Please Scroll Down to See Forums Below
napsgear
genezapharmateuticals
domestic-supply
puritysourcelabs
UGL OZ
UGFREAK
napsgeargenezapharmateuticals domestic-supplypuritysourcelabsUGL OZUGFREAK

Protein Factory fails label claims test

Status
Not open for further replies.

1fast400

New member
I was sent a protein factory sample from Tony1 and Dio. Dio's has not been finshed yet.

Tony1 sent a complete sheet of what his sample had. According to Protein Factory per 100g serving it would contain:

Calories: 375.29
Fat: 1.00g
Total Carbs: 5.14g
Total Protein: 86.28g


The test done by AAC Labs via AOAC lab testing produced this result:

Calories: 312.00
Fat: 2.13g
Total Carbs 29.7g
Total Protein 63.6g



Now I'm going to catch a lot on this I'm sure. I'll have the lab results scanned onto my website within 24h and you can see for yourself.

On another note I had Inlarge II and Isomatrix tested:

Isomatrix had 3g more protein per serving, .4g less carbs and 1g of fat more than label claim. It tested very well

NlargeII had an semi-odd result. They had 75.8g of carbs instead of 86, but had 66.3g of protein in stead of 52.



Just thought I would let you guys know
 
Man, I've been referring people to protein factory for a long time:mad: pricks

I'd be interested to know about optimum also.
 
Yeah, I'd be curious to know what blend it was too.

I've heard the Optimum stuff has tested well. Someone posted something a while back about it, but there were no scanned results.
 
I been VERY skeptical of Proteinfactory for since I've heard of it. I know I've bought a ton of protein from them, but till now... who really friggin knew what they're really doing there? We just take X and Y's word for it that it's good. I'm glad someone stepped to the plate and proved a point. I know they aren't taking my money again.
 
This is irritating considering I just received an order costing a little over a $100.00. On this order I decided to separate my protein from the carbs on my post workout mix. The protein was 86% hydro 520 and 14% BCAA's. Well the moment I tried it I could tell it wasn't hydro 520. Told the girl and she said it has to be right because it checked with the guys sheet in the back. I said noway and Alex said I bet he put such in such in. THey went back and asked the guy and sure enough he used the wrong protein. Who ever put this order together also over charged me 24.00 because they totaled the quantity wrong. THis is the second time I was over charged due to adding the quantity wrong. I did just received the correct hydro 520 order and there is no denying this tastes as described. If you notice how this sample assayed out it looks like the amount of protein it should have had was replaced with carbs. I think they may ultimately have a mixing problem (quality control). There should be more testing because of human error mixing. Again i remember a while back when I emailed Alex to come on the bodybuilding.com forum I had stated several times in other posts that there were some things that needed addressed. One of those was how they blended the mix all the way down to just 1%, some photos of the operation, etc. I still want to beleive they are a good company but this needs to be addressed! I think human error with mixing is the only way aside from down right deception that the order could have been messed up. We do need more tests because I have a hard time believing they are trying to cheat anyone. THis company was started on the basis of saving us from being ripped off. The order tested was .35 micellar, .40 cfm, .10 egg, .05 hydro 520 and .05 fructose.
 
Im sorry the correct mix %'s were cfm whey 50, micellar 30, egg 10, hydro 520 5 and fructose 5. I was looking at two orders at once.
 
My guess is that it was probably an employee error, mixing the wrong quatities and not mixing long enough vs downright deception. I would be interested in seeing how their pure protein tests vs claims.
 
JavaGuru said:
My guess is that it was probably an employee error, mixing the wrong quatities and not mixing long enough vs downright deception. I would be interested in seeing how their pure protein tests vs claims.



Maybe Protein Factory gets their stuff mixed at the same contract manufacturer that does the HDT 1-AD. REally, I am serious. I could probably find out.
 
Proteinfactory.com response
I have had bad experiences with past boards, that is why I choose not to respond. When people flame me curse at me and other nonsense I will not respond period. But since the moderators of this board and the members are upstanding people I will continue to post to straighten out any concerns.

my typing and spelling sucks by the way...

1) I truly feel the 1 fast 400 should have addressed the proteiinfactory first before posting on the messages boards. Then I could have responding myself first and also pointed out the error in his analysis. Since he looks like he owns his own supplement company it looks like a blantant attack on the proteinfactory.

