I believe that whether or not you prefer one type of shape (Ronnie's magic quality i.e.) or another is a matter of opinion. And to hear it stated as fact that one is better, is a little upsetting.
Ronnie has bigger triceps, wider lats. Gunter has better conditioning. Ronnie looks very thick and massive. Gunter is also massive.
I don't know what it is, but it is my opinion that Gunter has his own magic look, that flows alot nicer than many pros of today. It kinda reminds me of Arnold, but with all the leg mass that Arnold needed (IMO). That, plus his dead-on conditioning would place him ahead of a smooth, more bloated Coleman.
Ronnie on his best day might well deserve the Olympia crown over Gunter's recent condition. But this wasn't that day.
Jacob