Please Scroll Down to See Forums Below
napsgear
genezapharmateuticals
domestic-supply US-PHARMACIES UGL OZ
Raptor Labs UGFREAK OxygenPharm
napsgeargenezapharmateuticals domestic-supplyUS-PHARMACIES UGL OZUGFREAKRaptor LabsOxygenPharm

Extraterrestrials wouldn't be hostile

HansNZ

New member
I was watching the movie "Signs" on video the other night. I find it interesting the way that the film industry usually portrays extraterrestrials as hostile creatures out to "get" us.

I find this highly unlikely. I believe any species that has become an advanced space faring organism would have gone through the social change necessary to purge itself of militaristic and aggressive impulses.

In my mind this is only common sense because any species which had not done this would have wiped itself out before it got to such an advanced level. Even at our relatively primitive stage of development it is only a miracle that we didn't exterminate ourselves during the Cold War.

Even if we don't kill ourselves off violently, we seem likely to do it incrementally through the destruction of our environment.

Just my 2c :)
 
Last edited:
Currently , some nations have the capability to turn the world into a radioactive desert, yet it hasn´t happened.
There was never more knowledge in the world than today, yet people fight each other for the same reasons as did the Roman Empire.
I don´t think technological progress and social progress go hand in hand.
 
I agree, but not to the point of absolute certainty.

Referring to a little bit of Star Trek sci-fi (or even world history), you can find numerous species that are hostile despite their technological superiority.

The Borg for instance.

Or, more realistically speaking, those nice gentlemen who discovered America and slaughtered the Indians. Advanced sea-faring organisms were probably yesterday's equivalent of today's space-faring organisms, yet the purging of aggressive impulses was certainly not the case.

But I do believe strongly that the intentions of an extraterrestrial visitor will not be to rape and pillage... though I don't see any other point of visiting such a primative society. Surely they'd know that the first thing we'd ask for is their technology and medicine with nothing in exchange. That's certainly been the case on an Earth-level when it comes to a relationship between the U.S. and third world countries.

Let's just hope that the first extraterrestrial greeting is "Live long and prosper" and not "You will be assimilated. Resistance is futile!"
 
Actually I think their first words will be "you are still using track lighting?" ZAPPP!
 
I would feel that they would be hostile since they are far superior to us, but then again, it can work the other way too.
 
Warik said:
I agree, but not to the point of absolute certainty.

Referring to a little bit of Star Trek sci-fi (or even world history), you can find numerous species that are hostile despite their technological superiority.

The Borg for instance.


Remember Sci-fi is just that - sci-fi.

Or, more realistically speaking, those nice gentlemen who discovered America and slaughtered the Indians. Advanced sea-faring organisms were probably yesterday's equivalent of today's space-faring organisms, yet the purging of aggressive impulses was certainly not the case.


This is my point. At this stage we hadn't learned the right lessons, but we've been learning them from the mess that colonisation caused.

Our challenges are different. Back then our technology wasn't at the stage where we could wipe ourselves out, either by nuclear annihilation or industrialisation (within a liberal framework) destroying the environment. Because we face this challenge it is stimulating social change.

But I do believe strongly that the intentions of an extraterrestrial visitor will not be to rape and pillage... though I don't see any other point of visiting such a primative society. Surely they'd know that the first thing we'd ask for is their technology and medicine with nothing in exchange. That's certainly been the case on an Earth-level when it comes to a relationship between the U.S. and third world countries.

Let's just hope that the first extraterrestrial greeting is "Live long and prosper" and not "You will be assimilated. Resistance is futile!"

Yikes! I'd have to disagree that the relationship between the third world and the USA is one of benefits flowing in the direction you mentioned. But that is a topic for another thread.
 
HansNZ said:
I was watching the movie "Signs" on video the other night. I find it interesting the way that the film industry usually portrays extraterrestrials as hostile creatures out to "get" us.

I find this highly unlikely. I believe any species that has become an advanced space faring organism would have gone through the social change necessary to purge itself of militaristic and aggressive impulses.

What I have always questioned about sci-fi movies is the motive for why aliens always have some paranormal abilities, such as telepathy, psychokinesis, ability to heal others, etc. What is it that people believe that evolution will grant us powers beyond the natural?

Obviously the concept is a hint at man's desire for powers beyond those he currently has, or at least their possibility of existence. This makes for a better movie than aliens that are essentially like us, only technologically advanced.

