Please Scroll Down to See Forums Below
napsgear
genezapharmateuticals
domestic-supply
puritysourcelabs
UGL OZ
UGFREAK
napsgeargenezapharmateuticals domestic-supplypuritysourcelabsUGL OZUGFREAK

Attn : YARG ... On Bruce Lee ....

Djimbe

New member
Bruce Lee -

Well , to put it Lightly he was a Martial Arts Joke .

He NEVER Fought any Trained fighter exept one (Wong Jack Man) , and the ONLY Witness that dosent currently make $ off of selling Bruce Lees name says he lost .

He moved like a Karateka - Stiff , and Hard , but he talked about being "Fluid"
.

He broke the Principles of Wing Chun, and He would go about trying to discredit things that he didn’t fully Comprehend with the most Adolescent of "Logic”.

He took the Ideas of Sports systems (Fencing & Boxing) over Combat ones, and got his "Training" in those systems from one Manual, and one Article in Sports Illustrated.

He knew NEXT TO NOTHING of the Principles of Fighting, and yet he went on and on about what was and was not "Necessary” - Simply because YOU are too inexperienced to know why a thing is needed does NOT mean that it’s not needed. It means that you lack Combat Experience enough to comprehend its import.

He also Yammered ON & ON about "Going Beyond Form" when every first Year Student knows that that’s WHY you study, to get BEYOND the Form, and get the skills into your BONES.

Anything that HE didn’t Comprehend, he condemned. It would have been FAR easier to just ASK someone that knew better, but that would have been Beyond what his Ego would allow.



He stole every saying that he was famous for "Coming Up With" ... he only "Came Up With" then from his College Textbooks.

He was a Philosophy Major in College, and he basically just Sat about in Interviews, Misquoting REAL Thinkers into little Fortune-Cookie Soundbites, when most often he didn’t even Understand the INTENT of the Original Thinker when they SAID what he was Ripping off.

He was lauded for "Great Feats Of Strength" when he just did a couple of Parlor Tricks that aren’t really that Impressive, and he was Underweight for a Male of his Height. Most Women that are fitness Hobbyists (Housewives and High school Females) Have Stronger Lower Bodies than Lee did. His Cardio was that of the Average couch Potato.

Oh, and I don’t know anybody that’s in Half Decent Shape at Bruce Lees Weight that cant do Fingertip Pushups that wants to.

He never got in any but 2 fights after the Schoolyard crap that everyone gets into. He lost that one fight according to the only Witness to it that was Neutral.

Now Bruce Lee Fans will eventually Try to eek these (Less than 5) encounters into him being some kind of "Fighter" but the one guy that he fought was a Cook with VERY little Training at the time, and HE Handled Bruce like a Child.

The only other time that he was know to Match up with someone was a Student of Master Gin Foon Mark, who had about 11 mos Training at the time, and Bruce couldn’t gain any advantage over him, even tho he had 20 Mos of WC, and he had been "Practicing At Home”. Wing Chun and Mantis Players should be EVEN at about 1 year, so that means that bruce must have LOST something with his little WC Ideas, because they seem to have Undone the last 8 months (or the Equivalent) that he was Trained.

People have said and done MANY things in Bruce’s Name that are just Untrue
.

Linda saying that Bruce was told not to Teach NON-CHINESE was one of these things . She Created an issue of Racism where one was Unneeded , and made people think that Racism in the Chinese Community were all Bigots , in the Effort to make Bruce look like some "Hero" for "Fighting the Power" and "Fighting Racism" . I know Whites , AND BLACKS - In America AND China , that were being taught WAY before Bruce was around by the Chinese , as my Father was one of them .

I feel that in the stead of making Bruce look good , this has served to feed the Racism , and make ppl; think that Chinese are Racists on some sort of Broad Scale .

That’s SO Unfair .

Personal :

Many ppl complain because he was a Drug Abuser , Steroid User , and Adulterer , but I don’t consider this to be Martially Related , so I couldn’t possibly care less , as it’s NOT really Martially Related .

Bruce’s (Legitimate) Training under Qualified Instruction :

In writing about this period in Lee's life, Jesse Glover (his first American student) stated, "Wong was four years senior (in training) to Bruce in Yip Man's clan and Bruce studied privately for a year and a half under both him and Yip Man."

http://www.cebridge.com.au/Ipman/Sifus/Wong Shun Leung.htm

2) Bruce’s level of "Physical Fitness" :

http://www.myodynamics.com/articles/bruce.html

3) Master Gin Foon Mark lets Bruce Square Off with one of his FIRST-YEAR Students , whom Bruce cant beat :

http://members.aol.com/_ht_a/martyeisen/mantis/Lee.htm?mtbrand=AOL_US

4) Bruce’s fight with Wong Jack Man . The Reporter knows NOTHING about the Martial Arts , so he thinks that Bruce was a Master (As MUST Wong be , because he won) but the Facts of the Account are Investigated . oh , it also tells how Bruce ducked out of a Rematch later in PUBLIC to save his (acting)Career :

http://www.lakungfu.com/sifujackmanwong.html



sorry if any of this is Muddled - I should be Sleeping . If anything is ask and Ill Clarify later .
 
Since MOST ppl get their "Info" from that BULL$#*! movie that Linda Lee put out -
Heres JUST the stuff from "Dragon The Bruce Lee Story" ...

1) Bruce Injured his back performing a Weight Lifting Excercise called Good Mornings , wich basically involves putting a weight behind your neck and Bowing at the waist .

