yet... how bout taking away things she likes... like said ipod, tv, etc... or how about rewarding her for doing things you consider "good"... you know, positive reinforcement... seeing how that is widely considered the best way to correct a behavior in a child... maybe get wild and combine the two....
i've replied to the last callout of my degree, or career choice....


Are you really THAT simple?

Where the fuck have you been for the last 13 years of my life when I was SUCCESSFULLY PARENTING FOUR CHILDREN in an unbelievably fucked up situation that has been somewhat of my own design because of MY OWN INABILITY to effectively deal with my asshole exhusband?

How THE FUCK did I ever make it this far without beating all of them to death?!?! LOL

You have obviously not read a single fucking post I have ever made in regards to proper parenting.

Please, just stop talking now. It is getting embarrassing already.
 
thats fine... i can live with you thinking i'm a fool...

the other things all go together... it doesnt take a special person to be a mother or father... the counselor did her job... and i never defended my education...

finally, reread what you just wrote.. it says if... and that statement is as true as they come, even if it doesnt apply to you because thats not why you took your kid to the doc.
regardless, you are right.. i am wrong.. you have done everything necessary to discipline your daughters, i know nothing of the situation, in fact as i have learned from reading your posts, i know nothing, period... i am an idiot, i understand now...

enjoy life, hopefully it's good to you...
 
I have two kids.

Spanking is bullshit.

Can I totally see a parent spanking as a result of desperate total frustration? Yes. I have been there myself. Is it justified? No. I have a challenging son who I at all costs attempt to talk to or alternatively take things away and time him out. Does it work so that he never misbehaves the next time? No. Does spanking? No.

What do we teach our kids about hurting others? Not to do it, right? Not to hit, kick, punch, push, grab. Why? Because physical violence toward others is wrong, right? Then we turn around and hit them. So we condition our kids to behave by using fear of corporal punishment? I don't want my kids to walk all over me and disrespect me, but I sure as hell don't want them FEARING me. I continue to work towards finding resolutions that don't include physical harm. It's my job, obligation, and responsibility. Welcome to parenthood. My father slapped my sister in the head so many times, I used to stand there and bawl my eyes out watching. Was she a difficult girl..yes. But no one is going to tell me this shit..be it slams on the bum, or a few "controlled shots with a belt" wtf???..is the path to happy and respectful child development, or what's going to prevent them from drugs, alcohol, gangs, etc.

People love their kids, but there is nothing loving about hitting. There are laws against it. It is possible that parents take too many liberties with their kids and fail to realize that they have their own thoughts, obstacles, struggles. Yes, kids do need to learn to respect their parents, but it works both ways. If spanking is the norm in your household, then you need to tap into some resources and find another way. Spanking is absolutely for the lazy and the easy way out.

1-2-3 Magic is a discipline system which works, and you can get it on tape and from your local libraries, family centres, or family physicians.
 
jujubes said:
I have two kids.

Spanking is bullshit.

Can I totally see a parent spanking as a result of desperate total frustration? Yes. I have been there myself. Is it justified? No. I have a challenging son who I at all costs attempt to talk to or alternatively take things away and time him out. Does it work so that he never misbehaves the next time? No. Does spanking? No.

What do we teach our kids about hurting others? Not to do it, right? Not to hit, kick, punch, push, grab. Why? Because physical violence toward others is wrong, right? Then we turn around and hit them. So we condition our kids to behave by using fear of corporal punishment? I don't want my kids to walk all over me and disrespect me, but I sure as hell don't want them FEARING me. I continue to work towards finding resolutions that don't include physical harm. It's my job, obligation, and responsibility. Welcome to parenthood. My father slapped my sister in the head so many times, I used to stand there and bawl my eyes out watching. Was she a difficult girl..yes. But no one is going to tell me this shit..be it slams on the bum, or a few "controlled shots with a belt" wtf???..is the path to happy and respectful child development, or what's going to prevent them from drugs, alcohol, gangs, etc.