In my mind this is only common sense because any species which had not done this would have wiped itself out before it got to such an advanced level. Even at our relatively primitive stage of development it is only a miracle that we didn't exterminate ourselves during the Cold War.

Even if we don't kill ourselves off violently, we seem likely to do it incrementally through the destruction of our environment.

Just my 2c :)

The last sentence is just as fiction as the concept that any form of life that can leave it's planet, will have somehow changed it's rational desires for personal gain.
 
HansNZ said:
I was watching the movie "Signs" on video the other night. I find it interesting the way that the film industry usually portrays extraterrestrials as hostile creatures out to "get" us.

I find this highly unlikely. I believe any species that has become an advanced space faring organism would have gone through the social change necessary to purge itself of militaristic and aggressive impulses.

In my mind this is only common sense because any species which had not done this would have wiped itself out before it got to such an advanced level. Even at our relatively primitive stage of development it is only a miracle that we didn't exterminate ourselves during the Cold War.

Even if we don't kill ourselves off violently, we seem likely to do it incrementally through the destruction of our environment.

Just my 2c :)

I would have to disagree slightly. You do make a good point, but you forgot about the nature of the beast. "Survival of the fitest."

You made a comment along the lines of, this is only common sense because any species which had not done this would have wiped itself out before it got to such an advanced level. Do you realize how many countless civilizatons wiped each other out just to have the next one advance to where we are today.

Intelligence can be questioned. Questions lead to disagreements, disagreements lead to war. We are a very advanced civilization now, and look at us.

Yes, we are still existing today. But look at what the genius man has created to destroy the world. The Point is, don't fool yourself.

I do not in anyway acknowledge the existance of alien life forms, nor do I discredit it.
 
Warik said:
I agree, but not to the point of absolute certainty.

Referring to a little bit of Star Trek sci-fi (or even world history), you can find numerous species that are hostile despite their technological superiority.

The Borg for instance.

Or, more realistically speaking, those nice gentlemen who discovered America and slaughtered the Indians. Advanced sea-faring organisms were probably yesterday's equivalent of today's space-faring organisms, yet the purging of aggressive impulses was certainly not the case.

But I do believe strongly that the intentions of an extraterrestrial visitor will not be to rape and pillage... though I don't see any other point of visiting such a primative society. Surely they'd know that the first thing we'd ask for is their technology and medicine with nothing in exchange. That's certainly been the case on an Earth-level when it comes to a relationship between the U.S. and third world countries.

Let's just hope that the first extraterrestrial greeting is "Live long and prosper" and not "You will be assimilated. Resistance is futile!"

Nerd.
 
Uh....

HansNZ said:
Remember Sci-fi is just that - sci-fi.
HansNZ, that's a rather foolish thing to say.

Do you realize how much modern-day tech was envisioned in Star Trek back in the early-'70s?

In ST: DS9, the very counterpoint was made by a Ferrengi character to a Human. He commented how humans thought Ferrengi were so backwards yet their planet's history had no wars among themselves or salvery. Humans, however, killed each other and enslaved each other before going out into space.

The simple fact is, if an alien race comes to Earth, it will have one of two possible views of us. We are equal lifeforms to be treated with respect and dignity, or we are inferior lifeforms to be enslaved and exploited or erradicated.

The fact that they didn't kill themselves off doesn't mean they can't kill off those who are different from them.

The fact that they can cross thousands of light years doesn't mean they have wisdom or kindness.
 
I think they'd be all high and mighty. You know. "Well on Zardon we have...", "On Zardon our ____ is sooooooo much better than your ____" or "you think that's a bicep peak... no *Zardonite hits a double bicep pose*... that's a bicep peak."

And then I'd have to hit him back with "Oh yeah? Well if things were so great on Zardon, why didn't you keep your freaky bicep ass there?" :D
 
HansNZ said:


Even if we don't kill ourselves off violently, we seem likely to do it incrementally through the destruction of our environment.

Just my 2c :)

i read something about a project in new mexico or arizona, where they are trying to store ozone gases in empty oil reserves. it was something i just skimmed over looking for something else so it may be other pollutents. anyways, i think we will meet all challenges ahead of us in the future including environmental problems.

LOL, BTW, i love your signature. im gonna find one of yours and use it.

p.s. are you ryanh?
 
