I guess I look at it like this:
Fat loss or gain is dictated by the ratio of calories ingested and the calories burned.
If 2500 cals are required to maintain weight and we are looking at a possible fat loss scenario, which makes more sense:
1 - Eating a super tight diet and allowing the diet and weights to create the calorie defecit
2 - Eating more cals and then trying to burn them off??
I see a LOT of folks doing 45 minutes PER DAY of cardio to drop fat
folks - if that is "you", then "you" need a tighter diet
Excess cardio ramps cortisol wich literally eats muscle......