People love their kids, but there is nothing loving about hitting. There are laws against it. It is possible that parents take too many liberties with their kids and fail to realize that they have their own thoughts, obstacles, struggles. Yes, kids do need to learn to respect their parents, but it works both ways. If spanking is the norm in your household, then you need to tap into some resources and find another way. Spanking is absolutely for the lazy and the easy way out.

1-2-3 Magic is a discipline system which works, and you can get it on tape and from your local libraries, family centres, or family physicians.
You go girl!
 
I have not read any of the replies to this post because I did not want to read one that would anger me, disappoint me or just plain make me hate someone.

I was beaten as a child, several times to unconsciousness. I can remember not knowing what I had done wrong. So I learned to lie. And I lied about everything.
I lived in terror.

As a result I never spanked my children and I do not believe in it. Spank, grab or yell at your kid in my presence and I'll stop you and have the locals on your ass within 3 minutes.

Never assualt and/or batter your children. The end.
 
jujubes said:
I have two kids.

Spanking is bullshit.

Can I totally see a parent spanking as a result of desperate total frustration? Yes. I have been there myself. Is it justified? No. I have a challenging son who I at all costs attempt to talk to or alternatively take things away and time him out. Does it work so that he never misbehaves the next time? No. Does spanking? No.

What do we teach our kids about hurting others? Not to do it, right? Not to hit, kick, punch, push, grab. Why? Because physical violence toward others is wrong, right? Then we turn around and hit them. So we condition our kids to behave by using fear of corporal punishment? I don't want my kids to walk all over me and disrespect me, but I sure as hell don't want them FEARING me. I continue to work towards finding resolutions that don't include physical harm. It's my job, obligation, and responsibility. Welcome to parenthood. My father slapped my sister in the head so many times, I used to stand there and bawl my eyes out watching. Was she a difficult girl..yes. But no one is going to tell me this shit..be it slams on the bum, or a few "controlled shots with a belt" wtf???..is the path to happy and respectful child development, or what's going to prevent them from drugs, alcohol, gangs, etc.

People love their kids, but there is nothing loving about hitting. There are laws against it. It is possible that parents take too many liberties with their kids and fail to realize that they have their own thoughts, obstacles, struggles. Yes, kids do need to learn to respect their parents, but it works both ways. If spanking is the norm in your household, then you need to tap into some resources and find another way. Spanking is absolutely for the lazy and the easy way out.

1-2-3 Magic is a discipline system which works, and you can get it on tape and from your local libraries, family centres, or family physicians.

I couldn't agree with this more, very well said Jujube, I'm impressed.

Thelion, that sucks that you were treated in the manner that you were, at least now you sem to be a stronger pesrson for it by stopping that chain in your family. No form of spanking is acceptable PERIOD!
 
Looksa like the non-spankers are winning 3-2.
When my daughter was growing up, there was no way to punish her. Time outs didn't work making her stay in her room (with no toys/books), go to bed early, take away deserts, sleep overs, TV. she didn't care. If you made her go to bed early or stand in the corner, she would do so, until she fell asleep. She wasn't passionate enough about anything to let it control her behaviour.
She wasn't a bad kid, just normal kid stuff, maybe even better than most. But when it came time to discipline her, she didn't care.
When we tried positive reinforcemeent, it would backfire. Because when we'd try to admonish her for something, she'd say, "But I'm a good girl. I don't do bad things." I tell you, it was hard not to laugh when she said it, but still, it didn't work.
So, we spanked. I bet, between the ages of 5-15, I spanked her less than 10 times.
I know a guy who never spanked his kids. He hollers at them, intimidates the hell out of them, & threatens them. Better he spank 3 times a year, than the continual barrage of threats & intimidation.
BTW, thereis a big difference between spanking & beatings. A lot of you don't see a difference, but a kid who was spanked does not feel affraid of their parents. I was never afraid of my father, & he was a big strong, rough man. But he never failed to show his love, whether I was being punished or not.
 
HiDnGoD said:
I spanked her less than 10 times.

Did you happen to catch the look in her eye those ten times?