I would venture to think that they have been watching us from a far and are disgusted at the way we treat each other.
 
I had one in my bedroom last night. He just wanted to watch me jack off and that was it. Hard getting it up though with those beady eyes staring at me.
 
XBiker said:
I would venture to think that they have been watching us from a far and are disgusted at the way we treat each other.

Either that or they look at it as one big cock fight and their placing bets.

Mad
 
Re: Uh....

Baby Gorilla said:
The fact that they can cross thousands of light years doesn't mean they have wisdom

I disagree. The type of technology it'd take to make space travel feasible is far beyond anythihg we currently have now, so any race/species who had mastered such technology would have to be generally smarter than us.

I'd say 50-75% chance they'd be hostile, but I wouldnt throw the "friendly explorers" theory out the window right away.
 
HansNZ said:
I was watching the movie "Signs" on video the other night. I find it interesting the way that the film industry usually portrays extraterrestrials as hostile creatures out to "get" us.

I find this highly unlikely. I believe any species that has become an advanced space faring organism would have gone through the social change necessary to purge itself of militaristic and aggressive impulses.

In my mind this is only common sense because any species which had not done this would have wiped itself out before it got to such an advanced level. Even at our relatively primitive stage of development it is only a miracle that we didn't exterminate ourselves during the Cold War.

Even if we don't kill ourselves off violently, we seem likely to do it incrementally through the destruction of our environment.

Just my 2c :)
I FIND YOUR STATEMENT OF THE MATTER SO TRUE. E.T'S TO ME ARE FAR MORE SMARTER THAN WE ARE. THAT'S WHY NO ALIENS WANT TO DARE COME ON OUR PLANET. WE WILL BE THE ONE'S HOSTILE.
 
HansNZ said:
Remember Sci-fi is just that - sci-fi.

i.e. an illustration of a possible outcome of events based on insufficient data to make such a hypothesis, i.e. the same thing as your belief that they won't be hostile.

HansNZ said:
Because we face this challenge it is stimulating social change.

The only thing it has stimulated in recent history is conflict. We want Iraq dead because they want Israel dead who wants Palestine dead who wants Israel dead, and North Korea decides to raise its hand and say "hey we want you dead too." Humanity on a global scale is nothing more than a gathering of savages. It's only because of the elite few (maybe 1-2% of the population) that are born each generation that keep the planet going.

HansNZ said:
Yikes! I'd have to disagree that the relationship between the third world and the USA is one of benefits flowing in the direction you mentioned. But that is a topic for another thread.

Feel free to disagree, but what have Israel and Africa given us in return for our generousity besides ingratitude and assholicism, respectively.

An extraterrestrial species is to humanity as the USA is to a Africa. Earth would get clean, efficient energy technology just as Africa got $40B to fight AIDS. The extraterrestrial species would get a new threat attempting to exploit their new technology for aggressive behavior just like the USA got "fuck you george bush... america doesn't care about human beings!" speech.

bah

I picked the wrong era to be born in. Should have waited another 3-4 centuries.

-Warik
 
Darktooth said:
0aca06c8f287a8034765ab5d2c88c2e2.jpg

LOL!!!
 
Remeber how that alien from "Alien Autopsy" had a vagina.

Mabye they want to mate with us.
 
I disagree, the premise is based on these aliens having the same internal makeup as humans. Man is what he is due to evolution. Maybe these creatures don't have emotions, which would make it so they wouldn't understand our emotions, or empathy. Maybe they would be hard wired to be violent and view it as a necessity. Who knows what their evolutionary history or sociology would be like. It could seem totally rediculous to us, but normal to them.

Are you attracted to monkeys with red butts? They have 99% the same type of DNA we do but their mentality is totally different on what is attractive. A Nazi concentration camp worker, Ghandi, Al Capone & mother Teresa all shared 99.9% the same DNA. this would be a totally foreign species, they probably would have 0% in common with our DNA, they wouldn't even have DNA most likely.
 
This discussion is inherently ridiculous.

You are trying to apply human characteristics to alien beings.

Silly.
 
Frackal said:
This discussion is inherently ridiculous.
You are trying to apply human characteristics to alien beings.

Aliens would have to share at least some characteristics with humans, would they not Frack?

