Please Scroll Down to See Forums Below
napsgear
genezapharmateuticals
domestic-supply
puritysourcelabs
UGL OZ
UGFREAK
napsgeargenezapharmateuticals domestic-supplypuritysourcelabsUGL OZUGFREAK

Why Do Mexican "Illegals" Exist ???

DoseOfTruth

New member
Mexican citizen friend of mine told me he will be moving to California this year.

I asked him "How?" Thinking he was going to jump the border.

He said he had applied for a "Passport" and would be here in April or May.

Bascially he said any Mexican citizen is elligible for a passport, all they have to do is apply. Really no restrictions. I was shocked.

Being a SO-CAL native, my question is - WTF is up with illegals jumping the borders? Why not just get a passport and do it legally??
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I'M NOT SURE WHY ANY ILLEGALS EXIST CUZ WE LET JUST ABOUT ANYONE IN THIS FUCKING COUNTRY. WE NEED TO CLOSE OUR BORDERS.

FUCK, THE GUY JUST ARRESTED FROM AL QUEDA (THE NUMBER 3 GUY) WAS EDUCATED AT NORTH CAROLINA.




KAYNE
 
They need a reason to get issued a temporary visa.. We let people from all over get job or school visas to come here.
 
Anyone notice how immigration has changed in the last 30 years? Before, our policies were to allow individuals who had qualities that were beneficial to our country and most came from First World Countries. Now it is difficult for Western Europeans to get naturalized, while we literally hold Third World citizens hands while they get off the plane, bus, or run across the border. I met a man whose wife is a German citizen and she has not been naturalized after three years residency, and during her processing she cannot go home to visit and any little screw up can send her packing.

And we are trying to win a war on terrorism by attacking Iraq. Genius.
 
I SAW A NEWS REPORT AFTER THAT FUCKUP WITH THE MEXICAN GIRL THAT SAID NON-CITIZENS ARE ACTUALLY GIVEN PRIORITY OVER AMERICAN CITIZENS ON ORGAN TRANSPLANTS. HOWEVER, ONLY 5% OF THEM CAN BE ON NON CITIZENS THOUGH. EVEN STILL, THOSE 5% HAVE PRIORITY OVER A CITIZEN!!! FUCKING GREAT!!! JUST GREAT!!!




KAYNE
 
They may need a reason to get a "Visa". But to get a passport allowing them to cross into USA they need nothing. I am not sure how long a passport lets them stay in USA for, however once here what's the difference??
 
DoseOfTruth said:
Being a SO-CAL native, my question is - WTF is up with illegals jumping the borders? Why not just get a passport and do it legally??

Better yet, why not just stay in mexico?
 
The bottom line is, all borders need to be closed to all people. I don't give a fuck what country, culture or skin color you came from/are. Secondly, there are so many fucking immigrants coming to this country that they are not having enough time and space to ASSIMILATE into American culture like Italian, Irish, German,etc. immigrants did from the 1920's-1950's when immigration was curbed to allow the immigrants to become assimilated, and thus REAL AMERICANS. With so many Mexicans and Indians coming over at once, they are not truly assimilating into American culture, but moving into communitites that resemble their own little countries. Although Italians did, and still do this, we are FIRST AND FOREMOST AMERICANS. Also, we pay taxes that fund all of these fucking federal programs that these illegals love to use, but never pay a dime into because they all purposely evade taxes. DO YOU THINK YOU ARE BETTER THEN ME, PANCHO? I work for me and my own. I don't feel like working more hours a weeks sot that fence jumpers and loser ghetto motherfuckers can have money to buy crack and 40 ounces up the ass, but can't find just a few dollars to buy a pack of condoms in order to keep more of those bastards from coming into our world. I don't understand why all of the hispanics and blacks in this country, who truly can't support themselves, feel that they are somehow able to take care of not just a child, but like a half dozen. OH, THAT'S BECAUSE THEY KNOW THEY'LL BE LIVING OFF OF WHITEY'S TAX DOLALRS! Well guess what, it's survival of the fittest, and all the weak, lazy and stupid links in American society will be one day flushed down the toilet.
 
supernav said:
Because, coming from someone who immigrated *legally* -- trust me, the bureacracy and b.s. and stupidity of the INS ENCOURAGES illegal immigration. It is 10000x easier to jump a fence then it is to do it legally. You have a 100x better chance of getting deported if you walk through the INS office and try to do the paperwork, then if you jump a fence. Also if you try to do it legally, the INS will try EVERYTHING in it's power to deny your application, and sit on it for 5-7 years, unless you go jump a fence.

The whole agency is sooo f'd up, there's a reason why everyone just comes here legally. In order to immigrate, you need approximately $10,000 for a lawyer, 3-4 years to waste, and 2-3 INS interviews waiting 6 hours in line, where if anything goes wrong -- you could be deported right there. Now tell me, how many mexicans have that time and money to spend?

and the stupdiity is. The INS sends out 50,000 "lottery" green cards every year to just random people around the world. What a SLAP in the face to the people trying to do it legally that is! You, from Canada, you gotta fill out 20 forms and $2000 in fees and wait 3 years. You, from Bahrain, you get in for free. Instant green card. Enjoy. You, from Mexico, hop a fence and enjoy your stay.

-= nav =-

Stupidity can only be an excuse so many times. After awhile you must realize that there is an agenda and a concerted effort to such illogical events.
 
i think the first thing we need to do is make rednecks breeding illegal.

How many of you had parents who were also siblings?
 
Anytime some one make a valid, provable point about race/immigration, some stupid liberal responds that only rednecks make such remarks. Guess what, they are made by intelligent, educated white men who don't live in trailer parks, Paco.
 
you get a feeling they think every fucking body should be in the US. why have a immigration policy if theres gonna be this shit?
 