The glimmer of pain, defiance and/or stoicness (for those kids who get hit regularly), sadness, shock, and hate in the eyes of children who get spanked, hit, beaten, whacked, whatever you want to call it, mixed with their common attempts to act as if it doesn't matter, should be enough to want to cause any compassionate and loving parent to want to find another way.

Screw the rest of the excuses.
 
For all who think they are enlightening me - please reread that my situation is not about patting the bottom of a willfull 2 year old.

My children are in a terrible situation where they are forced to shuffle between two households. One where there is ZERO discipline and where they are rewarded for acting out at my home. On top of the fact that they are dealing with all of the issues of raging hormones, peer pressure, their changing bodies and roles in the world, and the very ABNORMAL issues of watching a judge systematically give them to their father even when their mother has NEVER broken the law or done thing one to harm anyone. <---- makes for some fucked up kids. But that's ok because it is MY JOB to help give them the tools they need in order to function properly in a fucked up world.

There is no 1-2-3 magic that is going to work for a 13 1/2 year old who is choosing to come and go as she pleases. I recently found out that there is a registered sex offender living within .8 miles of my daughters' school. I had no clue where she was on a Friday night till 11:30PM. I am sure that taking her IPOD or having her sit on a time out chair would have worked magic like it did when she had a tantrum at the age of four because I wouldn't let her stay up past 8PM.

Again - until you have walked a mile in my shoes, you can say what you want, but your suggestions are frankly insulting to my intelligence.

You can say what you like. I NEVER had a problem disciplining my children before I split from their father. I have four - close in age. My oldest was 8 when I asked their abusive father to leave us. I can count on one hand how many times ALL FOUR of my children have been physically disciplined by me their entire lives. My oldest is now 13 1/2.

I honestly wish that the anti-spank camp would read more of my posts about positive parenting and how corporal punishment is not necessary for all children but when it is properly used as a small part of the whole scope of discipline it IS 100% effective.

If you dont believe in it, fine. Dont spank your kid. As long as he isnt harming me or my kids more power to you.

Again - the police department will not be calling YOU when MY DAUGHTER has been molested by some sick fuck because she thought she was old enough to decide her comings and goings and the rammifications of all of the behaviors that may ensue.

If there be one adult who has raised a single child to adulthood and has never had to lay a hand on them to discipline their child, I would tremendously appreciate their input.

I have NEVER abused any of my children.

A spanking does NOT = beating or abuse.
 
I was also beaten within an inch of my life by family - not my parents. But mother condoned it and I was told to lie and hide it from my father.

I still have nightmares to this day because of all the times that I have been beaten and sexually assaulted. The nightmares come nearly every night.

I never have and never will beat or assault my children.

I did neither. If an adult can not make a distinction between beating/assaulting and disciplining a child then they 100% should NEVER lay a hand on anyone. Least of all someone smaller and weaker than them.

(My 13 1/2 y/o is physically bigger than me and believe it or not often times because of my health issues is as strong or stonger.)
 
BIKINIMOM said:
I was also beaten within an inch of my life by family - not my parents. But mother condoned it and I was told to lie and hide it from my father.

I still have nightmares to this day because of all the times that I have been beaten and sexually assaulted. The nightmares come nearly every night.

I never have and never will beat or assault my children.

I did neither. If an adult can not make a distinction between beating/assaulting and disciplining a child then they 100% should NEVER lay a hand on anyone. Least of all someone smaller and weaker than them.

(My 13 1/2 y/o is physically bigger than me and believe it or not often times because of my health issues is as strong or stonger.)

A respected 84 yrs lady at my church said she wished she'd been spanked, even by her school. Instead of spanking they'd give what I call 'Social sanctions' - they knew she loved P.E (Physical Education), so when she got bad she was forbidden P.E and given an extra math class (which she hated). Again, she said she'd rather been spanked!

Assertive Guy
 
BIKINIMOM said:
For all who think they are enlightening me - please reread that my situation is not about patting the bottom of a willfull 2 year old.