- They'd have to have a way to communicate, just like us
- They'd share common knowledge with us (for example, the speed of light is no different to an alien than to us)
- They'd have to be at least somewhat physically similar to a human (physical body capable of movement, you wouldnt see an alien blob)
- They cant violate laws of physics, so if aliens wanted to come down to Earth, they couldnt "transport", they'd have to come down and land their ships
 
Re: Re: Uh....

BeefyBull said:
I disagree. The type of technology it'd take to make space travel feasible is far beyond anythihg we currently have now, so any race/species who had mastered such technology would have to be generally smarter than us....
Wisdom isn't the same thing as intelligence.

Mankind is very intelligent. Is he wise?
 
What would probably happen is that some fat alien with four green slimy tentacles would come around in a hawaian shirt , with sandals and white socks and talk about our cute, but a little backwards planet. Maybe they would bitch about about our planet not having 1000000 different canals on TV, but they can cope with it for 2 weeks.
 
I seen a ufo!

Who says aliens cant be blobs or defy laws of physics? There are lifeform blobs on our planet right now!(dont go there). So put a brain in one big deal. Who says they have to have arms and legs? Dolphins are smart, they dont have legs! Maybe they'll propel themselves by continuous high hydrogen farts! Fact is, until one of these bastards beams down in my backyard I will not formulate an opionion. I would tell the story of the time I seen a UFO, but im afraid that would be a big waste of time here. Oh well, here goes anyways. I dont know what to tell you, I havent seen any 200' diameter orbital spaced lighted up ships hoovering 100feet over a railroad track since then. I wasnt drinking either. Go ahead, have fun with that one! I know what I saw, I drove right under the motherfucker. My friend wanted to stop, I speed up and told him if he wanted a closer look jump out the fucking car because im gone. It zipped off into nothing after we were about 1 mile from it. Yeah, ok, it was a government thing! Sure! I know, it was a low orbit satellite!
 
Re: I seen a ufo!

rsnoble said:
Who says aliens cant be blobs or defy laws of physics?

The reason I said it couldnt be blobs is because blobs mostly likely couldnt put together a space ship and work the controls.

Maybe the aliens wouldnt look much like humans, but theres a good chance that an advanced life form would have arms and legs of some sort.

As for defying laws of physics, thats up in the air b/c what humans think of as laws of physics may not be all true... or aliens may find new laws of physics or ways to alter them. BUT until we see aliens transporting, flying, or something of that nature, it'd be wise to assume they they are effected by gravity, heat, etc. like humans are.
 
With all the alien sightings there are two conclusions that I have.
1. Humans want attention, are stupid and lie alot and have bad eyesight.
2. Aliens exist.

As for alien species; if one wanted to destroy us or help us they would have recce'd us first. Ie sightings. If they attacked us and nuclear weapons did not deter them we could try and ally with a rival alien species. As for sightings; speak out!
 
wouldn't be hostile

As far as visits by "Extraterrestrials", I believe they are really Time Travelers from the future or Cross Dimensional Travelers through one of the 11 dimensions! And most reports of UFO's are actually Government "Dark Project!" As far as the rest of the Abduction reports, they are the result of bad medication and Hallucinations!

The distance of any intelligent life in this Universe or one of the Bubble Universes is to far! However a possible worm hole could bypass the distance for them! Disregarding a worm hole I think the probability of the "Visitors" being Future Travelers or Cross Dimensional Travelers is higher!

As a result I believe these "Visitors" or "Extraterrestrials" would not be hostile! But Worm Hole Alien Travelers would be hostile if you follow the laws of nature! Which is survival of the fittest!

:alien:
 
Last edited:
Maybe their really hungry? Or possibly looking for a new suitable home. I have heard of the theory that aliens are another species existing on a "different wavelength" and inadvertently crossing over to ours. Sounds a bit far fetched.
 
DcupSheepNipples said:


And most reports of UFO's are actually Government "Dark Project!" As far as the rest of the Abduction reports, they are the result of bad medication and Hallucinations!

The distance of any intelligent live in this Universe or one of the Bubble Universes is to far!


No
 
I'd have to agree with Hanz in the sense that, any alien race achieving that level of technology would have to be inherently peaceful...within its own race. They could only have gotten that far if they were all at peace with each other, but that says nothing of their intentions towards other races.

