HANSNZ: Incorrect. The lendlease system did indeed supply the British with much material, as did other allies such as NZ and Australia, for most of the war. This materiel was not decisive at the time of the Battle of Britain when the UK fought back Germany ALONE. It wasn't until after this that this war material started to have an effect. The BRITISH prevented their own defeat, later american assistance kept a bankrupted UK in the war, it did not save them initially - the British saved themselves.
first, i never said it was decisive, but to say it didnt contribute is wrong. non-military supplies was already being sold to the allies under the 1937 neutrality act. weapons were allowed in nov 1939 under a modification of the law. and as i mentioned the US was the MAIN supplier of oil to the allies(tanks and aircraft fuel). the land lease act was passed in march of 41. at this point great britian had already been fighting for 18 months and was broke. are you telling me that at this point the british could have continued to fight the germans with success? we both agree that the major turning point was stalingrad in late 42 early 43. these american contributions did nonthing to help up until this point???
HANSNZ: Agreed, invading North America by sea would have been difficult strategically. But to say that if the Germans had attempted that the preparations the Roosevelt administration had made at that point would have been sufficient is stretching it a bit.
it would have been unsuccessful.
The British and French were making plans much earlier and look how much trouble they found themselves in nonetheless. In any case Russia was Germany's prefered target, not the US. But to say that a German defeat of Britain and Russia wouldn't have been a direct threat to the US is laughable. These two countries were all that stood between Germany and total world domination. In the longer-term it seems unlikely that the USA would have been able to defeat a victorious Germany and marauding Japan alone.
i never said it would not been a direct threat. that is the reasoning roosevelt used to convince the americans to enter the war. we could have just as easily dropped h-bombs on germany and who ever else.
HANSNZ: Really? You've done nothing more than me to prove your points. So calling arrogant Americans arrogant makes me arrogant? Interesting philosophy....