My children are in a terrible situation where they are forced to shuffle between two households. One where there is ZERO discipline and where they are rewarded for acting out at my home. On top of the fact that they are dealing with all of the issues of raging hormones, peer pressure, their changing bodies and roles in the world, and the very ABNORMAL issues of watching a judge systematically give them to their father even when their mother has NEVER broken the law or done thing one to harm anyone. <---- makes for some fucked up kids. But that's ok because it is MY JOB to help give them the tools they need in order to function properly in a fucked up world.

There is no 1-2-3 magic that is going to work for a 13 1/2 year old who is choosing to come and go as she pleases. I recently found out that there is a registered sex offender living within .8 miles of my daughters' school. I had no clue where she was on a Friday night till 11:30PM. I am sure that taking her IPOD or having her sit on a time out chair would have worked magic like it did when she had a tantrum at the age of four because I wouldn't let her stay up past 8PM.

Again - until you have walked a mile in my shoes, you can say what you want, but your suggestions are frankly insulting to my intelligence.

You can say what you like. I NEVER had a problem disciplining my children before I split from their father. I have four - close in age. My oldest was 8 when I asked their abusive father to leave us. I can count on one hand how many times ALL FOUR of my children have been physically disciplined by me their entire lives. My oldest is now 13 1/2.

I honestly wish that the anti-spank camp would read more of my posts about positive parenting and how corporal punishment is not necessary for all children but when it is properly used as a small part of the whole scope of discipline it IS 100% effective.

If you dont believe in it, fine. Dont spank your kid. As long as he isnt harming me or my kids more power to you.

Again - the police department will not be calling YOU when MY DAUGHTER has been molested by some sick fuck because she thought she was old enough to decide her comings and goings and the rammifications of all of the behaviors that may ensue.

If there be one adult who has raised a single child to adulthood and has never had to lay a hand on them to discipline their child, I would tremendously appreciate their input.

I have NEVER abused any of my children.

A spanking does NOT = beating or abuse.

I'm sorry your children are in the situation that you describe, and although I'm not going to assume that I'm "enlightening" you in any way, and realize that you are a grown woman who can do with her children what she wishes, this is my feeling about hitting kids and it doesn't require me to go back and reread anything.

I don't know what "DYFUS" is, but any organization or professional that I'm aware of that works with child discipline and children's issues does not condone or advocate for spanking. We can sit here and get into fine lines which apparently separate spanking from hitting from abuse from beating back to tapping. What a waste of time, and if the spankers have this much time to define the types of physical punishment toward their children, then I would say they have the time to educate themselves about the alternative discipline systems that are in their community, before blatantly stating it won't work with THEIR children. On the contrary, the system I mentioned is effective for older children and teens, with the necessary modifications made. I can honestly say that I still have a long road ahead of me where my son is concerned, but you can darn well be sure I give myself credit for consistently attempting to give my son the proper tools that you mention, however before I can give my son tools, I NEED THE TOOLS..that are going to hopefully positively foster my attempts to guide him in the right direction...a way that doesn't hurt him physically.

I also don't think you really can consider yourself in a position to tell others that they shouldn't speak on the subject because they haven't raised a child to adulthood. Perhaps it's because you believe we have yet to experience some kind of revelation or affinity on the way, thus making us abandon our beliefs about hitting our children. I have been in the spanking zone, but it made me want to work harder to find an alternative, not justify it and patronize other new or yet to be parents. Yes, our parents spanked us and did the best they could with the tools, knowledge and education they had, remembering that was in the day when women were expected to greet their husbands with their hair done, makeup intact, and a martini in one hand his slippers in the other. We've evolved and so therefore so should our methods with our children, especially the difficult, non-compliant, troubled ones...the ones who need us to be patient the most.

Once again, the resources are there for troubled kids, but it's the parents who need to recognize their own limitations and perhaps the truth that the burden is not there for them to shoulder alone.
 
jujubes said:
I'm sorry your children are in the situation that you describe, and although I'm not going to assume that I'm "enlightening" you in any way, and realize that you are a grown woman who can do with her children what she wishes, this is my feeling about hitting kids and it doesn't require me to go back and reread anything.

