Devastation said:
1. 4 reps is not heavy. i doubt this is within 90% of his 1 rep max
For bodybuilding it could be considered a hair low, but I don't have any big problem with low reps

The only reason I'd change that would be to conserve energy for something else.
2. 9 sets is not unneccesary volume. i have been doing 9-11 sets of bench movements for 4 months straight and have had non stop gains. i do occasionally have a planned light day or take a day off if needed
Do you do 4 sets of bench presses to failure every time you train the movement? One at 12 reps, then three more at 10-8-4? Are your genetics comparable to Biogeared, and are your respective test levels similar? (I don't remember if you're natty as of late or not.)
Biogeared is actually doing more toward 11 sets for chest. That's an awful lot to do week in and week out...some people easily surpass that level of work with other methods, sure...but they're not going to failure
all the time, and aren't doing lots of other high-rep or isolation movements, all of which eat away at recovery like mad.
I'm not trying to bust your nut here, but it's important to keep this in the proper context. An 11 set per bodypart bodybuilding routine, especially one that's 5 on, 2 off, is very hard for most naturals to handle...
...if, of course, they want to progress. Biogeared does, but he's been stuck for awhile. Something needs to change, and making him stronger off the chest would help, but why stop there? That's like only cutting off a toe when an entire leg is gangrenous.
3. if i was a bodybuilder i would more than likely include flyes into my routine
I used to, and don't anymore. They don't do anything that the presses can't, and they typically involve much more limited poundages.
That's a catch-22. The CNS doesn't adapt to the most isolated moves as well, so progressive overload is very difficult to achieve. Moreover, the weights are already so light that even 2.5 lbs. increases represent a BIG jump percentage-wise.
I think isolation stuff is energy better spent on big, basic exercises. They're a more efficient use of the body's resources, which are certainly limited. And they're more effective, too: a guy who increases his bench press by 50%--say, from 250 to 375--will grow a LOT more pec mass than a dude who moves his DB fly from a pair of 50's to 75's.
4. his split is fine if he is not doing deadlifts and then squats the day after. if he is he will be comprimising his squat workouts. when i was bodybuilding i had great gains on a somewhat similar program, drug-free
I understand that. Many people have. Arnold certainly had great gains on his 6 on, 1 off, 2-a-day regimen...volume
can work, it's just rarely close to ideal for bodybuilding.
The crux of this is Biogeared is
not experiencing great gains at the moment. Something is obviously wrong; and given the success others and myself have had with types of low-volume training (Doggcrapping), I think volume is a very likely culprit here.
I've seen it too many times to dismiss it out of hand.
5. i still don't understand why everyone is giving him advice on how to progress in weight on his lifts when he is a bodybuilder. he is lacking in nutrition and rest if he is not progressing physically. intensity may also be lacking in his workouts. if he wants to lift more he should switch to powerlifting. even if i still was a bodybuilder, knowing what i know now, i would focus my workouts on powerlifting as this has given me the greatest base to work with that i have ever acheived
?
You're contradicting yourself bro. First, you say you don't know why a bodybuilder should up his poundage, then you say if you were still bodybuilding, you'd be powerlifting.
A bodybuilder should
always strive for progressively greater poundages. That precedes nutrition IMO...you can have the best diet in the world, but if you aren't moving more weight week after week, what's the incentive to grow?