Navbar

  Elite Fitness Bodybuilding, Anabolics, Diet, Life Extension, Wellness, Supplements, and Training Boards
  Supplements Discussion Board
  HMB

Post New Topic  
profile | register | preferences | faq | search

Author Topic:   HMB
Stallion215

Cool Novice

Posts: 15
From:
Registered: Nov 2000

posted December 06, 2000 10:40 AM

Staff Use Only: IP: Logged


Has anyone tried HMB. I bought the EAS brand of HMB. It was $90 for a bottle of 360 capsules. I have to take 4 capsules, 3x a day. I was wondering if anyone has used any type of HMB and what they experienced from it.


Click Here to See the Profile for Stallion215     Edit/Delete Message      Reply w/Quote
Julez

Elite Bodybuilder

Posts: 1165
From:UK
Registered: Dec 1996

posted December 07, 2000 01:53 PM

Staff Use Only: IP: Logged


I don't think it's such a good supplement. A few of my friends have tried it and didi'nt all that much in terms of strength and mass

------------------
Julez
Truth and Justice
shall triumph over
Bullshit and Bureacracy.


Click Here to See the Profile for Julez   Click Here to Email Julez     Edit/Delete Message      Reply w/Quote
Bart Boy

Amateur Bodybuilder

Posts: 104
From:
Registered: Nov 2000

posted December 07, 2000 01:58 PM

Staff Use Only: IP: Logged


HMB is the best supplement ever!If you couldn't tell I was being sarcastic.I can't believe they actually still sell that stuff.If I were you I'd return that shit now and get your refund.Damn, ninety dollars, you should have bought yourself some protein powder or something.


Click Here to See the Profile for Bart Boy     Edit/Delete Message      Reply w/Quote
GetHuge

Pro Bodybuilder

Posts: 429
From:
Registered: Jul 2000

posted December 07, 2000 02:49 PM

Staff Use Only: IP: Logged


Many recent studies have shown that it doesn't help at all.


Click Here to See the Profile for GetHuge   Click Here to Email GetHuge     Edit/Delete Message      Reply w/Quote
Stallion215

Cool Novice

Posts: 15
From:
Registered: Nov 2000

posted December 15, 2000 01:59 PM

Staff Use Only: IP: Logged


Your right guys it hasnt done much. the first 2 weeks i only gained 3 pounds and put 10 pounds on my bench and 20 on my squat. i will try somethin else.


Click Here to See the Profile for Stallion215     Edit/Delete Message      Reply w/Quote
Valdez

Elite Bodybuilder

Posts: 883
From:wa
Registered: Sep 2000

posted December 15, 2000 04:43 PM

Staff Use Only: IP: Logged


quote:
Originally posted by Stallion215:
Your right guys it hasnt done much. the first 2 weeks i only gained 3 pounds and put 10 pounds on my bench and 20 on my squat. i will try somethin else.

oh my god!! aaaaarrrrgh, I am so tired of people saying that they "gained 10lbs on thier bench or 20lbs on there squat" especially in relation to a supplement, "I only... HMB sucks." or "I gained... andro rules!" gimme a break, I feel like I'm looking at a muscle-tech ad every time I hear something like that. a picture of Matt Duvall holding a container of Nitro-tech with a big old shit-eating grin. I'd probably puke if I ever looked through another Muscle Rag.

I swear it's nothing personal agaist you Stallion, just I grow very weary of statements like that

p.s. nothing personal.

------------------

quote:
You cannot be a champion just by eating the best foods, you cannot be a champion just by training the most, and you cannot be a champion by taking the most or the best steroids and drugs. The most important attribute you need to be a champion is attitude -Franco Columbu


Click Here to See the Profile for Valdez   Click Here to Email Valdez     Edit/Delete Message      Reply w/Quote
mightydog

Elite Bodybuilder

Posts: 1207
From:
Registered: May 2000

posted December 15, 2000 05:18 PM

Staff Use Only: IP: Logged


Oooo, do you mean Bill Phillips lied?!?