I don't know what "DYFUS" is, but any organization or professional that I'm aware of that works with child discipline and children's issues does not condone or advocate for spanking. We can sit here and get into fine lines which apparently separate spanking from hitting from abuse from beating back to tapping. What a waste of time, and if the spankers have this much time to define the types of physical punishment toward their children, then I would say they have the time to educate themselves about the alternative discipline systems that are in their community, before blatantly stating it won't work with THEIR children. On the contrary, the system I mentioned is effective for older children and teens, with the necessary modifications made. I can honestly say that I still have a long road ahead of me where my son is concerned, but you can darn well be sure I give myself credit for consistently attempting to give my son the proper tools that you mention, however before I can give my son tools, I NEED THE TOOLS..that are going to hopefully positively foster my attempts to guide him in the right direction...a way that doesn't hurt him physically.

I also don't think you really can consider yourself in a position to tell others that they shouldn't speak on the subject because they haven't raised a child to adulthood. Perhaps it's because you believe we have yet to experience some kind of revelation or affinity on the way, thus making us abandon our beliefs about hitting our children. I have been in the spanking zone, but it made me want to work harder to find an alternative, not justify it and patronize other new or yet to be parents. Yes, our parents spanked us and did the best they could with the tools, knowledge and education they had, remembering that was in the day when women were expected to greet their husbands with their hair done, makeup intact, and a martini in one hand his slippers in the other. We've evolved and so therefore so should our methods with our children, especially the difficult, non-compliant, troubled ones...the ones who need us to be patient the most.

Once again, the resources are there for troubled kids, but it's the parents who need to recognize their own limitations and perhaps the truth that the burden is not there for them to shoulder alone.

Wow...just wow, awsome post
 
OK, I understand what you are saying better than you know, however, I dont think you understand what I am saying and it is not because you aren't bright. Clearly you are exceptionally bright.

DYFUS - the division of youth and family services (the government agency that investigates all forms of child abuse) DOES condone corporal punishment. Right, wrong or indifferent - THAT IS A FACT.

How do I know? Because I have had DYFUS called on me on several occasions with all sorts of nonsense allegations of abuse and believe it or not, eventhat I starve one of my children.

Every single social worker has left my home shaking their heads and clucking their tongues offering NO OTHER OPTION from the consistent discipline I have offered my children from the time they were babies. And this did include rare occasions of corporal punishment. Whether you like it or not - that is also a fact. So there goes your theory about "tools". I HAVE THEM and employ them... every single one, including BUT NOT LIMITED TO: corporal punishment.

Your son is not with you less than half the time or even half the time being disciplined properly than having ZERO discipline and boundaries, even being rewarded for negative behavior. If your son has never been a discipline problem for you - I applaud you and hope that he grows to be a man that never brings his mother a single tear from pain.

Until someone can offer me solid concrete ways to deal with my children other than the ways that I have been (more positive parenting than negative treatment for negative behavior) I will continue to keep my ears open, but employ the methods that I do.

And I am sorry, but your son is 8/9 correct? You honestly haven't clue one what is in store for you.

Adolescence has humbled me in ways that I can not begin to explain. When I heard stories of what it was like to parent a teen I thought to myself, "Yea right - fucking incompetent moron of a parent. Probably the same one who didnt know how to get a kid out of diapers before the age of 3 and had to sleep on the floor of the kids' room till they were 6 to get them to sleep in their own beds at 11PM or had to make 5 different meals before the kid would pick the FIRST ONE to eat."

Boy - was I in for a fucking rude awakening. But my circumstances are made nearly impossible because of the specific delimas we are forced to endure and I STILL can count on one hand how many times I have had to employ corporal punishment for ALL FOUR OF MY KIDS.

I think I am doing a pretty damned good job.

Anyone who thinks that an individual in my situation is either A) a lazy moron or B) a crack whore who gives a shit but smacks first and asks question later need walk a mile in my shoes not to mention that they can kiss my rock hard ass. As I said - the morgue wont be calling YOU to identify MY CHILD'S mangled remains.

Bottom line is this:

If you dont believe in spanking, then dont spank your kid. As long as he/she is not hurting me or any of my children more power to you.

But you have zero business sounding off self-righteously to me or anyone else that has been in my shoes.
 