I started the proteinfactory back in 1998. at that time I was a heavy supplement user. I loved to learn educate myself about the suppl industry. I tried everything from boron to sterols. I used Designer protein with a passion but it gave me gas and digestive problems. I was searching the net and found Glanbia at the time they were avonmore usa. (Makers of CFM) Myself and a friend decided to start a supplement company and sell straight up whey isolate CFM. We bought a pallet. at the time it was about $6,000.00. Now it is about $12,000.00 We bought it to a bakery and had it blended with cocoa and aspartame and package it there and stuck labels on it. Of course the protein failed. Everyone knows that the suppelment industry is ruled by the marketing kings.

Hence we were stuck with allthe CFM. My friend went on to college and I continued to work for my dad. At the time I was heavy into the mesomorphosis message board and posted that I had CFM whey isolate if anyone wanted to buy any in bulk.

Boom..people liked the idea of getting a whey isolate for 8and change a pound and without all the krap in it.

I came up with the idea of proteinfactory.com saw that the name was available from network solutions and bought it. Soy was pretty popular at the time so I bought that too along with milk isolate. I started to take personal "customized" orders off the message boards emailed to me. Some guys didnt like the aspartame. some guys didnt like too much soy. Thus the customization idea began.

If anyone remembers when I first started I would have to answer my emails at about 4 in the morning. answering questions about customzing etc.Make all the customized protein orders. Then head to my real job at 9 am.. get off work at 5.. and finish the orders.

I started to expand the product line. get in more proteins. the best protein I could find and sell them at low prices.

After about 6 months I finally got into the building I am in now, hired some 18 year old girl to help me with the computer and continued to grow.

Unfortunately I did not know what I was getting into. The customzing part is a very difficult process. On average 1 man can blend up 5 orders in one hour. MAX!!!. everytime the bowls and mixers have to be clean. Thus the proteinfactory limited itself on how much it can grow. Any further growth would have caused customers orders to take 3 weeks to get if they were in CA. ( we are in NJ)

My day starts at 6 am. I start by opening the place up for the employees and mixing myself until about 9 AM. at 9 AM customers start calling the questions about customizing ect. Right now the proteinfactory employees about 10 -15 people.

Orders come in
The customized orders MUST come across my desk before mixing. Beginners mix in 25% 360 with 75% caseinate. We then have to contact the customers whom screwed up there order and revamp it.

The orders then travel to the back for processing.
Orders get processed
orders archived by the mixers
orders are brought to the front office for billing and shipping

Hence orders can be processed incorrectly from several pathways
1) order was written up incorrectly by the customer
For example
CFM 10lbs choc no sweetener

The customer gets the order and says it doesnt taste like choc because he didnt get a sweetener

2) One of the customer service girls wrote it up wrong.

3) The mixer made a mistake with the order.

that is basically in a nut shell how proteinfactory works.
I try to respond to all emails in a timing fashion. Anyone can call me at anytime during the day. 800-343-1803 If im not there I call them back. If I dont call me again, email me bug the hell out of me i dont care.,

I started the proteinfactory to give people one thing...PROTEIN..I tell you guys where I buy my protein from. I can provide the C of A's. I try to be as open as possible. I still am one of the only companys that will tellyou where the protein comes from. I am very easy to get in contact with as opposed to other supplement companies.

When I first started proteinfactory I was selling to my friends on the boards. It was fun. We were beating the supplement companies by giving them better protein and super low prices. then as I grew and supplement companies and supplement retailers learned of proteinfactory the flaming started to come. It became less personal. ( I sound like jerry mcquire here)Then after a while the boards were just people telling me to **** off. so I left the boards. That is why I posting in my original email that I wouldnot be back. The proteinfactory is about honesty, telling the large supplement companies to take there bogus pills and whatever and go stick it. I can get protein basically right from the manufacturer and not pay for the fancy packaging and advertising. 50% of my customers I have had a conversation with. Helped them with the diets protein, steroids ect. They become my friends.

I wont make any flames about fast 400, but if he was truly a member of this board he would have emailed me first to discuss things in a mature manner and not the way he went about it. Then he could have asked me to post the response. . Sorry fast400 but you went the wrong way about it. I have nothing, and I mean NOTHING to hide. Analyzed my proteins till the cows come home.