Click Here to See the Profile for mightydog   Click Here to Email mightydog     Edit/Delete Message      Reply w/Quote
riskybiz007

Pro Bodybuilder

Posts: 464
From:CA, usa
Registered: Jun 2000

posted December 16, 2000 01:19 PM

Staff Use Only: IP: Logged


bro no offense to you but you're an idiot spending 90some dollars on HMB which is proven not to do shit! spend money more wisely on shit that actually works...


Click Here to See the Profile for riskybiz007   Click Here to Email riskybiz007     Edit/Delete Message      Reply w/Quote
Vitaman

Elite Bodybuilder

Posts: 939
From:The Key Stone State
Registered: Apr 2000

posted December 18, 2000 07:16 AM

Staff Use Only: IP: Logged


This Months Issue of Muscle and Fitness examines HMB from various studies. Basically it looks good.


Click Here to See the Profile for Vitaman   Click Here to Email Vitaman     Edit/Delete Message    UIN: 77744808   Reply w/Quote
natch

Novice

Posts: 9
From:
Registered: Nov 2000

posted December 18, 2000 01:44 PM

Staff Use Only: IP: Logged


Yeah, so did dibencozide, boron, OKG and smilax back in the day...

Bullsh*t hype is just that and Bill Phillips did lie, HMB does not "feel like deca".

Plain leucine is just as effective in my opinion and the needed dosages to see a result (still marginal) much, much lower.

HMB is not worth the money. Not at all.

Invest in a good whey powder, some flax oil and a solid multiple vitamin and you'll get much more than from HMB.

Heck, for $90 you could add tons of other great stuff to the list and still get some change back...


Click Here to See the Profile for natch     Edit/Delete Message      Reply w/Quote
kid

Cool Novice

Posts: 35
From:burlington,ma 01803
Registered: Nov 2000

posted December 18, 2000 07:56 PM

Staff Use Only: IP: Logged


i would not waste your money on any supplement out there except the necessities: protien powder, meal replacments, vitamins, glutamine, etc. the only supplement i would recommend is the zebutol. try to buy it from a store and not over the internet.


Click Here to See the Profile for kid     Edit/Delete Message      Reply w/Quote
Sniperwolf

Cool Novice

Posts: 46
From:Tokyo, Japan
Registered: Dec 2000

posted December 18, 2000 09:24 PM

Staff Use Only: IP: Logged


I've heard this stuff is no good too, but after I finished this stuff I was looking the biggest I've ever looked. It may have just been a coincidence or just psychological but as a result I'm willing to give it another try again.


Click Here to See the Profile for Sniperwolf   Click Here to Email Sniperwolf     Edit/Delete Message      Reply w/Quote
BarbarianHorde

Amateur Bodybuilder

Posts: 77
From:Syd, NSW, Australia
Registered: Dec 2000

posted December 19, 2000 07:29 PM

Staff Use Only: IP: Logged


lay off, it feels like Deca!
well, kinda like it.
well, looking at a vial of it.
well, thinking about looking at a vial of it...

(actually, all it does is cause a medium to severe weight loss from the hip pocket area. very effective for wallet spot-reduction)

------------------

You can't scuplt a pebble...


Click Here to See the Profile for BarbarianHorde   Click Here to Email BarbarianHorde     Edit/Delete Message      Reply w/Quote
riskybiz007

Pro Bodybuilder

Posts: 464
From:CA, usa
Registered: Jun 2000

posted December 19, 2000 09:26 PM

Staff Use Only: IP: Logged


bro i agree with you 100%
fuck these morons who say It feels like Deca, or how they can consider any of their products even close to deca or d-bol or any other stuff. I've used my fair share of their products, it never felt like deca or d-bol.


Click Here to See the Profile for riskybiz007   Click Here to Email riskybiz007     Edit/Delete Message      Reply w/Quote
Sniperwolf

Cool Novice

Posts: 46
From:Tokyo, Japan
Registered: Dec 2000

posted December 19, 2000 09:26 PM

Staff Use Only: IP: Logged


Natch what are you talking about Bill Phillips is the most honest man in bodybuilding.


