Do you want tingle or no tingle? I vary them. For tingle I recommend Black Diamonds from Swedish Beauty. For no tingle I recommend Chocolate silk also from them. If you want something with a little l-tyrosine in it then there is a product I used called hempz, with hemp seed in it. all trendiness aside it was a really good product and got very hot but did not last and itch like the tingle products do.