Please Scroll Down to See Forums Below
napsgear
genezapharmateuticals
domestic-supply
puritysourcelabs
UGL OZ
UGFREAK
napsgeargenezapharmateuticals domestic-supplypuritysourcelabsUGL OZUGFREAK

Top 10 Franchise Quarterbacks

glad to see Quinn on there,imo one of the best Qb's at the moment either in NFL or NCAA,he should be heismann
 
what about peyton? that sucks
 
hamstershaver said:
what a fucking joke of a list
Click to expand...

I couldn't agree more. Yeah Brady Quinn shouldn't even be on the list. Where the hell is Payton Manning, Brett Favre (on his way out, but still) and Joey Harrington. :biggrin: Kidding of course on Harrington as well all know Garcia is now our starter. Another shit head if you ask me.

This is the biggest bullshit list I have seen out of those guys. I have met many of the SI web journalists as we do alot of advertising with them. They never have an answer as to how they rationalize the rankings when they do a bullshit list like this.
 
LOL at the back up for Atlanta, Matt Schaub, almost being as high as Michael Vick. Sure Vick cannot pass THAT well but he sure can make up for it running.
 
seriously the worst sports list i've ever seen
 
I'm actually laughing at the Quinn selection because he's included in a list where the other nominees are in the NFL.

Because Ryan Leaf was amazing in the NFL, just as he was in college. Let's not forget about Heath Shuler, Andre Ware, David Klingler and Rick Mirer.

VICK? VIIICK?? I'm sick to my stomach. What happens when Vick's legs no longer have juice and he still has failed to develop into a true passing quarterback? Atlanta's offense is based around the run. He is not proven. What a joke. Cite to me 1 game where Vick's arm got them out of a jam. Those site even admits he's good for selling tickets. Cool.

Schaub. Wow. He throws for 1 monster game and now he's the future of the world.

I love how they rank potential QB's with proven ones. Sports Illustrated is printed for golf playing CEO's who know nothing about real football.

Shit, they should have thrown Alex Smith in there too. He's been playing very well.
 
swole said:
I'm actually laughing at the Quinn selection because he's included in a list where the other nominees are in the NFL.

Because Ryan Leaf was amazing in the NFL, just as he was in college. Let's not forget about Heath Shuler, Andre Ware, David Klingler and Rick Mirer.

VICK? VIIICK?? I'm sick to my stomach. What happens when Vick's legs no longer have juice and he still has failed to develop into a true passing quarterback? Atlanta's offense is based around the run. He is not proven. What a joke. Cite to me 1 game where Vick's arm got them out of a jam. Those site even admits he's good for selling tickets. Cool.

Schaub. Wow. He throws for 1 monster game and now he's the future of the world.

I love how they rank potential QB's with proven ones. Sports Illustrated is printed for golf playing CEO's who know nothing about real football.

Shit, they should have thrown Alex Smith in there too. He's been playing very well.
Click to expand...


yeah but Vick will be a non proven passer with at least 1 more super bowl ring more than Marino
 
swole said:
I'm actually laughing at the Quinn selection because he's included in a list where the other nominees are in the NFL.

Because Ryan Leaf was amazing in the NFL, just as he was in college. Let's not forget about Heath Shuler, Andre Ware, David Klingler and Rick Mirer.

VICK? VIIICK?? I'm sick to my stomach. What happens when Vick's legs no longer have juice and he still has failed to develop into a true passing quarterback? Atlanta's offense is based around the run. He is not proven. What a joke. Cite to me 1 game where Vick's arm got them out of a jam. Those site even admits he's good for selling tickets. Cool.

Schaub. Wow. He throws for 1 monster game and now he's the future of the world.

I love how they rank potential QB's with proven ones. Sports Illustrated is printed for golf playing CEO's who know nothing about real football.

Shit, they should have thrown Alex Smith in there too. He's been playing very well.
Click to expand...

a bigger joke is that quinn is on there but they leave off leinart and young
 
rudeboyja said:
yeah but Vick will be a non proven passer with at least 1 more super bowl ring more than Marino
Click to expand...

Whatsa u point?

Dawg, let me know when Vick breaks any sort of QB passing record.

Using your logic, Trent Dilfer is/was a better quarterback than Dan Marino because he won a Super Bowl. Rings are not accurate measures of QB greatness.
 
What makes you so sure Vick will ever win a championship? Everyone was so sure Marino was going to win several when he was a young QB. It of course never happened. And a list of the best franchise QBs without the QB who broke the record for most TDs, is current MVP, and who's team has the best record in the NFL just shows how little these "experts" actually know. This list reek's of bias.
 
Ok I actually read the original article and it says Peyton's too old to be on the list since he's 30. I'd still have to disagree as he's not that much older than Mcnabb and Brady and still has 8 or so years left in him.
 
JonPee said:
What makes you so sure Vick will ever win a championship? Everyone was so sure Marino was going to win several when he was a young QB. It of course never happened. And a list of the best franchise QBs without the QB who broke the record for most TDs, is current MVP, and who's team has the best record in the NFL just shows how little these "experts" actually know. This list reek's of bias.
Click to expand...
dan marinos career, no matter how many passing records he broke, or any other records, wasnt complete without that superbowl ring
:(
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

PICK3
Mock NFL Draft has 4 L.S.U. Tigers going in the 1st round!
Replies
2
Views
725
gotmilk
gotmilk
Lestat
here is the weekly recape I wrote for my fantasy football league
Replies
12
Views
2K
Phaded
P
FreakMonster
College Football Sucks!!!!!!!!!!
Replies
16
Views
3K
prophet
P
Top Bottom