-casualbb
 
casualbb said:
I'd have to agree with Hanz in the sense that, any alien race achieving that level of technology would have to be inherently peaceful...within its own race. They could only have gotten that far if they were all at peace with each other, but that says nothing of their intentions towards other races.

-casualbb

They also could have been the most brutal exterminating all others on their planet.In a word,Winners.

Mad
 
HansNZ said:


I find this highly unlikely. I believe any species that has become an advanced space faring organism would have gone through the social change necessary to purge itself of militaristic and aggressive impulses.

In my mind this is only common sense because any species which had not done this would have wiped itself out before it got to such an advanced level.


Hans,

Almost all of our technologcal breakthroughs are fostered by a desire to conquer or out-do other people.

Why would future breakthroughs arise elsewhere?
 
Re: Re: Extraterrestrials wouldn't be hostile

MattTheSkywalker said:
Almost all of our technologcal breakthroughs are fostered by a desire to conquer or out-do other people.

Why would future breakthroughs arise elsewhere?

Who were we trying to conquer when we invented the remote control?

It is very likely that in a civilized society, invention and innovation would be inspired by a desire to improve quality of life instead of conquering people.

Creating a cleaner, more efficient source of energy (hydrogen-based, matter-antimatter, etc) would serve the purpose of being cheap and less harmful to the environment. Certainly no "conquering" going on there. If anything, our LACK of invention and innovation is what is driving the urge to "conquer" since we have been blessed with 0.0000000001% of the world's oil and 99.9999999999% of the world's need for oil.

-Warik
 
I'd like to state an actual fact in this thread. Ready?

None of us have a clue about how extraterrestrials would act, hostile or whatever. peace
 
Re: Re: Re: Extraterrestrials wouldn't be hostile

Warik said:


Who were we trying to conquer when we invented the remote control?

It is very likely that in a civilized society, invention and innovation would be inspired by a desire to improve quality of life instead of conquering people.

Creating a cleaner, more efficient source of energy (hydrogen-based, matter-antimatter, etc) would serve the purpose of being cheap and less harmful to the environment. Certainly no "conquering" going on there. If anything, our LACK of invention and innovation is what is driving the urge to "conquer" since we have been blessed with 0.0000000001% of the world's oil and 99.9999999999% of the world's need for oil.

-Warik

warik,

Read my initial post. I wrote "conquer or out-do" other people. If it is not explicity for military use, innovations are driven by financial opportunity. (out-doing) Very little is invented to improve quality of life, rather instead for the financial benefit of the innovator. quality of life follows, in theory. it doesn't lead.

Remote control LOL! Remote communication via radio waves was (Surprise!) a military invention. Remote control TV is an adaptation that came about many years later. Just like the Internet.


Hydrogen powered vessels is old news. This was used 70 years ago. It's popular again due to the Middle Aeast situation.

Oil: We have alot of oil here actually. And as for consumption, it is decreasing here and increasing exponentially in the Far East. They will surpass us by 2005.
 
DcupSheepNipples said:


As far as visits by "Extraterrestrials", I believe they are really Time Travelers from the future or Cross Dimensional Travelers through one of the 11 dimensions! And most reports of UFO's are actually Government "Dark Project!" As far as the rest of the Abduction reports, they are the result of bad medication and Hallucinations!

The distance of any intelligent life in this Universe or one of the Bubble Universes is to far! However a possible worm hole could bypass the distance for them! Disregarding a worm hole I think the probability of the "Visitors" being Future Travelers or Cross Dimensional Travelers is higher!

As a result I believe these "Visitors" or "Extraterrestrials" would not be hostile! But Worm Hole Alien Travelers would be hostile if you follow the laws of nature! Which is survival of the fittest!

:alien:

did you read that book vistors from time too?

in it the author makes an interesting case for his theory that UFOs are actually visitors from earths future.
 
did you read that book vistors from time too?

in it the author makes an interesting case for his theory that UFOs are actually visitors from earths future.

No! But I might have to check it out! Believe it or not that all came from the neurons of my brain! I really need to start writing more of this stuff down! Money to be made and author groupies to bang!
 
At one time, you could find any number of highly respected scientists who would tell you that the heavier an object was, the faster it would fall.
They had an incomplete understanding of the laws of physics.
Maybe we do too.
All it might take is a single common breakthrough, or a new technique, and we would have a bunch of nations launching spacecraft... no wiser, kinder, gentler or more cooperative than now.
 
Top Bottom