Fox News covered the story showing that INS is trying to deport one of the men who detained Richard Reed (the shoe bomber), because of paperwork. This man has value to our nation, but every criminal from Mexico, with no job skills, is kissed at the border.
 
mike79 said:
The bottom line is, all borders need to be closed to all people. I don't give a fuck what country, culture or skin color you came from/are. Secondly, there are so many fucking immigrants coming to this country that they are not having enough time and space to ASSIMILATE into American culture like Italian, Irish, German,etc. immigrants did from the 1920's-1950's when immigration was curbed to allow the immigrants to become assimilated, and thus REAL AMERICANS. With so many Mexicans and Indians coming over at once, they are not truly assimilating into American culture, but moving into communitites that resemble their own little countries. Although Italians did, and still do this, we are FIRST AND FOREMOST AMERICANS. Also, we pay taxes that fund all of these fucking federal programs that these illegals love to use, but never pay a dime into because they all purposely evade taxes. DO YOU THINK YOU ARE BETTER THEN ME, PANCHO? I work for me and my own. I don't feel like working more hours a weeks sot that fence jumpers and loser ghetto motherfuckers can have money to buy crack and 40 ounces up the ass, but can't find just a few dollars to buy a pack of condoms in order to keep more of those bastards from coming into our world. I don't understand why all of the hispanics and blacks in this country, who truly can't support themselves, feel that they are somehow able to take care of not just a child, but like a half dozen. OH, THAT'S BECAUSE THEY KNOW THEY'LL BE LIVING OFF OF WHITEY'S TAX DOLALRS! Well guess what, it's survival of the fittest, and all the weak, lazy and stupid links in American society will be one day flushed down the toilet.
Karma to you
 
anythingbutsane said:
i think the first thing we need to do is make rednecks breeding illegal.

How many of you had parents who were also siblings?


I agree with everything Mike said...The US will be a 3rd world country if we continue to let people in who do not share the American way of working hard to better themselves. What we have here is people coming in exploiting our system and not even trying to learn the language. On top of that all of these 3rd world people coming in have too many kids that those of us who do work will be out numbered. There is a reason the countries they come from are shit...its because it is full of lazy ass pieces of crap like themselves and by them coming here and bringing their families and having ten kids it makes the US more like their home. I'm all for closing the borders or atleast putting quotas on the amount of unskilled people coming in. Also there should be no public assistance for non US citizens...Watch the illegal immigration numbers drop then.
 
Close both borders! Put US troops on them! We are the only country that doesnt protect our border with troops! Hell Mexico has massive troops on their southern border! Open up new Ellis Islands for Immigration! Allow only a certain amount per year! Ratio near even to births/deaths per year. Have a guest worker program for those that want to work in the US, will have jobs and tract their every move! We don't need anymore workers now with a fucked up economy! Repair the Visa system and don't allow terrorists, and criminals in! Stop allowing uneducated, sick people who will not work and drain the US taxpayers! Get rid of the rule if your born here illegaly you can become a citizen! WTF is that! If your going to become a citizen assimulate, learn english, and love this country! Otherwise why would you want to be here! If not get the fuck out, because France will take you!
 
the solution is not to close the borders.

the solution is to repeal the income tax.

If we repeal the income tax, the illegals will be paying an identical share to the legals. Let them in. Let them work.

Why be defensive about these things?
 
Let them in. Let them work.

What work! You don't live near the Southwest do you! You used to see illegal Day workers on the streets in the dozens! They would get work! Not anymore! Hundreds, thousands lined up all day! No work! I have no problem with a guest worker program for those that will have work! But no work illegals got to go home!
 
We need to make that river wider and put up a high voltage fence..

If they still get my that shoot the fuckers. twice..
 
from someone who was an "illegal" immigrant many years ago, some of us didn't have a choice. our family was pretty much burned out because Pemex, by direction of Shell Oil had decided that my mother's homeground was viable for oil. the Problem is that our family, being indigenous (mexican niggers, if you will), we were not given the monetary remuneration to which all citizens who are displaced are entitled to. we were basically told to "move the fuck out" and the local authorities provided us with about a thousand pesos and bus fare anywhere we wanted. well, to make a long story short, my parents were ignorant, uneducated, country people who didn't know the ways of the city as their only source of culture was in the hills. they tried making a go in Mexico City but found that Mexicans in Mexico city were just as mistreating of the indians as can be and would often promise my mother paychecks but would never pay up. after a while, my mother decided that the best option would be to move to America since her chances were probably better there.

Now, you may say that there is no justification, you may even argue that my mother should have remained in Mexico, so i can't argue that. one thing though, i was a baby when i was brought over illegaly, so i didn't have a choice.

what i do know is that since my mother didn't have a birth certificate (most indigenous people don't or have a very hard time getting one), she coudn't get simple medical benefits in mexico, let alone dream of a Visa, and the world is as cold there as it is here, nobody really cared to help her, they just told her to go to America where having no documents isn't as bad as it is in Mexico.

should i blame my mother for hurting the american laborer? should i blame her for taking an american's job? should i have suggested to my mother that she get a "visa" and get her paperwork the right way instead of hopping the border in spite of the fact she tried with her limited resources?

have i taken advantage of the american entitlement system? actually, i will answer that , no, and nobody in my immediate family has either because although my mother was ignorant due to her country background, we are all very intelligent (standard Stanford-Binet I.Q. ratings in my family and my cousins stands at 142-167, mine is the 167), and as such, have never needed to take advantage of any "affirmative action" or "welfare" or even "unemployment" since i never stayed unemployed long enough to need it when i DID lose my job.

Unfortunately, throughout my life, i have been accused of taking jobs away from the american, when i have consistently earned my accolades (including in my current profession) entirely on my merits, in spite of coming from an ignorant, and "illegal" background.

