First post ever on a BB. I have also tried everything under the sun.
I have used their products in the past and I like them. I never had them tested so I cant say if they have in them what they say or not, I have a friend that is fairly well known in the BB community and he never said they did not have in them what they claim. Just that they might not do what they claim. He loves a good German Micronized Creatine.
But the real way to know if they "the plaintiffs" are lying is that BSN counter sues for defamation of character. If these statements are false this is clearly slander and libel. Time will tell. If they don't counter sue, I would question the product. I will prob. purchase some other "supps" until this straightens itself out.