Djimbe said:Any of them would hit PLENTY hard enough to crush your Trachea , no ?
Oh , and the faster somethign traves the harder it hits .
Thats actually a clip of my core system , Wing Chun . I wonder whos school that is ...
Kane Fan said:TKD is generally limited to point sparring and light contact
KK has full contact as a staple
that's really the big difference
mfpd said:we put on the chest protectors and head gear and basically did full contact sparring.
jleeno_911 said:
Spanky11 said:I think that this is the main difference between TKD and KK - we do not use any chest guards, head protectors, padding, etc.
The other main difference is that we kick to the leg, whereas TKD does not (to my knowledge at least).
Second main difference is the competitions - we fight for 3 minutes, and the goal is to knock the other guy down (again, no padding).
Third main difference is that we train 50% punches, and 50% kicks - I'd say that TKD is approx 70% kicking. Also, a good KK fighter needs to have knockdown power in his hands, as well as his feet.
mfpd said:I must have come from a different 'era' TKD school. In the lower belts (white, yellow, green, blue) we did light contact sparring. In the upper belts (red, brown, black) we put on the chest protectors and head gear and basically did full contact sparring. I remember I got KO'd in class before. It wasn't uncommon to have 1 or 2 per week to really get their bell rung. We also did the point sparring stuff, but our instructor wanted to make sure we could hit and take a hit "for real" if the need ever arose. However, the only thing that bothered me was that we weren't allowed to punch to the face/head.
I have seen several of the McDojo's out there, and yes, their sparring classes are laughable to say the least.
As with any style, if you get the right instructor - the possibilities are endless. If you get the wrong instructor, it is just pointless.
Kane Fan said:I wasn't trying to say I knew what every school of TKD was
just the majority
mfpd said:I must have come from a different 'era' TKD school. In the lower belts (white, yellow, green, blue) we did light contact sparring. In the upper belts (red, brown, black) we put on the chest protectors and head gear and basically did full contact sparring. I remember I got KO'd in class before. It wasn't uncommon to have 1 or 2 per week to really get their bell rung. We also did the point sparring stuff, but our instructor wanted to make sure we could hit and take a hit "for real" if the need ever arose. However, the only thing that bothered me was that we weren't allowed to punch to the face/head.
I have seen several of the McDojo's out there, and yes, their sparring classes are laughable to say the least.
As with any style, if you get the right instructor - the possibilities are endless. If you get the wrong instructor, it is just pointless.
novamanms said:I've heard about TKD way back when it was taught a bit more like Kyokushin is taught now. Most people forget that at one time, it was a military art.
I would say those punches could be effective. Many stunning, and the stun would be multiplied if one could pull off half of them in a real fight. But none are deadly. It takes 8-18 pounds of pressure to incapacitate a person when SOME vital targets are hit. But the real advantage of chaining punches at such a great speed like that would be to overwhelm their senses.
I am only skeptical about having the time and opening to pull those off. Granted, that is lightning speed. But I think in a real-life situation, it would still be a bit different.
I would use a few of those strikes and finish with an elbow...or take the guy down. Stun them, close out with a power shot, and get away.
jleeno_911 said:
I honestly dont see the Disagreement .novamanms said:Fair enough. I think we can agree to disagree on the matter.
This page contains mature content. By continuing, you confirm you are over 18 and agree to our TOS and User Agreement.
Please Scroll Down to See Forums Below 














