i personally went through the same dilemma as you. in the past i have always used clomid with hcg. it was only a little while back i examined the "extreme" side effects i experienced. these included complete loss of libido and wacky (to say the least) mood swings coupled with depression.
further poof of my negative experiences was the fact that generally speaking i have an extremely high libido (i would fuck a donkey if it looked at me the right way!) - joking. anyway you get the point. about 4 or 5 days into the clomid i could not get a hard on for the life of me, and the ones i did get were chubby at best. this was a far cry from my 24/7 erections. okay enough about my dick, so i decided to stop clomid and within 5 days the big guy was back and ready to assassinate my girlfriend.
the point being the clomid killed my dick and sex drive in the process.
this last cycle i went without the clomid (i will list what i took at bottom) and i was as hard as a rock the entire time. now that i think about it, i have a hard on right now, i dont even notice it anymore! - again joking.
i had my blood work done both times, after the cycle.
with clomid - levels were just above baseline acceptable levels
without clomid - levels were healthy and where they should be.
first to address you question - why are we straying from what we have always known works. well, whats best today is not always best tomorrow. people took clomid because know one ever knew any better. personally i took clomid because people i knew that did crank took clomid when they were done, so why should i be any different. now i bet if i told those very same people i know to take what i took post - they would be telling people not to take clomid - remember word of mouth is based on what someone else has experienced, and they may not have pursued all avenues. and unless you try both ways "clomid and without" clomid i really dont think that you have the right to tell people what to do.
heres an example.
you may think that clomid works for you because you get "X" results from it. but what you dont realize is that if you tried it without you would get "Y" results which are greater than "X". for people to say 'well all this talk about not taking clomid is shit and ill stick with what works for me" unless you try both ways how do you know what works best for you??
to address you second comment about people worrying about the side effects from clomid and not carrying about the sides from juice. with juice i never see any sides. if they are prevalent they are internally and as bad as it sounds "out of site out of mind" right?? (i do always get blood work done post) with clomid the sides are severe for myself and it attacks my most valuable asset - my cock.
people dont care about the sides from juice because they cant see them - besides some acne. as soon as you fuck with a mans manhood - hes pissed , and scared.
its the same with smoking how can anyone possibly want to start smoking or continue with all the health risks we now know??
sorry for all the ranting - just a very in-depth point you bring up.
my post cycle:
avena sativa
zinc
magnesium
B1 - thiamine
B12 injectable
hcg