Tough choices those! Definitely no bad boys, because I don't have patience for games. Politeness is always good (to me a sign of maturity and masculinity), but not too pretty, where all they think about is their appearance. (I prefer being the pretty half of a couple!) Rugged and masculine sounds good at first, but not so rugged that they neglect basic hygiene.
My choice would be polite cleaned-up rugged masculine man.
I like a clean cut guy that knows how to dress and act. He also has to know how to treat me like a woman deserves to be treated. He also has to have a personality and he has to be intelligent too.