Please Scroll Down to See Forums Below
NFL Fans - need your opinion
- Thread starter big dog
- Start date
DownUnder23
New member
Holmes without a doubt
DownUnder23
New member
check out his scoring production for the season and he missed the last 2 games
PsychoSkitz
New member
Faulk AND Holmes. Flip a coin.
DownUnder23
New member
You asked who we thought the best rb was ...not who had the best line.......holmes did win the nfl best rb award 
the others are very good also.....i think he is the best overall back though rushing and receiving
ricky williams cant catch a fucking cold...but a great power rusher
ahmad green fumbles a lot..overall one of the best
faulk off-year for him
Tomlinson very impressive year
mccalister proved he is a nfl back
the others are very good also.....i think he is the best overall back though rushing and receiving
ricky williams cant catch a fucking cold...but a great power rusher
ahmad green fumbles a lot..overall one of the best
faulk off-year for him
Tomlinson very impressive year
mccalister proved he is a nfl back
big dog
New member
Faulk, was my choice also, with Holmes 3rd...
Dillion definately deserves consideration, too bad he is on a shitty team.
EJ, no way, not right now..he isnt the half the RB was before the injury.
Ricky cant catch a cold??? About as far from the truth as can be...Jim Haslett began this propaganda..I live in NO and have watch him..He has EXCELLENT hands out the backfield, but does have fumbling problems..check his receiving stats and compare them to others..you will be very surprised.
Dillion definately deserves consideration, too bad he is on a shitty team.
EJ, no way, not right now..he isnt the half the RB was before the injury.
Ricky cant catch a cold??? About as far from the truth as can be...Jim Haslett began this propaganda..I live in NO and have watch him..He has EXCELLENT hands out the backfield, but does have fumbling problems..check his receiving stats and compare them to others..you will be very surprised.
u4ik_RAGE
New member
EJ was out most of this season, unfortunately. On this season's merits he's not even on the top 30 list, but if he get back to old form, he's in the top 4.
Faulk is in his own world. He's mentioned that he's always looking at the 2nd and 3rd defenders when he's got the ball, because he knows the 1st guy is always going to miss. You watch him run and it happens play after play a lot like Emmitt used to do.
Faulk is in his own world. He's mentioned that he's always looking at the 2nd and 3rd defenders when he's got the ball, because he knows the 1st guy is always going to miss. You watch him run and it happens play after play a lot like Emmitt used to do.
PsychoSkitz
New member
Don't forget a healthy Fred Taylor, bitches
K
KAYNE
Guest
DEUCE SHOULDNT EVEN BE ON THAT LIST. PREIST IS THE BEST. RICKY WILL BE IN 2 YEARS.
KAYNE
KAYNE
u4ik_RAGE
New member
big dog said:
The same can be said about Curtis Martin, Charlie Garner, Travis Henry, Tiki Barber (up to late December apparently), and a few other guys.
Since we're talking RBs, I think one of the craziest things is how Fred Taylor will get stuffed 4 or 5 straight playsand then break a 70 yarder. He seems to do it everytime I watch J-Ville play.
big dog
New member
Yeah, Deuce has alot to prove still...but has a super scary size/speed ratio..he needs to stay out of the hooters on Vets or hell get too fat.
I think RW will be the most dominant RB in the league for the next 3 years....The last 8 game of this year he was fucking unstoppable....
he looked like jim brown..
I think RW will be the most dominant RB in the league for the next 3 years....The last 8 game of this year he was fucking unstoppable....
he looked like jim brown..
slickdadd
New member
Keep in mind, more often than not, the RB makes the Offensive Line, not the other way around. Regardless of your O Line, if the RB doesn't hit the holes, break tackles and make people miss, it doesn't matter. The O-Line only gets the RB started.
With that said, the past two years, Holmes has been the best. Without a doubt. Scoring machine. Receiving, running, the whole nine yards.
Now Ricky came to the dolphins with the exact same line they had the previous years and turned in almost a 2000 yard season. It's hard to argue with that. And anyone who says he can't catch is ignorant and hasn't even watched him play. He played a big role in the receiving game this year. More than a lot of those other guys you mentioned.
So those are the two best in my opinion. Faulk is more of a receiver that plays RB in a great system, or a past great system. He is good, but give it to him 25-30 times like Holmes and Williams and he won't produce the same.
McCallister and Tomlinson are good, but not THAT good just yet.
With that said, the past two years, Holmes has been the best. Without a doubt. Scoring machine. Receiving, running, the whole nine yards.
Now Ricky came to the dolphins with the exact same line they had the previous years and turned in almost a 2000 yard season. It's hard to argue with that. And anyone who says he can't catch is ignorant and hasn't even watched him play. He played a big role in the receiving game this year. More than a lot of those other guys you mentioned.
So those are the two best in my opinion. Faulk is more of a receiver that plays RB in a great system, or a past great system. He is good, but give it to him 25-30 times like Holmes and Williams and he won't produce the same.
McCallister and Tomlinson are good, but not THAT good just yet.
FAULK
Similar threads
- Sticky
