I lived with my ex for a few months before we got engaged. We were married 16 months later and looking back now... I don't think I would do it again. Living together first ensures nothing.
Now that I have children I would NEVER sleep under the same roof with a man before marriage so if I ever become insane and decide to end my life all over again LOL, I will have to do it the "old fashioned" way.
It isn't whether or not you live together first that will determine whether or not you "truly" know that other person and this knowledge is not what will prevent a divorce down the road.
I knew my ex very well and he knew me. BUT after 12 years and four children the simple fact remains that I CHANGED... HE DID NOT. I am not saying that this makes it "his fault". All I am doing is offering an explanation.
Some couples will grow together with time and others will grow apart. He was the king of the castle (my fault) and when I got tired of indentured servitude he wasn't about to let me have it any other way. See what I am saying?
If I did not have children though, I would never legally remarry. I would maintain MY OWN PLACE and be a "permanent girlfriend"...
But that is only me.
The two of you should discuss this amongst yourselves and decide what the best route is FOR YOU GUYS. Don't do things because you think it is what is expected of you or it will make other people happy. If you want to live together first (It will alleviate a lot of stress, trust me on this one) then do it. If you do not, then DON'T.
Finally - believe it or not living together BEFORE marriage is totally different than living together AFTER marriage - I don't know exactly why that is, but it is. I was told this by other people in the same circumstance and passed this info onto others. I didn't believe it until it happened to me and neither did they, or the person who gave me the info for that matter (it came from a woman who did both. First time the old-fashioned way, second time not). But WE ALL CONCURRED AFTER WE LIVED IT - IT WAS TRUTH.
Good luck either way and a little word of unsolicited advice? DON'T SPEND A TON OF MONEY ON THE WEDDING - TRUST ME - IT IS A FRIVOLOUS WASTE OF FUNDS!
Either way.... I wish you two peace, friendship, comfort and mutual support. Love, your children will teach you what that is all about... Either that or you can tell me what that is when you still look at your wife with the same eyes that you did the first time you knew you loved her 40 years later when you are still reaching for her gnarled hand with your own careworn hands thinking she is the most beautiful woman ever created... this look refelcted only by her eyes when they look into yours.