2) The movie makes out that Wong Jack man would Kick Bruce while Bruce wasnt looking , (thus causing the Above back Injury) because Bruce supposedly Beat him , wich , in fact , he didnt . In fact , Wong NEVER kicked Lee at all , as he felt that his Experience with Kicks put himn at an Unfair Advantadge over lee .

3) In the Fight between Wong and Lee , there were several people present , but there ws no "Council" or whatever that was in the Film . There were a couple of Interested Chinatown MA guys , Linda Lee , and Bruce's senior Student .

4) The fight between Wong and Lee took place at a neutral MA school in Oakland . Not in some wierd cave/courtroom .

5) The Fight was to happen because Bruce put the word out that he could beat any person in the Chinatowns of the Bay area , And Wong let his Ego get the better of him , so took uo the Challenge .

6) The movie claims that Wong and the "Kung Fu Comunity" wanted Bruce to stop teaching non-Chinese . Racism never had ANYTHING to do with the fight . The fact is that Wong taught Caucasians well before Bruce did . Now MOST of his students were Chinese , but thats becase all Americans knew about back then was Karate and Judo . The fuinny thing is , Bruce hadnt made Kung Fu FAMOUS ENOUGH YET for the Chinese teachers to have more Western students !

7) accoarding to the only neutral witness , the fight ended due to Bruce giving up because he was exhausted from his relentless attack of wich he appearantly only landed a single blow . Also the fight lasted 20+ minutes . According to Linda the fight lasted a couple of minutes and was easy , but then she later says that this fight was the turning Point that made Bruce think about JKD . Why would a EASY win be any kind of Revelation ?

8 ) The Tao of Jeet Kune Do was published from Bruce Lees notes in 1979 - years after his death . He didnt "Write It" as a book , and he did not get a copy in the Mail like in the Film .

9) Bruce already had a school when he MET linda . She did not have anything to DO with suggesting he open it like in the Film .

10) The producer on the Green Hornet was introduced to lee by a HAIRDRESSER . Not everythign happened in the Manly World of MA tournaments .

11) Bruce didnt start MA lessons until he was (at LEAST) 13 . The movie suggest that he started earlier because of Nightmares or somethign . Accoarding to his senior students he only had between 18 and 24 months of Instruction total , due to having to leave for the US and Financial reasons , and was considered a beginner , though a Talented one .

12) Bruce Lee did not fight any challengers on the set of Tang Shan da Xiong (1971) . The only thing close to a challenge on a movie set was with an extra on the set of Enter the Dragon (1973) and this was a Challenge of Authority , not Prowess . The Extra was Fired , even though he walked away after being struck .

13) No one heard a "Whootah" out of Bruce until 1972 on the set of Jing Wu Men . The movie shows him doing it as a kid .

14) Wong Jack Man's brother never had to "seek Revenge" on the set of any movie that Bruce was shooting . Not even sure Wong HAS a brother .

15) As stated , Bruce didnt Fight anyone at the Ed Parkers - ESPECIALLY not in 60 seconds - He just talked about his Theories . Therefore the "Rematch" with Wong never happened . In FACT , Wong challenged Bruce PUBLICLY to a rematch because bruce lied about beating him in an Interview , and claimed that he RAN from Bruce like a Coward , so Wong took a big ad out in the Largest Chinese Lang newspaper in the Bay Area . Bruce refused to accept the challenge for a Publicly televised rematch .

SOME of the above from : http://us.imdb.com/Goofs?0106770
 
Nice post and good articles. People forget that Bruce Lee was primarily an actor and not a proven NHB fighter. I don't think he would pose a threat to any skilled fighter today in any Mixed Martial Arts competions. He was useful, however, through his films, to get thousands and thousands of people interested in Martial Arts and making as popular as it is today.
 
alex2678 said:
Nice post and good articles. People forget that Bruce Lee was primarily an actor and not a proven NHB fighter. I don't think he would pose a threat to any skilled fighter today in any Mixed Martial Arts competions. He was useful, however, through his films, to get thousands and thousands of people interested in Martial Arts and making as popular as it is today.


Oh definately , and I still watch his flicks now and again and crack up at the WHOOOTAAAHHH !!!(s) myself . But using him as a good Role Model from a TRAINING standpoint is not a great Idea . He basically eschewed EVERYTHIGN that EVERYONE that actually WORKED at MA ever has PROVEN works ! And either HE , nor ANYONE EVER using his Methods has EVER become any kind of Full Contact OR MMA Champion ! In the end what hes (and his students are) selling is Shortcuts , and there arent any . Its funny how ven the Gracies PROVE this , stick to ONE THING , MASTER it , and THEN worry about "Rounding Out" your game . either that , or figure out that Mastery is a LONG journey and accept it ! They dont let ppl represent their Family until they have had about TWENTY years in the system !

There ARE no Shortcuts .
 
All things said and done, if he gets people interested in getting off their ass and into MA training then good.

He may be all these things, such as a trickster, but for those who dont realise this, his image has kicked off thousands of students into self improvement.

My MA history started with "Karate Kid", which I know is a joke. but as a 13/14 year old, it was the turning point for me. I too was bullied and was sick of it, that movie got me interested and I started in Kempo one week later. It wasnt long before I realised the movie was Bullshit but I was firmly on my way to the person who would dish it out with joy. bAnd Bruce Lee got me interested in the Nunchuku.

Its like St George and the dragon, its all Bullshit, but if it gets you off your ass, awesome. we all had a reason for starting, some fantasy, some reality. as long as the outcome is real it doesnt matter.

But if all these things you mentioned are true, then shame on those who make him out to be all that he wasnt.
 
Top Bottom