BIKINIMOM said:
OK, I understand what you are saying better than you know, however, I dont think you understand what I am saying and it is not because you aren't bright. Clearly you are exceptionally bright.

DYFUS - the division of youth and family services (the government agency that investigates all forms of child abuse) DOES condone corporal punishment. Right, wrong or indifferent - THAT IS A FACT.

How do I know? Because I have had DYFUS called on me on several occasions with all sorts of nonsense allegations of abuse and believe it or not, eventhat I starve one of my children.

Every single social worker has left my home shaking their heads and clucking their tongues offering NO OTHER OPTION from the consistent discipline I have offered my children from the time they were babies. And this did include rare occasions of corporal punishment. Whether you like it or not - that is also a fact. So there goes your theory about "tools". I HAVE THEM and employ them... every single one, including BUT NOT LIMITED TO: corporal punishment.

Your son is not with you less than half the time or even half the time being disciplined properly than having ZERO discipline and boundaries, even being rewarded for negative behavior. If your son has never been a discipline problem for you - I applaud you and hope that he grows to be a man that never brings his mother a single tear from pain.

Until someone can offer me solid concrete ways to deal with my children other than the ways that I have been (more positive parenting than negative treatment for negative behavior) I will continue to keep my ears open, but employ the methods that I do.

And I am sorry, but your son is 8/9 correct? You honestly haven't clue one what is in store for you.

Adolescence has humbled me in ways that I can not begin to explain. When I heard stories of what it was like to parent a teen I thought to myself, "Yea right - fucking incompetent moron of a parent. Probably the same one who didnt know how to get a kid out of diapers before the age of 3 and had to sleep on the floor of the kids' room till they were 6 to get them to sleep in their own beds at 11PM or had to make 5 different meals before the kid would pick the FIRST ONE to eat."

Boy - was I in for a fucking rude awakening. But my circumstances are made nearly impossible because of the specific delimas we are forced to endure and I STILL can count on one hand how many times I have had to employ corporal punishment for ALL FOUR OF MY KIDS.

I think I am doing a pretty damned good job.

Anyone who thinks that an individual in my situation is either A) a lazy moron or B) a crack whore who gives a shit but smacks first and asks question later need walk a mile in my shoes not to mention that they can kiss my rock hard ass. As I said - the morgue wont be calling YOU to identify MY CHILD'S mangled remains.

Bottom line is this:

If you dont believe in spanking, then dont spank your kid. As long as he/she is not hurting me or any of my children more power to you.

But you have zero business sounding off self-righteously to me or anyone else that has been in my shoes.

I'm not really clear on what you were trying to convey with regard to my son, or how you even know what age he is, but I suppose that may have come from your chats with another member here..no doubt a person who dismisses spanking as a routine way of child rearing. Don't bother to clarify.

I simply made statements to back my position on spanking, and to reinforce that there are other options, and yes to advocate for the feelings of children. If you want to talk about a pious attitude, never once did I state to you that you "don't have a clue", or rudely tell you to kiss my not-so-rock-hard ass. I believe I have an excellent understanding of what I am enduring now, and what I just may have to endure later, and yes there have been many tears brought from pain of being a mom..and a single one at that, for the fact that I have been married for the last year and a half has unfortunately still kept me in the position of single mom, raising my children by myself. Clue into that. I have challenges with my kid who doesn't need to be a teen in order for me to have a clue, and I don't have to walk in your shoes in order to consider myself a seasoned parent, which you assert. That seems self-righteous to me.