I can also tell you that suggesting military defense of the borders is ignorant of the simple fact that you cannot stem the flow of immigration by any military means no matter how strong (see the berlin wall for more info). the problem is that as hard to believe as it may seem, there is a class of people (country folks , much like your much maligned "rednecks" in america) who do not share the educational advantages and as such, are abused in Mexico such that at the very least, if they are to live such challenged lives, they may as well make a meager income instead of die of hunger (why else would someone risk their life to cross?). this is not a choice that is made to take food away from hard-working americans, but rather a life-or death situation, made easier by american businessworkers who also pander to mexicans by offering them employment for wages that most americans would never touch with a ten-foot pole.

you may think im against some form of reform of immigration, but actually, no, i agree that a well-thought out plan should be administered, but anyone who throws out a solution while being ignorant of the situations of both americans and mexicans and other immigrants, will not have much credibility because this topic is very close to many and like abortion, one worth fighting over ... but we should never have to go there .... because the day we take it there, we have all lost ...

so please, keep in mind that we are all humans, and some of us (cognizant of the fact non-first-generation-immigrant-americans will accuse of of taking entitlements not entitled to us or advantage of affirmative action for our own means) actually have worked very hard to get where we are ..... it really hurts to hear anyone voice such hurtful and thoughtless remarks
 
since my mother's initial immigration, she has since gone to school, received her GED diploma, acquired our legal residency (in the early amnesty of 76) and is slowly working her way through college and is now an American Citizen. She is stil very much indigenous and has the "old ways" in her blood, but then again, cultural diversity is one of the blessings which she has brought me. as for me, I am already a Post Grad, still in studies and rather successful in my own merits and have the certifications (Stanford-Binet, MEPS) to prove that i did not take advantage of any types of entitlements ...

so if you want to shoot babies like me twice, i'd ask you to reconsider
 
flex123 said:
We let people from all over get job or school visas to come here.

That's not true.
They have restricted WHITE EUROPEAN immigration. It is very difficult if you are European to get papers to live and work in the states.

It is part of the deliberate plot to "brown" america.
 
Hey Kidville - why didn't you and your family just stay in mexico and try to succeed there?

Mike79, Victus..., right on.
 
in retrospect, I’m certain that our success would have been assured here and in China, but as bad luck would have it, my mother was constantly exploited for her labor in Mexico City far too many times and the fact that she didn't know how to read made it nearly impossible to get any help from government sources. after about 7 years of trying, she had me and it became nearly impossible to work and have a baby while getting bouncing paychecks, or getting your paycheck skimmed for 40% (a common practice in Mexico even today). Now I’m not trying to make her life a "violin saga" (sorry if it sounds that way), but unless you have been a part of an "undesired" underclass as we were, you cannot fully comprehend the amount of discrimination and hardship that you will run into. I guess that my mother felt that if she was going to work 18-hour days, she may as well get paid for them, so she came to America and as luck would have it, it worked out well for her. She and my father built a nice business in the garment industry, which they then used to invest in Real Estate. They still don't have Health insurance, but they are very well off with their holdings, and their unbelievable work ethic is something I'd sure like to come close to.

As for those slurs about "fencejumpers" and claiming that illegals don't pay into the Federal Tax system, this is a grossly inaccurate statement for 95% of the illegal immigrants who draw wages. the truth is that most of these individuals although they falsify their documents, pay into the Federal Income Tax system just like everyone else, except a great deal DO NOT claim tax returns at the end of the year (fear of being caught), and so the Federal Government then gets billions upon billions a year (I have the study somewhere if you want me to post it) by simple escheat. This (unofficially) is one of the reasons for why the federal government isn't nearly as militant in their enforcement of labor laws as many of you may wish they were. The problem unfortunately though is that the State governments never see any of this surplus and are often burdened with the public education of and occasional entitlements of these people who "don't exist" (insofar as being accounted for), so being that they have to pay for much of this but don't get nearly as much as they'd like, it is often the state governments which feel compelled to create legislation simply to adequately cover all their constituents. Now I’m greatly oversimplifying for the sake of illustrating the broad and significant trends here, and it's also not entirely true that the states don't see any of the "illegal" immigrants' money (there are other ways that these invisible people are counted), but for the most part, the states do not benefit on nearly the level that the federal government does. in essence, if you research immigration laws for the past 120 years, you will find that a substantial number of measures were begun by local and state governments before they became federal measures.

As for the statement that assimilation is best, I highly disagree because American culture has been, is, and always will be a mix of cultures. America is Europeans, Africans, Asians, South Americans, Australians, Canadians, Mexicans, and each contributes to the culture. The term "Americanization" was also used to "Americanize" the Native Americans (the true Americans), and Christianity was shoved down their throats too, and you should ask any Native American how he felt about that. Although I believe there should be a certain amount of homogeneity in a culture in order to effectively communicate amongst ourselves, using the term "Americanize" has for the past hundred fifty years been degraded to an ethnocentric imposition by the ruling class upon the rest of the classes. I believe that we should all speak and understand SSAE, I also believe we should know our history (all of it, good and bad), and learn to love this country as we love our families, I also believe we are Americans, not Hispanic Americans and such. I speak perfect English and know my country's history well, I love this country and have worked hard to get where I am. I have also contended with folks who feel that I should "go back to where you belong", but frankly, nowadays, I don't really think Uncle Sam or Gray Davis would really want me to leave as I have proven my worth and value to my country.
Are there dregs amongst Mexicans? Are there people who take advantage of the system? well there are dregs and nogoodniks amongst everyone, and to assume that one group of unproductive people is more an emergency than say corporations which reap 50 times the welfare that all of America gets, well, I have a hard time seeing the logic in everyone wanting me to go back to where I came from.
 
After reading some of the posts here, I have to admit that several respondents really need to rethink the whole issue. Mexicans are breaking the law in order to better their lives. If you were born in a third world country and saw immigration to the US, illegal even, as your only hope of a good life then you would take it. Christ, half of you take steroids to have bigger muscles while risking legal penalties. However, you claim you would not break the law if it would dramatically improve your lifestyle.
Americans and American organisations and companies are looking out for thier own interests, world over, at the expense of everyone else in order to line their pockets yet when a poor immigrant who was not as fortunate as many of you to be born in this country wants to lookafter his and his families interests half you goons want them killed. Lets not even forget the fact that it is immigrants who, even today, drive this coutry to succeed. Sure, close the borders. Then maybe some of you rednecks will finally see that maybe the US is not letting in immigrants because its continuing its long legacy of being the world's Mr. Nice Guy, but in fact that immigration is needed to fuel the economy. Half of my proffesors in grad school were immigrants. Do you know why the US as the best Universities in the world? I can guarantee you its not because of its American faculty.
 
