Satch Vs. Carth.. The Judging Panel..

[TRAINHD]

NEEDSIZE had a good idea

each member will vote and post their vote on the thread.
for example:

PROPORTION: satch

SYMMETRY: satch

MASS: carth

BODYFAT: satch

so that would give SATCH 3 points and CARTH 1 point.

we'll add the points up after, lets say, 1 week.

sounds good?

Thats the only way to make everyone stand behind their vote IMO.

 

[satchboogie]

right on!

i think that will stick

 

[sparetire]

I never recall agreeing to that. There has to be a fair way of doing this. That poll shit doesn't seem fair at all! And in regards to poses. Someone has to teach me that shit or tell me what to do. I'm not that INTO bodybuilding. I don't know what name of the poses are. And I don't know how to CORRECTLY do them.

Someone with high authority on this forum. Like Mods, and mentors should probably discuss how we are going to vote. And most importantly what shots need to be done and how.

And once that is done. Both Satch and I should be notified.

You know, i have to say something hear that might not be so popular. When you first took the challenge with Satch, you were pretty optimistic and had a positive attitude. I know life has it's problems and we all succumb to them every once in a while and we have to decide how to take them on and prioritize. I realize neither one of you are pro body builders, but seriously, how hard is it to look at the poses of other pro's and do a few for the camera? 2nd, I totally agree with satch's outline for judging. In order to be judged fairly and correctly, we need to look at your body fat, muscular definition, tone, etc, in order for us to pick a winner. Sure, satch has a lot of fans, but so do you carth. I think if we all are honest here and judge with all honesty in mine, then the best man will win.

With that being said, can you please stop crying about what's not fair and toss the ole' "poor ole me" attitude in the garbage and get with the program. We've been listening to your roid rages for the past month or so and using them as excuses about this little, fun, challenge between you and satch. In my opinion, who cares? Pose down in any and every position and post them pics up on July 17th and let's see who wins.

Now, with THAT being said, if you honestly look better than satch in my opinion, and if i'm allowed to vote in this, i'd vote for you.

I say, get the head moderator and let him work out the rules about everything. If there's a poll, then make sure no one cheats and only votes 1 time. Or, pick a fair committe from pro's here or mods and let them pick the winner.

geesh!

 

[Smokescreen]

I am unsubscribing to these threads. So if there is anything I must really know. Please...someone PM me. Thank you!

 

[satchboogie]

I am unsubscribing to these threads. So if there is anything I must really know. Please...someone PM me. Thank you!

SO SO WEAK!!!

 

[Phaded]

i personally think its not even gonna be close even though carth is crazy he's gonna win by landslide..

 

[satchboogie]

i personally think its not even gonna be close even though carth is crazy he's gonna win by landslide..

you wanna ride $1000 on that?
and ill give you odds too.

 

[krishna]

Make sure you provide all your stats too so we can take into consideration height and length differences etc.

 

[TheAssholeFomerlyKnownAsDBBT]

i personally think its not even gonna be close even though carth is crazy he's gonna win by landslide..

I'm not going to be be near a computer on July 17--outta da country--but I would like to put my vote in now-even tho this one will not be a ballot counting close race...

CARTH
CARTH
CARTH
CARTH

Phaded this contest is a jizzoke huh, not even CLOSE ...word life Bruce410 feels me.

 

[slat1]

Heres the deal. I could care less what anyone thinks. When the pictures go up. I am putting them infront of the head judge from the NPC New Englands. I will have him fill out a score card just like he does at every show. He does not come to this site so he will show no bias and his scores will be out in the open. I will post what he writes. No matter what the judgings system is I'm posting it... That should shut everyone up about what is fair and what is not. It will all be right infront of us from a highly qualified individual who decides on a regular basis who goes pro!!!!