Ultimately, I hope your children fair well in all that they do. That's really the important thing above all else.
 
jujubes said:
Did you happen to catch the look in her eye those ten times? The glimmer of pain, defiance and/or stoicness (for those kids who get hit regularly), sadness, shock, and hate in the eyes of children who get spanked, hit, beaten, whacked, whatever you want to call it, mixed with their common attempts to act as if it doesn't matter, should be enough to want to cause any compassionate and loving parent to want to find another way.
Screw the rest of the excuses.
LOL, actually, I asked her last night, because of this thread, what she felt when she was spanked.
She said, firstly, she was mainly angry that she got caught, & secondly, she felt betrayed that I wouldn't believe her protestations of innocence. She said, at hose times, she never felt that I didn't love her, she knew the punishment was for a specific activity. She said she has never feared me. She has been afraid of getting caught, which she said, many times, she wasn't.
IMO, & hers I didn't spank her enough.
What you do for your children probably works for them. All children are different, even within a family, so you can't say 'this' works for everyone, or 'that' doesn't work for anyone. For people that spank their kids, it is a selfless, loving act, not done in anger or to simply make them pay for their crimes, but to get their attention in a way that works for them and to help them modify their behaviour.
Seriously, a couple of times I spanked her, I actually cried myself.
 
If I was having children now, I would look deeper into the different strategies available. When we were raising our kid there were 2 strategies, spank & don't spank. We looked at the people that we knew weren't spanked & chose the corporal route. All 3 of us made it with our psyche's intact, well, except my wife, but that's a different story.
BTW, BIKINIMOM & jujubes. You both have convincing arguments for your case. I suggest we agree to disagree & leave it at that. It's clear neither one of us will change our minds.
 
jujubes said:
I'm not really clear on what you were trying to convey with regard to my son, or how you even know what age he is, but I suppose that may have come from your chats with another member here..no doubt a person who dismisses spanking as a routine way of child rearing. Don't bother to clarify.

I simply made statements to back my position on spanking, and to reinforce that there are other options, and yes to advocate for the feelings of children. If you want to talk about a pious attitude, never once did I state to you that you "don't have a clue", or rudely tell you to kiss my not-so-rock-hard ass. I believe I have an excellent understanding of what I am enduring now, and what I just may have to endure later, and yes there have been many tears brought from pain of being a mom..and a single one at that, for the fact that I have been married for the last year and a half has unfortunately still kept me in the position of single mom, raising my children by myself. Clue into that. I have challenges with my kid who doesn't need to be a teen in order for me to have a clue, and I don't have to walk in your shoes in order to consider myself a seasoned parent, which you assert. That seems self-righteous to me.

Ultimately, I hope your children fair well in all that they do. That's really the important thing above all else.

I wasn't telling you to kiss my rock hard ass and I apologize if you took it at that. I began my statements by acknowledging that you are obviously bright. My statements towards others were mixed in to my reply but in this venue it is nearly impossible sometimes to only speak to one. I always assume that most will realize that if the shoe doesnt fit - I am clearly not speaking to them. I should remember that this is not the case.

You mentioned your son was younger so that is how I knew he was not yet of teen years.

Being a single parent isnt easy. Feel you on that.

What you (and most others) DONT understand that were my ex to die yesterday our lives would be a cake walk in comparison to what our lives have been like for the past 5+ years. To have one parent absent is not an ideal situation, however, it is far more desirable than to have your child used. Trust me on that one. We can leave it at that.

I am not self-righteous - period. Just a bit annoyed by all the attitude that has been flung at me from the word jump. The very first post on this thread is just a small example.

I have time and time again made specific remarks about:

- The merits of postive parenting.
- Establishing clear boundaries with consistency.
- Catching your kid doing something right as opposed to having to deal with a negative.
- The preference of raising your hand to show love and comfort and NOT to discipline.

I refuse to even get a TV as that would be just one more reason for my children and I to effectively ignore each other.

WE TALK.

I talk to my girls and when they talk back: I LISTEN.

We read. I am always engaged in conversation while we are doing WHATEVER - cooking, playing a game, coloring or laying in bed at night whispering sweet nothings dreaming about what our lives will be like "someday."

Now, if all of that (in a nutshell) doesnt scratch the surface of the fact that I am somewhat in touch with the fact that "a good beating now and again" is hardly an acceptable EXCUSE for parenting then there is nothing more for me to say. <----- this last statement is whence most of my frustration comes.