The protein that you analyzed could have been blended incorrectly. I cant guarantee it wasnt. Just like your analysis was wrong right off the bat. I called your lab, the chinese guy answered the phone. I pointed out his mistake. But what youre trying to make people believe is that I try to rip people off. That is what I see, maybe im wrong. But judgeing from the posts from other people that I what they are getting from your analysis. "Hey the proteinfactory is selling protein laced with too much carbs". that is what I see. If you didnt you wouldnt be posting all over the net. You would have came to me like a professional and talked to me first. If you think your trying to expose the proteinfactory for something your not. Once again I have nothing to hide. Proteinfactory has had loyal customers for years. Not only do we sell to bodybuilders, but we are extremely popular with the cancer boards. The CFM in Plain is extremely helpful to them. Same with the gastric bypass patients that cant have any flavorings or junk or want to be sure they are getting pure protein.


I am commericially and personally liable for the protein I ship out everyday. I pay thousands of dollars for product liability insurrance. We have to try our best to make sure we put exactly what is requested in there or we get sued for product liability. I dont play games like that.


The customizing part is extremely difficult work. Noone does it but us. Errors will be made. I cannot fix that unless every order is analyzed. Which would jack up the price of hte protein. And that is not what people would want. But if you want it i will do it for peolple.. I will make it an option on the order form.

I will respond to this post in an intelligent and professional manner. but I wont respond to flaming useless posts.

Thanks for all the business.

Alex Rogers
Proteinfactory
 
i would think, and hope, that it was only a mixing error. looks like they may have added in carbs instead of one of the proteins or something.

like JavaGuru, i'd like to see how their individual proteins test out.
 
Important question

I have a question that might affect any analysis done on products that contain protein and carbs. Unless im wrong it may be impossible to meet the label claims with any mix like this. I recently started ordering my post workout protein and carbs separately because of this. When carbs, protein, vitamins, etc are all mixed in one batch and you scoop out a serving isn't possible on that serving to get more carbs than protein or vice versa. I started wondering if when i put my post workout mix together how do i know im not getting say 70 grams of carbs and 30 protein and then the next time 30 grams of carbs and 70 protein. I have always felt this way about creatine and dextrose mixed products. You may scoop out and only get 2 grams of creatine one time and 8 grams the next even if the label says 5 grams per serving. A while back i decided to try grow. At the time it came in the 2 lb. container or individual packets and i thought to myself im going to get the packets because each serving is going to be different. If you look at the results of nlarge its off the label claims. There are 10 grams more of protein and 10 less of carbs. Nobody's reacting to this because it looks like your getting more protein than you paid for but id be willing to bet the next serving could be vice versa. You will get the amount of protein thats supposed to be in the container as a whole but its going to be different with each scoop. Isomatrix was closer to label claims because it only contains protein. i bet if we knew how much of each individual protein was in each serving and tested for them the amount for each one would be different for each serving. It wont suprise me if Dio's mix contains some carbs that it wont match the protein calculator. At the same time im willing to bet that if you tested just the individual protein from the protein factory it will match with no problem. I think if one is worried about meeting label claims they are better off ordering ingredients separately.
 
JavaGuru said:
My guess is that it was probably an employee error, mixing the wrong quatities and not mixing long enough vs downright deception.


And He's wins Emplyee of the month 12 times a year...

A scam is a Scam!

Sirwanksalot
 
$.02

Fellas,

Thought I would put in my $.02....For what it's worth, ive ordered from PF.com and was happy. When Alex talks about individual customer service, yes it was good- but this is why people order from internet places instead of XYZ, because of the service and assistance. I do not think you are a scammer.

HOWEVER, people pay $$ thinking they are getting a certain product. If it was a one time mistake, fine, no big deal. Maybee someone should run some more tests.

But all in all: it is what it is- or in this case, it isn't what it isn't....And that is the bottom line.....and that is bothersome....

A/C
 
And He's wins Emplyee of the month 12 times a year...