DoseOfTruth said:
Mexican citizen friend of mine told me he will be moving to California this year.

I asked him "How?" Thinking he was going to jump the border.

He said he had applied for a "Passport" and would be here in April or May.

Bascially he said any Mexican citizen is elligible for a passport, all they have to do is apply. Really no restrictions. I was shocked.

Being a SO-CAL native, my question is - WTF is up with illegals jumping the borders? Why not just get a passport and do it legally??

He means a MEXICAN passport. There is no reason a Mexican wouldn't want to, say, visit relatives in the USA, for instance. Once there, he just doesn't go back.

Lots and lots of Irish folks have done this over the years. They would go on a tourist visa, then stay working illegally in relatives' restaurants, construction businesses etc. BTW it is not illegal to have, say, your cousin working in your bar if they are not getting paid and are on a "working holiday".

Howeverm if you cross the border legally the cops can refuse to let you in or come looking for you. Say, you might have to leave the address you will be staying at with them, and they might come and check if you weren't on the flight out that you had booked. INS have a long arm. Getting over the border without trace means you can't be tracked down.

Plus in places like Mexico not everyone can read and write, which I guess you need to be able to do fill out a passport form, and it's not free to apply for one either I'd imagine, not counting police bribes to "speed things up" (ie not shred your form).
 
Illegal aliens exist because they do not have the means and/or the discipline to apply properly for a green card.

It is almost always an education problem, meaning there are no (maybe very few) programs to teach people how to apply, what to expect or how long it takes etc etc.

But from the sheer number of illegal aliens, I'd say it's simply a discipline problem.
 
Gemini_Man said:
Definatley a discipline problem! It seems all these people know how to is make babies for us to support.

Well, I wouldn't go to *that* extreme.
Last time I checked, California was the only state that provides any welfare to illegal aliens, or Undocumented Citizens, as they like to call them.
 
KidVilla, you say your Mom left Mexico City because she would be over worked and loose 40% of her paycheck through skimming. When Minimum wage in the US is 5-something/hour, dont you think it is the same idea when she receives $2.00/hour for picking fruit in a field?

For every success story like yourself there has to be atleast 20 out there who come for the system. I work in a financial aid dept of a college and it amazes me how many illegals without paperwork come into my office and try to get free aid from the government to go to school. They tell me they dont understand when I say they have to pay all by cash because they arent eligible for education loans/grants.

As for your culture theory-
America was a young country 100-200 years ago. It was basically a newborn. There was no American way or a standard American Culture which is why everything seemed to mix together and be multicultural. Since then we have developed our own culture-one that is prominent enough to actually have influence on other countries cultures around the world. When the majority of people are brought up in this English speaking culture and you start to bring rice and beans into the mix many people think you are trying to change our culture of Burgers and Apple Pie. Then you have the people who lived here 30 years and still cannot speak English. We speak English here, learn it.
 
I don't know the percentage, but a lot of illegals are here because people hire them for cheap. maybe if people didnt want cheap labor we wouldn't have so many here.

Also, Bush is desperately trying to woo the hispanic vote. Clamping down on hispanic illegals would hurt his image in that community. It's all politics.
 
The Nature Boy said:
I don't know the percentage, but a lot of illegals are here because people hire them for cheap. maybe if people didnt want cheap labor we wouldn't have so many here.

Also, Bush is desperately trying to woo the hispanic vote. Clamping down on hispanic illegals would hurt his image in that community. It's all politics.

this is because the unions have over-inflated wages. This is the same reason that companies pull up shop and move to mexico.

No matter how many wally the rednecks raise to protext their 22.50/hr job sholveling stone in the quary, we live in a global economy now. If your wage is over-inflates, your employer will find a way to remove you from the equation.

Either your company moves to mexico, or mexico moves to your company. It doesn't really matter.
 
I can also tell you that suggesting military defense of the borders is ignorant of the simple fact that you cannot stem the flow of immigration by any military means no matter how strong (see the berlin wall for more info). the problem is that as hard to believe as it may seem, there is a class of people (country folks , much like your much maligned "rednecks" in america) who do not share the educational advantages and as such, are abused in Mexico such that at the very least, if they are to live such challenged lives, they may as well make a meager income instead of die of hunger (why else would someone risk their life to cross?). this is not a choice that is made to take food away from hard-working americans, but rather a life-or death situation, made easier by american businessworkers who also pander to mexicans by offering them employment for wages that most americans would never touch with a ten-foot pole.

Tell it to the UN! :bawling: Illegals dont deserve America's benefits! Nothing in life is for free! How about some restitution from Mexico for Native Americans! Your Spanish Ancestors slaughterd them! And your Racist comments are unwarented!
 
I'd like to smash you in the mush

VicTusDeuS
(I work in a financial aid dept of a college and it amazes me how many illegals without paperwork come into my office and try to get free aid from the government to go to school. )They tell me they dont understand when I say they have to pay all by cash because they arent eligible for education loans/grants.

As for your culture theory-
America was a young country 100-200 years ago. It was basically a newborn. There was no American way or a standard American Culture which is why everything seemed to mix together and be multicultural. Since then we have developed our own culture-one that is prominent enough to actually have influence on other countries cultures around the world. When the majority of people are brought up in this English speaking culture and you start to bring rice and beans into the mix many people think you are trying to change our culture of Burgers and Apple Pie. Then you have the people who lived here 30 years and still cannot speak English.( We speak English here, learn it.)VicTusDeuS

First you write about being amazed how many illegals try to get government funding for education. Then you spout off some ignorant shit about "We speak english learn it".Funding for education...Hello shithead..(speak english)sounds like their trying. If people like you had a brain you'd be dangerous.
 