You are correct though, that all that matters is the well-being of the child. I have given my life for my children TWICE now and would do it again in a heartbeat. Until any one of you have sacrificed your life for a child, please dont come at me with holier than thou rhetoric (if the shoe fits). My children and I have suffered unbelievable pain because of the mean-spiritedness of another. You haven't clue one as to how it feels to be us so please just keep your judgment to yourselves. The pain is unimaginable and changes both the parent who has had their child yielded/and or taken/kept from them AND the child in ways that a shot or two on the rear end with a belt could barely BEGIN to scratch the surface of. So again, please spare me the rhetoric of the look of pain in a child's eyes.

I will tell you about the look of REAL pain in a child's eyes.

Just one example: when the police pry them off of you, "Please mommy, please mommy... I dont want to leave you mommy. When am I going to see you again mommy. PLEASE DONT GO MOMMY."

Imagine your child is kept from you FOR NO REAL REASON - NOW THAT IS DAMAGING TO A CHILD.

NEVER HAVE I DONE THIS TO THEIR FATHER - NOT EVEN WHEN THE LAW BACKED ME FOR HIM BEATING ME TO THE GROUND AND THREATENING TO VICIOUSLY KILL ME IN FRONT OF OUR CHILDREN.

THAT IS A LOOK IN A CHILD'S EYE THAT I HOPE YOU NEVER SEE.

HdnGd is also correct.

If you choose not to spank your child. Dont spank.

If I feel it is appropriate and all the other means of effective discipline have been exhausted, I WILL spank my child.

Agree to disagree - we can leave it at that.
 
HiDnGoD said:
LOL, actually, I asked her last night, because of this thread, what she felt when she was spanked.
She said, firstly, she was mainly angry that she got caught, & secondly, she felt betrayed that I wouldn't believe her protestations of innocence. She said, at hose times, she never felt that I didn't love her, she knew the punishment was for a specific activity. She said she has never feared me. She has been afraid of getting caught, which she said, many times, she wasn't.
IMO, & hers I didn't spank her enough.
What you do for your children probably works for them. All children are different, even within a family, so you can't say 'this' works for everyone, or 'that' doesn't work for anyone. For people that spank their kids, it is a selfless, loving act, not done in anger or to simply make them pay for their crimes, but to get their attention in a way that works for them and to help them modify their behaviour.
Seriously, a couple of times I spanked her, I actually cried myself.[/QUOTE]

In my language there is an expression "Better that you should cry now, then that I should cry later."

I have cried a river because I know hat most of the time when I discipline my children (regardless of the method I employ) it is basically because my kids are in a situation now because I HAD NO CLUE - still dont - how to effectively deal with their father. Breaks my heart every single time.

One of THE BEST posts on this thread yet.

Thank you.
 
Lestat said:
I too was spanked, and turned out ok.. but I can't say it didn't effect me.. a lot at the time.. less now, but I still have underlying resentment.

Ultimately, my parents did the best they could, I was the oldest and they were figuring out how to parent as they went.. overally, they did a great job.

So if you do something bad you are just going to tell your kid " oh son you didn't do the right thing dont do it again." Then he laughs as you walk away and burns you condo down the next day.
 
BLITZ99 said:
not sexually....

when does spanking cross the line? when should you stop spanking your child?

after reading a thread the other day i began wondering this....

a lot of us were hit with belts or paddles when we were young, but just because that shit happened back then doesnt make it right, ya know? so when does it cross the line???

in my opinion, if you have to take your kid to a doctor for the lashings you gave them, you are a fucked up individual with anger issues and need to get that shit resolved before you can become a respectable (not good) parent.

Spanking children? Beat 'em if ya got 'em!
 
jujubes said:
I'm not really clear on what you were trying to convey with regard to my son, or how you even know what age he is, but I suppose that may have come from your chats with another member here..no doubt a person who dismisses spanking as a routine way of child rearing. Don't bother to clarify.

Hmmmm I wonder who this member is???

Yes I think that spanking is ok, did I say it should be routine, nope can't say that I did.

I can say that I have never spanked any of the children.
 
Neo22 said:
So if you do something bad you are just going to tell your kid " oh son you didn't do the right thing dont do it again." Then he laughs as you walk away and burns you condo down the next day.

logical progression.
 
Top Bottom