Actually, there is a big difference between an honest mistake and intentionally adding greater amounts of cheaper material. My company does a lot "process improvement" consulting with tier II auto maufacturers. You would be amazed at the number places during the manufacturing process errors are made, due to human error 90% of the time. Add to that the amount of custom mixing they do and there are going to be quite a few mistakes. That's why I mix components myself, I don't trust a guy who probably doesn't give a shit about his job. Here is a quick list off the top of my head where errors may occur.

1. The customer gives the wrong mix/percentage.
2. The person taking the order misunderstands the customer.
3. The person taking the order accidently writes down the wrong percentage/mix.
4. The mixer misinterprets the order.
5. The mixer makes a mistake in measuring/mixing.
6. Equipment error causes a problem in measuring/mixing.
7. The wrong mix is labeled for shipment.
8. The shipping labels get confused and the wrong mix is sent to the wrong person.
 
I've recently began ordering from PF. Alex was big help, and his story seems legit...

But a mistake is a mistake, maybe we should pay a bit more for the orders to be checked.

I will order again from PF.

TPH
 
I'm just glad NLarge actually had more protein than label claims since I've been using it for about 10 months now. I was considering switching to proteinfactory since I stopped bulking but this has me reconsidering spending the extra cash.
 
This attack on the PF is pure BS. Sorry, but sabotage of reputation is the #1 attack technique in the natural product industry.
 
SofaGeorge said:
This attack on the PF is pure BS. Sorry, but sabotage of reputation is the #1 attack technique in the natural product industry.
Damn. What do you live inside my head? That's exactly what i was thinking.

The peeps that posted this I've never seen on this board before, and as most of you know I'm here always. I've ordered from PF and will again. This guys sounds to be like a straight up bro to me and I like to think I'm able to spot this sort of thing.

I'd also bet very few OTC sups consistently live up to label claims.
 
genarr3 said:

Damn. What do you live inside my head? That's exactly what i was thinking.

The peeps that posted this I've never seen on this board before, and as most of you know I'm here always. I've ordered from PF and will again. This guys sounds to be like a straight up bro to me and I like to think I'm able to spot this sort of thing.

I'd also bet very few OTC sups consistently live up to label claims.

I think we just both tend to apply common sense and experience to most issues.

The Protein Factory has everything to lose and nothing to gain by shorting ingredients. Alex knows his business inside out. He is not ignorant that his products could be tested - hence he would be very unlikely to deliberately short ingredients to make an extra maybe $2 here and there. He has had a long term reputation for taking great pride in running a quality business, and he is envied for his good reputation by his competitors.

And now question the motivation of the "good samaritan" who posts about Alex's negative test? Who does he work for? Why would some common Joe shell the money out of his won pocket to test his $20 order of protein. He is an unknown poster here yet he readily is prepared to post the fully prepared and lengthy material on this site.

The BS meter goes DING DING DING.

This is somebody trying to do a whack job on the protein Factory - nothing more... and it wasn't even a very creative attempt.
 
Listen, 1fast400 had the sample from the protein factory tested at the REQUEST of protein factory users on the bodybuilding.com forum. He has tested samples of products that he carries as well in his nutrition store. He has stated in the posts on the bodybuilding.com forum that he doesn't think the protein factory is trying to rip anyone off and this is probably no more than a mixing error. I dont think anyone doubts that by doing testing on products requested by members of the bodybuilding.com he can drum up business but he didn't go out of his way to try to discredit the protein factory. He operates a nutrition store like the many that are out there. I dont think if he discredits the protein factory he is going to have a huge surge in people buying isopure or metrx or whatever when you can get this anywhere. The sample used was mine. People kept asking 1fast if he would do a test of their protein. No one had sent one in so i figured what the hell i'll send one in. Maybe this will stop a lot of the posts like "is the protein factory a scam". I didn't think there would be any discrepencies myself. In fact i didn't want to send it in at first because i didn't want to waste my own powder on a test that was going to be fine anyways. I have used their products exclusively for over a year. I have been contacted by Alex to verify the %'s in the mix that was used. I also don't have any qualms about using them again. THe test was done. There probably was an error in mixing. In the order that I placed after this one I had 3 ERRORS including someone mixing the wrong protein in a mix so its not so far fetched. My order was corrected and everything is fine.
 
I think we just both tend to apply common sense and experience to most issues.

haha, after reading the following you'll realize you should have used some common sense.