VicTusDeuS said:
When the majority of people are brought up in this English speaking culture and you start to bring rice and beans into the mix many people think you are trying to change our culture of Burgers and Apple Pie. Then you have the people who lived here 30 years and still cannot speak English. We speak English here, learn it.


Dude, you crack me up. That reminds me of our local public pool that is overun by mexicans during the summer. It is known as the bean dip.;)
 
DcupSheepNipples- Sir, I appologize if my “quoted” alliterations appeared to be derogatory statements, but my original intent was to follow standard MLA procedure for regurgitating previously stated comments (in this instance, the term “redneck” was already used 5 times before I used it). If my comment appeared to be defamatory, please understand that my intent was never to “inflame”, but to continue the line of reasoning. Also, using the phrase “much like your much maligned ‘rednecks’ in America” was, if you consider the context and do not take my message out of it, intended to solidarize both the plight of the regional agricultural Americans who also are just as mistreated by the system as we are (solidarize means that we are united in our pain/plight), in this way, it is difficult to consider my remark as racist as I am simply saying “like the pain you feel, brother”.

As for your statement about restitution from Mexico for Native Americans, well, this reasoning is specious because our “Spanish Ancestors” slaughtered my indigenous peoples too, as a matter of fact, the great Devil, Hernan Cortez killed and wiped out the entire Aztec civilization to the point that a nuclear device could not have done a better job. There is no unity between Mexicans and Spanish as there is between Americans and English (at least not in a soul-to-soul way, but I'm sure business relations are good simply because we share a common tongue), and many educated Mexicans, the ones who becomes professionals in Mexico have a mild resentment whenever they recall how inhumanly their ancestors were treated. I have mild reservations about remunerations, but in my heart I feel it is a good idea, but to do so would bankrupt the Spanish, but I’m sure you are well aware of the atrocities that one people will do to others, and how their children are held in contempt for the sins of their fathers, and how the children resent this because they feel they were not the causes of the pain of the oppressed. In other words, Pol-Pot, Hitler, The South, Stalin, Amin, and many others would be facing some serious monetary losses if we followed your dictum to its logical conclusion, and for some reason, I feel this makes such a rule, impractical to say the least

As for Illegals not deserving America’s benefits, I agree with you, but the amount of rhetoric and fire that is spewed against the “big picture” problem of illegal immigration, one which has been with us since the turn of the Industrial Revolution, especially in light of the fact that we have concerns which eclipse it many times over (such as the looming threat of war and the fact that one week of war will cost our country more than all the welfare programs have cost in the past decade for the entire country, not to mention occupation if it happens, and what about gas prices and their effect on the national economy). I thoroughly agree that most entitlements such as welfare and Medicaid should be strongly curtailed to all but the most critical emergency services, but as illogical as it seems, to deny a group an education (as evidenced by proposition 187 here in California) although logical, is short-sighted of the simple fact that you don’t improve a society by denying it an education, you further impoverish it. The idea that illegals will not come to America if they don’t get an education is preposterous because many illegals already have no concept of a grammar school education and not forcing their children to school will only give them greater freedom to exploit their children’s labor. The point I'm trying to make is that broad statements such as the ones you made are not sensitive to the diverse nature of our country; and even if you did hate Mexicans (I only include this point for the sake of argument, I do not suggest that you DO hate them, so please don’t assume this is what I meant), you will not do our American society any favors by simply putting a group down …. This country is run by the dollar, not by the White Man, we should stop thinking in terms of race and culture and think in terms of how we can make our society more perfect, and denying a group and education in this modern society is worst than barbaric. I mean, ask the Chinese who have been here since the railroad workers if you need more proof of what denying a group their political and social rights will help.
 
As for your statement about restitution from Mexico for Native Americans, well, this reasoning is specious because our “Spanish Ancestors” slaughtered my indigenous peoples too, as a matter of fact, the great Devil, Hernan Cortez killed and wiped out the entire Aztec civilization to the point that a nuclear device could not have done a better job.

Ok, I get your point! Apology accepted! I know it was a horrible genocide! My whole argument rests on "Legal" nothing more! I think that coming into the US Illegaly is not moral, and is breaking US law! Why even have borders or citizenship if the borders are not respected! I just wish the borders were closed off and legal means were improved! That way those that want want to become citizens will have respect for our laws! And rather than send Mexican citizens to the US, why doesnt Fox improve the Economy of Mexico! How long is the corruption going to last! I don't know why there has not been another revolution in Mexico! And this goes for every other people and nation in the world!

I also wish business that explote illegal labor were shut down! I don't hate illegals! I hate that they are breaking laws and taking resources from tax payers! I hate the US government and Mexican government for letting them do it! And i'm your sure to admit the US can handle only so many more people now! The economy doesnt have the capital to absorb so many people at once! To many people at once causes the standard of living to go down! We can't even absorb highly educated immigrants around the world right now! It would be nice to live in a big utopia, but right now it's not going to happend!
 
VicTusDeuS – as far as making a paltry wage, most Mexicans get paid not by the hour, but by the piece, so a long-hours-working individual will make more than double or triple or even quadruple the minimum wage if they work, don’t take lunches or breaks, and stick around for 18 hours (like she did). Although the danger of exploitation exists here and is common in low-wage jobs like hers in the garment industry, I guess it was luck that she teamed up with an employer early on in America who was a decent person and paid her for what she did, mostly because he was impressed with her work ethic and it was in his interest to keep her happy (they would pick her up and take her home and buy her lunch just to keep her happy). Is there a chance the situation would be the same here as in Mexico? No if only because in America, you actually have much more disposable income than in any other country on the planet, even at 5 dollars an hour, you can at least afford to buy food and live in your parents’ house, whereas in Mexico, on minimum wage, you will barely be able to pay for 3 meals a day, so forget about clothes, radios, or any of the other disposable luxuries that even the most impoverished American of us enjoys. When one loses their job over there, they don’t have money to keep them up, so many people go hungry for days and only when they find some church to give them a meal can they hope to be fed. If you ask missionaries who visit Mexico, it is a humbling experience because only then do you realize that the idea of PERSONAL INITIATIVE, the belief that you can be a success if you just work hard and live clean and pray every night, suddenly seems questionable (but you must truly be immersed in this world to see the abject destitution and the heroic efforts by people who by all means should be dead). So no, those who manage to make a living in Mexico, do so the same way that here in America we do, they go to school, they learn, and they work with the system, but please keep in mind that tens of millions have been forcibly marginalized outside of the system…

