True, I forgot that there is that inherent disadvantage to plats b/c they cant give red to nonplats or it becomes a bomb. Hence, you cant say that you disagree with them.
I virtually never give red whether Im plat or nonplat though. Just my own karma deal, I dont let people manipulate me into doing it. Although, I manipulate people to get mad at me all the time. Thats funny when people take me seriously and then they take time to respond in some way LOL, like it matters. No probs giving red to people, just a personal thing for me.