Allthewhey vs Optimum 100%

[Becoming]

Just wanted to take a quick poll before I order some more protein. Want to go with optimum 100% whey (w/aminogen) OR isolate from allthewhey...

Here is the criteria.... I get big time stomach problems from most whey, bars, etc. (seriously, one protien bar and I am in bigtime pain- like on the ground type pain).... Had been from ordering PF casinate 30%, egg 30%, whey isolate 40% with aminogen added, but sick of the 10+ day wait for their stuff.... That was the first stuff I could put down, previous was always going with egg....

What I am looking for is anyone else who gets bigtime stomach probs from whey who can reccomend either? I would go with allthewhey, but no aminogen is added and this makes me nervous (don't know if I should risk throwing away the cash on an order).... these two brands seem to be the most popular right now....

 

[Becoming]

Bump for info... I know MissChris had weighed in on the side of allthewhey in a previous thread, but wanted to see if anyone else similar had history of gastro problems and had tried either....

 

[Gigantasor]

Becoming,


Have you tried any of the soy proteins? I hear they are good for people that suffer from what you are describing. I know a few guys who swear by the stuff.

 

[Becoming]

I think I recall something about soy protein and raised estrogen levels... no thanks... Also, I don't really like vegetable protein sources (personal preference-I'm anti-vegan...lol)... would rather go with whey (milk) or egg derived.... Like I said, I have had great success with the PF mix above (and their whey isolate), I know isolate in general is supposed to not have many problems in this regard, and the aminogen in the optimum is supposed to help, but just wondering about these two specific kinds....

Thanks for the suggestion though... Karma for trying to help (let me know if it is gray, but should be okay)

Bump for anyone else on bellyaches and these two specific brands...

 

[geoffgarst]

Stick with whey, milk, egg, casein proteins - much better protein over soy. Soy is okay, but don't revolve your diet around it.