…it is not the same to be a part of the system and to never have even known that it existed…

As for my culture theory, I think if you see my previous post, you will see that you and I probably agree on this point. I agree that we should all speak SSAE (Standard Spoken American English, media English if you will), I agree that we should all share some common communications skills and experiences in order to improve the homogeneity of our culture, but there is no one “American” culture. Evidence need not exceed our language. American English has so many non-Anglo-Teutonic words nowadays that you could not communicate with Shakespeare had if he were alive right now (interesting sidenote, as a student of linguistics and a speaker of 5 languages, it is interesting to know that current studies of English vowel shift indicates the Shakespeare’s English is closer in sound to American than British English, at least in theory). So yes, I agree that we should all have cultural fundaments that bind us, and I also wish more people who don’t speak English should speak it, but I also wish that my English sisters and brothers would increasingly take up additional languages (many people in other countries make the joke about how you call a person who speaks two languages a bilingual, and one who speaks only one language an American, not to offend, but to illustrate the large number of Americans who only speak one language) simply because of the joy of learning about new cultures and the sensitivity to other cultures that it breeds, learning a new language should in my opinion be stressed much more than it is in our educational curriculum (yes, I know it already is, but the percentage of language students who are functional in a second language is still appallingly small in light of the fact that your typical college student may average 2.5-3 years with a foreign language)
 
Didn't the aztecs kill off the mayans who were killed off by the spanish?

What about restitution for the poor mayans?
 
Re: I'd like to smash you in the mush

Lostdog said:
First you write about being amazed how many illegals try to get government funding for education. Then you spout off some ignorant shit about "We speak english learn it".Funding for education...Hello shithead..(speak english)sounds like their trying. If people like you had a brain you'd be dangerous. [/B]

Listen you wetback loving piece of shit, I was speaking of two differnt situations. On top of that, its the parents that have been here since 1985 and still dont understand a hint of english. Illegal or not if your here almost twenty years and plan on staying, atleast make an attempt to learn the language and stop wandering around my fuckin job asking every other person if they speak Spanish.
With the financial Aid part, along with the legals i get atleast 2 illegals a week that want free government money to get into school. That has nothing to do with them speaking english or not..its how they try to use the system to get everything for free even if they are not a US citizen and should not be here. It burns me up because I last year when I was in school I didnt get any government assistance because my parents made too much money yet a border jumper expects to get a handout??????
 
Kid- you seem very intelligent and should be proud of the hard work your parents put themselves through to build a better life. I have no problem with people like that, I actually see them as an inspiration to alot of home grown lazy fucks we have around here.

The people I dont like are the ones that come here specifically to use the system that was designed to help others. You work hard, your parents both worked hard and learned to save a build a life for themselves..unfortunatly not all illegals strive to achieve that. I deal with them on an almost daily basis when I am working at the college and its frustrating to see how many handouts these people get....while one of the parents only works and the other one sits at home. Maybe if she would get off her fat ass she would do something with her life. I work 2 jobs working close to 70 hours a week, surely she can have 1 job. lol

There is nothing wrong with holding on to your culture, but flaunting it around is just plain annoying...Ever here on the radio shit like "puerto rico!!! puerto rico!!!" Sometimes people here forget their Americans :rolleyes:
 
******** You are skating on thin ice***********
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Code – actually, Early MesoAmerica began with the Mayas, who after their civilization declined, were superceeded by the Olmecs (remember those colossal heads), it is only after the decline of the Olmecs that the Aztecs came into power. Neither of these societies co-existed because by the time one rose, the other had long ago fallen. The greatest of those civilizations (technologically speaking), the Aztecs, were avid collectors of Olmec art, but did not have much recollection of Mayan works. Were there trifles amongst the peoples? Yes, as in all societies since the beginnings of agriculture back 12,000 years ago, people have warred, and the Aztecs were no different. They did kill and slaughter smaller tribes when the interest was theirs, so as I had stated in my previous posts, remuneration and it’s logic suddenly loses its appeal if we consider the absurdity of determining who are the modern ancestors of the Aztecs and what they owe the Totonacas, for example.

Victusdeus – I agree with you that there are dregs in our society who do nothing more than take up oxygen and live off of the paycheck that I put in so many hours to work, for these wastes of oxygen (when they become permanent, we are all entitled to have “down” times), I have nothing but contempt and no empathy for. People who will take advantage of any system whether it be the entitlement system, the corporate welfare system (which is many times more abused, and costs our taxpayers more money, just look up what your state government pays to woo your favorite football teams into town), cheaters at school, women in the workplace who wrongly accuse innocent men of sexual harassment when such a thing never happened (abusing a rule intended to protect wrongfully harassed women), well, for these people, I cannot put into words the utter disdain that they engender in my soul.