The Protein Factory has everything to lose and nothing to gain by shorting ingredients. Alex knows his business inside out. He is not ignorant that his products could be tested - hence he would be very unlikely to deliberately short ingredients to make an extra maybe $2 here and there. He has had a long term reputation for taking great pride in running a quality business, and he is envied for his good reputation by his competitors.

Nobody doubts this. Alex has a business that I assume he can't run by himself. If Alex has a stupid person working for him or someone that get angry at him, his products will suffer. I don't think Alex ever intended for his products to be this way, but in this case (and many others if you read the bb.com thread) it happened.

And now question the motivation of the "good samaritan" who posts about Alex's negative test? Who does he work for? Why would some common Joe shell the money out of his won pocket to test his $20 order of protein. He is an unknown poster here yet he readily is prepared to post the fully prepared and lengthy material on this site.

Um, ok I guess you win the award for lack of research. I post on over 10 message boards over the internet with a total post count of about 6,000. I own a nutrition store and online business. I've tested over 12 proteins (which you would have found had you done a search under my name). I'm also the one that did the testing on HDT's 1-AD and found it underdosed at 28mg per 100mg cap. I'm not "joe", I'm much more than that. If you would have done some reading you would know this.

The BS meter goes DING DING DING.

Something tells me this bell doesn't ring as loud right now.

This is somebody trying to do a whack job on the protein Factory - nothing more... and it wasn't even a very creative attempt.

I'm not trying to be creative, that is the job of muscletech and biotest. I'm reporting results I found from a very credible lab. Go do some more research before you post such ignorant information.
 
1fast400 said:
Something tells me this bell doesn't ring as loud right now.

Actually, the BS meter reads even louder. No one would post on 10 boards without a vested financial interest in their posting. That invalidates you as someone who would participate in an unbiased testing of a competitor's products.
 
I can't say for sure the reasons for the discrepencies in the PF's mixes. What I can give is my own personal recommendation for the Protein Factory and Alex. I have used there product for the last 3 years, and while I have had some mistakes made with my order, they were always corrected proficiently. I will admit that it would be difficult to mix many different supplements into one batch and have it be 100% consistent. For those of you who need this kind of consistency, I recommend getting individual supplements from the PF and mixing them yourself. The reason Alex and his company can offer a good product at such low prices is:

1.) Alex does a lot of the work himself which cuts down on overhead
2.) They spend next to nothing on marketing, advertising, and labeling of there product

Alex has always seemed to be a stand-up guy and has always treated every customer I know in a professional manner. I will continue to order from him and suggest the same to everyone else.
 
No one would post on 10 boards without a vested financial interest in their posting


I hope your joking right? I see MANY of the same people (at least they use the same handles) on these message boards, I guess they ALL must gain financially from it....jesus...
 
1fast400 said:



I hope your joking right? I see MANY of the same people (at least they use the same handles) on these message boards, I guess they ALL must gain financially from it....jesus...

Yeah, right, and they are all good samaritan's shelling money out of their own pockets to test health products for the good of others... then they make sure they multi post the same post to different forums.

Ocham's razor... look for the simplest answer.
 
Seems really wrong. I'm sure it was a one time thing. I mean... people on Keto order stuff from them and STAY in keto. I'm sure the carbs are what they say they are. I'm sure their home formulas are down right.
 
Just ordered my first MIXED protein from PF

1 lb Egg white
1 lb Milk Protein Isolate
3 lb Ion Exchange Whey Isolate
1 lb Caseinate

All mixed together with Chocolate and Splenda
 
I mentioned this one other time, but I will no longer order from Protein Factory... The fact they failed label tests doesn't even bother me that much (that can happen to anyone)... but that justified my reasoning for not ordering there again even more. I had a bad experience personally with one of my orders and it was promised at least on two different occasions I would be reimbursed for my troubles (either money back or product replacement). I both e-mailed and spoke on the phone with Alex and he seemed helpful and seemed like he wanted to make the situation right, but it was all talk and no action. To make a long story short, there was a quality control problem with two different canisters of his Frostein product. Test results or no test results, I do not respect a company who does not respect their customers. If I'm just a number to them and not a person, why should I do business there?
 
this is pure sabotage, in his profile he claims to own Unlimited Nutrition, defaming another company is no way of doin business on these boards
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom