Billy the kid VS Doc Holiday

[_Outlaw]

Billy the kid VS John (Doc) Holiday...Who do you guys think would win?

My vote goes with the Kid.....

 

[_Outlaw]

bump

 

[sh4dowf4lcon]

Doc Holliday would win.

I'm your huckleberry...

Say When...

 

[Becoming]

Doc- I think reports on the kid were more exaggerated... I heard he was borderline mentally retarded.... for real...

 

[argent]

Holliday would roll The Kid

I heard something similar about the Kid being MR or something.

 

[hardrock]

Why do you think they had Emilio Estevez play him in Young Guns.

Doc would whoop him.

 

[Becoming]

hmmm. this has not turned into much of a debate after all....

 

[The Ranger]

Actually Billy the Kid was not a gunslinger per sey, he got caught up in the Lincoln county war between english and irish merchants...Most of the people he killed were not in shoot outs but shoot from cover or concelment...

Doc is a different story all together, he was a man that had no reason to live, and he exemplified that fact in every aspect of life....

Of all the western gunfighters, King Fisher, Bill Thompson and Bill Hickcok were amoung the best...

Ranger

 

[fistfullofsteel]

Doc played by Val Kilmer, "I'll put you out of your misery. Say when."

"Come on Johnny, Come on, you ain't no daisy, you ain't no daisy at all."

 

[louden_swain]

John Wayne

 

[sh4dowf4lcon]

John Wayne

See there...Swain, Wayne isn't in the question...

I say Doc over Billy the Kid...in a close one!