As for holding onto your culture, I agree, but most folks who speak to me on the phone always mistake me for a non-Hispanic, possibly multi-generational American when I am a first-generation immigrant. The thing is, I listen to and enjoy Spanish rock and play it where I work, realizing that some folks might find it frustrating since they don’t enjoy it, but then again, I enjoyed “99 Luftballons” back before I learned German. I also speak to my parents in Spanish and those who know me well know that I am a very Mexican guy, but in agreement with you, I have done it in a way that I don’t impose my culture on others, but rather invite my friends to partake in it whenever they want … they enjoy the fact that we go south of the border and that I know my way around better than most (because I can speak Spanish perfectly in colloquial terms too). getting back to the point though, I agree that people should be sensitive not to impose their culture such that it makes others feel excluded (such as speaking in foreign tongues in front of others who don’t speak it), but not everyone is as cognizant of the irritation this can be. I’d categorize this in the category of minor human insensitivities and rudeness (as opposed to specifically saying it’s cultural problems), which is universal, much like people who talk on the cellphone, or motorcyclists who drive recklessly, or gymrats who hog the machines but don’t use them for their intended purpose…. It’s all a matter of them being sensitive, and those of us who find ourselves irritated should bring it to them in the most tactful manner…

Anyways, I’d like to leave by saying that the problem is complex, but we should be sensitive to all people because in the end, we are all on this train round the sun

(I know, sounds trite, but it’s a grossly underused concept) …

sensitivity to others, and helping others be sensitive to us …
 
TO KIDVILLA---

There is an old Italian saying, "A FEW shining stars cannot light up the entire night's sky." Essentially, a few hispanics who've broken the mold cannot pick up the great weight and drudgery of their own people, of whom 95% are unwillingly to ASSIMILATE into American culture and society. We Italians, just like Irish and Germans, are proud of our heritage, but we are AMERICANS FIRST AND FOREMOST. Now Hispanics have been coming to the U.S. for decades, and still they have made very little progress in the the form of assimilating into American society. Oh, yes, here and there you'll get a few "token Hispanics" who are elected to this or that political position, or be an executive at a company, but virtually the rest of them, they still speak, act and have the mentality that we white people exist to work to give our tax dollars to let their illegal and legal immigrant asses come to our country and abuse our federal programs and services, all the while refusing to assimilate into "gringo society".
 
hopefully this can answer your question

Mike79 - regarding your comment "95% are unwillingly to ASSIMILATE into American culture and society" is a grossly erroneous statement based on anecdotal or observational and personal and heresay evidence. I hope you can take my word on how prone personal observations are in regards to misinterpretation, and the only evidence I trust is double-blind findings, and even then, I have my doubts. If you have the DOUBLE BLIND amounts of evidence that 95%, then we can talk, but failing that, your statement paints a broad and negative brush over far more Hispanics than is just, and this is 1 cent of the dollar that is used to discriminate against the Hispanic (cent by cent, it adds up).

Without even resorting to studies (which I can for both sides if you wish), I present you with the following reasons for why its so hard to ASSIMILATE, yet why SO MANY DO ASSIMILATE.

1. Anti-Hispanic Prejudice - Hispanics have been here since long before Americans have in many areas, and since the beginning, we have been marginalized in much the same way as African-Americans were (maybe not in all aspects, but my point remains valid). We have been slaves, sharecroppers, not allowed to testify in court, killed, lynched, and denied the same rights as most Americans, even when they are knowledgeable enough to pursue their rights. Our jobs were taken away when soldiers returned from World War II. Hispanic-American reporters have been unwittingly "termintated" (see the life of Ruben Salazar, a prominent reporter for the Los Angeles Times who "died" accidentally by police intervention). In 2003, there are still restaurants where I will be looked at as if I was from Alpha Centauri as soon as I walk in, (and that happened when I walked into a Denny's in Woodland Hills), and I would not receive service for upwards of 45 minutes! (and when I finally did get service, the waitress told me she didn't have tortillas). As much as it may not be legal to discriminate, it's a way of life which most of us who are "minorities" must contend with. Why does this matter? Because being the recipient of centuries of prejudice makes it hard for you to reason why you want to be a part of those who oppress you (hard is not impossible, keep this in mind)

2. Natural Human Enculturation - most groups of people bind to themselves into groups whenever they are in a foreign country and Mexicans are no different. When I was in Okinawa as a kid, I was in the Gaijin community where everyone spoke English. The Americans there had no need to learn Japanese because most everything they felt they needed was in the Gaijin ghetto, and actually held it in contempt (evidenced by the fact Americans would go to Japanese centers and expect the natives to understand their language, sometimes attack the Japanese simply because they could) the local natives because they didn't speak English (1). The point to be made here is the Americans have been in occupation since WWII and a surprising few are functional in the language, even after being stationed for a decade (I admit learning "nihongo" was not easy, but the same can be said for Japanese learning to speak our "eigo"). Visiting American encampments in the Middle East, once again, you will note many Americans will cling to one another and sometimes, many will not learn the language and will resist adopting the culture simply because it is foreign to them. But as anyone who has been in any American areas in foreign countries will also attest, a substantial (I'd estimate 30-40%) portion of Americans will definitely take an interest in adopting, learning, and enculturing themselves and "when in Rome do as the Romans do," and this percentage is pretty constant amongst Hispanics too. In other words, we humans tend to group ourselves based on some binding tie, not just the Hispanics, but there are always significant amounts who will venture out from their own culture to learn the ways of their adopted country.

3. Benefits of homogeneity - you can ask the most ignorant "wetback" you see on the street what one of his top 3 goals are when he comes over here, and most will tell you that it is to LEARN ENGLISH. Even the most simpleminded immigrant understands the importance of learning the language, and many do make heroic efforts to learn the language, but learning a foreign tongue has never been an easy task (try learning one if you don't believe me, in most colleges, foreign language studies rank low in popularity due to the difficulty and repetitiveness of the topic). I mean, how many Americans would learn a foreign language if they weren't forced to? (yes, I know some like me would, but how about out of 1000, I'm sure the number will be quite low). Add to this, the benefits of an education, many Hispanics that I know realize the benefit of learning and push their children to learn, you just don't see too many of these because these folks are busy working and in school, the only ones you typically see are the ones who AREN'T working or schooling. But the Hispanic, like the rest of the human population is not perfect nor any more evolved than Americans, Europeans, or anyone else, so you will have numbers of Hispanics who after trying hard, will give up (just like everyone else, except that they have another culture to fall back on, which in this case, I agree, is a disadvantage). The third advantage that most Hispanics agree on is that "in Rome, do as the Romans" (it is popular in Spanish too), and in spite of the fact that the "Romans" will treat the Hispanics differently, Hispanics still want to emulate them. A last point on this is ALL THE WORLD WANTS TO EMULATE AMERICANS. This statement is broad so it's not 100% right, but for the most part, the Europeans like to emulate some of our things, the Japanese like to do that, and so do the Mexicans…. To see this point, talk to a Mexican who's been here for 5 years and then gone back to Mexico; I'm sure he will tell you that all his people back home will definitely notice his dramatic enculturation into American society, English (maybe choppy and not functional yet) and all.