Click Here to See the Profile for Sniperwolf   Click Here to Email Sniperwolf     Edit/Delete Message      Reply w/Quote
Wanabebig

Amateur Bodybuilder

Posts: 60
From:
Registered: Dec 2000

posted December 23, 2000 02:16 AM

Staff Use Only: IP: Logged


I feel the opposite HMB works well, but it is a slow working supp, instead of 3 steps forward and 2 steps back its 2 forward 1 back. There are also several university studies backing it


Click Here to See the Profile for Wanabebig     Edit/Delete Message      Reply w/Quote
BSmooth

Amateur Bodybuilder

Posts: 56
From:New Jersey
Registered: Dec 2000

posted December 30, 2000 12:32 PM

Staff Use Only: IP: Logged


Any gains from taking HMB are marginal. The last study I read had two groups of people work out for 3 months. After 3 months the HMB group had gained more lean mass, but it was something like only a 5% increase.


Click Here to See the Profile for BSmooth   Click Here to Email BSmooth     Edit/Delete Message      Reply w/Quote
BackDoc

Pro Bodybuilder

Posts: 349
From:
Registered: Feb 2000

posted December 30, 2000 11:04 PM

Staff Use Only: IP: Logged


The university studies showing HMB to be highly effective were funded by the supplement companies. I used to be a lab rat for a research professor at a medium to large sized upper eschelon school. Even with the school based funding for research, he still had to go out into the marketplace to get funding. There's no secret to this.

Here's something you and I can do to 'prove' or disprove the effectiveness of a supplement:
--find a medical researcher who is willing to do a project not for peer-reviewed publication. Give this doctor 25,000 dollars to do a simple (volunteers only) research on the supplement of your choice. Then tell this man that you will give him an additional 25,000 upon completion of a positive results-based conclusion...the final money for his use as he sees fit (basically payoff money). Many of them will outright refuse on the basics of ethics. Some of them might be afraid of the legal angle. Some of them will do the research just to get more funding. That's just about it.

HMB may have passed the university study showing it to be effective for a large majority of the focus group, but there are too many real world people who have gambled and lost using this supplement.

If you know that it works for you, then I commend you and I am somewhat jealous. If you've never tried it, I'd have to say save your money until more "University studies" have backed the original one.


Click Here to See the Profile for BackDoc     Edit/Delete Message      Reply w/Quote
fourhundred

Amateur Bodybuilder

Posts: 152
From:izmir,turkey
Registered: Apr 2000

posted January 02, 2001 01:53 PM

Staff Use Only: IP: Logged


I DO NOT HEAR GOOD NEWS ABOUT IT FROM WWW.TESTOSTERONE.NET
I DID NOT GAIN VISIBLE RESULTS ALSO FROM HMB(3GRAMS A DAY)


Click Here to See the Profile for fourhundred   Click Here to Email fourhundred     Edit/Delete Message    UIN: 65202996   Reply w/Quote
Promet1

Novice

Posts: 1
From:Naperville,IL
Registered: Jan 2001

posted January 02, 2001 05:32 PM

Staff Use Only: IP: Logged


I've taken Hmb for about 3 weeks make no
gains the first week but made nice moves
on all lifts the second and third weeks
... the eas rep at a show i was at
told me Hmb would be as hott of a seller
as creatine if it show gains faster
the best gains are made after six weeks
I bought two bottles when I started
I plan on going 8 weeks
I'll keep in touch


Click Here to See the Profile for Promet1   Click Here to Email Promet1     Edit/Delete Message      Reply w/Quote

All times are ET (US)

Post New Topic  
Hop to:

Contact Us | Back to Elite Fitness | Privacy Statement

Powered by Infopop www.infopop.com © 2000
Ultimate Bulletin Board 5.45c



HomeArticlesDiscussion BoardsFeatured SitesContact Us� ReportsSupplementsShopping