4. Cycle of Immigration - actually Mexicans have been assimilated into American culture much like Italians, Germans, Africans, and everyone else, the thing is that once integrated enough, most Hispanics and Mexicans (not exactly the same), they blend into the background because the "racial" background and bloodline of many Mexicans can pass for Caucasian because there is European blood in Mexicans too. What this means is that John Smith probably had a grandfather named Juan Martinez, even if he has blue eyes and blonde hair. Now I'm touching a sore point here, and somebody might misinterpret what I'm saying so hopefully I can clarify it by stating this: a Hispanic that immigrated 90 years ago, marries another Hispanic, some of their kids fall in love with European or Anglo Americans and have children, these children then have kids who marry other Americans (because many who fall in love don't care about race), and by the 4th generation, they are indistinguishable by name, or appearance from the rest of the general "American" population. There is a well-known cycle of immigration that occurs over the years and its broken down into 3 generations:

4a. The first generation is the ones who cross the border. They speak their native tongue mostly and really only marry first generation immigrants like them.

4b. The second generation are the children of the first generation. They speak both languages and typically marry mostly 2nd gens, but nearly as frequently, will marry 3rd gens and "Americans"(for the sake of this illustration, Americans means all who are more than 4 generations detatched from immigration)

4c. The third generation are children of the second gens. They usually speak only English and rarely speak their grandparents' tongues. They typically only marry 3rd gen folks or "Americans" but on some occasions marry 2nd gens, very rarely marrying 1st gens. By this time, most of these folks' nationality and culture is nearly indistinguishable from what you would call "typical Americans" and for all intents and purposes, they are "typical Americans." They enjoy almost everything that "typical Americans" enjoy, and consider themselves "Americans"

(now keep in mind, this illustration is a generalization and as such, there are many exceptions to this rule, but it applies quite well to almost all cultures, whether it be Japanese, Chinese, Italian, Croatian, Russian, Brazilian or Mexican)




right now, the recent influx of immigrants (from 88-99) means that the majority of those you consider "Hispanics" or those who you mistakenly call those 95% are comprised of a substantial number of FIRST GENERATION IMMIGRANTS, and as such appear to represent the majority of the Hispanic population to the untrained eye, but in 50 years, they will be like the rest of "normal Americans," indistinguishable from the general population, even race-wise because of the strong Caucasian blood in many Hispanics.

(by the way, I don't subscribe to the concept of race, but unless you want me to double the size of the response as to why I don't, and form a thesis to explain my position, lets just trust that I have a valid reason, and every scientific body for the past 50 years doesn't subscribe to that concept either, but I know many others do, so I thought I would add that last part)

Those of us, who you can classify as Hispanics then, are just the same as you and everyone else. We are all the same, we have ignorant imbeciles who take advantage of systems and as I said before, I am all for removing entitlements to anyone who is illegal, as a matter of fact, IM AGAINST WELFARE IN ALMOST ANY FORM FOR ALMOST EVERYONE, I have little faith that it serves much of a purpose other than to keep the poor in poverty. There are the same proportions of hard-working folks, there are also the same amounts of religious folks, whores, good and bad people, and hard working people like my mother who succeed here. WHAT REALLY GETS MY GOAT IS THIS CONSTANT DESIRE TO SEPARATE THE HISPANIC AS THE PUTATIVE CAUSE OF SO MANY PROBLEMS BECAUSE PEOPLE SEE THE BAD EXAMPLES AND BELIEVE THIS PROVES HISPANICS (OR IMMIGRANTS IN GENERAL) AS "UNDESIRABLE".WE ARE ALL THE SAME MORE OR LESS AND IF WE WANT TO DEAL WITH SOME OF SOCIETY'S PROBLEMS, WE NEED TO BEGIN BY BEING SENSITIVE TO SOCIETY.

Just "shoot the fuckers. twice" doesn't solve the problem
Calling them "wetbacks" doesn't help
Making generalizations that Hispanic (or any) immigrant is lazy, a leech, or unworthy doesn't help
They are not in on some plot to "brown" America


We are all the same, so lets get together and work to resolve the REAL problems in the world, and stop going after one group when they have as many productive and valuable people as the rest of the world does……


(please, read the rest of my posts if you intend to respond as I'm pretty sure I've covered almost everything you'll have a question to, I enjoy holding intelligent discussions and covering well thought out points, but like most other posters, I feel insulted if someone asks me a question which I've already answered… otherwise, I'm more than happy to respond)





(1) for more information on American violence against Japanese: http://japanupdate.com/previous/02/01/23/story8.shtml




A discussion that is pro-immigration limitations, but I like the point Mr Burtless makes:
"If depression in wages means the overall structure [of wages] is reduced by immigration, I find that a little hard to believe. After all, some of us benefit from immigration. It may not look that way, but the fact that I can purchase a restaurant meal or stay in a hotel or have my clothes dry-cleaned and laundered at a very cheap price relative to what I could in Japan is a real benefit to me and raises my real wage."

Or the idea that in the "big picture" the effect of job loss or displacement has never been quantized:
"I just cannot buy this theory of no displacement, because I am convinced the studies must all be at such a macro level that the displacement or disturbances or adverse effect is so small on the macro scene, but in fact, there are people who are on the micro scene who are adversely affected." Markley Roberts
http://www.cis.org/articles/1994/paper9.html



Hispanics realize the importance of integration
http://www.hispanicmagazine.com/2000/oct/Features/index2.html

An interesting article covering integration of one family
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/national/longterm/meltingpot/meltingpot.htm
 
Last edited:
If you are done speaking your liberal nonsense, go clean a toilet.
 
Top Bottom